***PLAYER RATINGS*** vs Charlton

[One Teddy Maybank]

Stockdale - 5 - yet to make a save. Dynamite with his feet, but should have been sharper on the second goal. Wonder if Kuszcz would have saved the first.....
Bruno - 6 - ok
Bennett - 4 - Had an absolute stinker, culminating his part in their second with JFC
Greer - 6 - turned too easily on the second
Dunk - 8 - largely because of the goals he scored
Holla - 6 - ok
JFC - 5 - some good passes, some bad, but what was he doing on the second with Bennett? Stupid booking
Crofts - 5 -
Tex - 6 - some brilliant things, some very ordinary
Corluga - 6 - great first half, tired second
CMS - 5 - poor performance, against two big defenders, made good runs, but poor control quite often, great swivel and shot in 2nd half.

Gardner - 6 - ok
KLL - 6 - great cross for the second
Baldock - 6 - barely in the game, but tried


Hyypia/Jones - really poor that they didn't demand that Holla took the free kick near the end.

Ref - just a t**t. Pointed to his watch re time-wasting in the 25th minute, and preceded to do nothing.....

 

[Tory Boy]

Stockdale - 5 - yet to make a save. Dynamite with his feet, but should have been sharper on the second goal. Wonder if Kuszcz would have saved the first.....

Pretty sure I could have saved the first.

TB

 

[Albumen]

Jesus, harsh scores there.

 

[Bladders]

Jesus, harsh scores there.

Agreed, anyone not at the game would think we were rubbish

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

Pretty sure I could have saved the first.

TB

Just wonder if he was unsighted, when I watched the replay it seemed to come through a 'sea of legs'.

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

Agreed, anyone not at the game would think we were rubbish

Thought we were in the second half..... Hardly created anything. Two goals from set pieces, CMS swivel..... anything else, Bennett lashing it into the side netting, not particularly great.

 

[Marshy]

Stockdale 6
Bruno 6
Dunk 8
Greer 7
Bennett 7

JFC 7
Holla 6
Crofts 5

Tex 8
Colunga 7
CMS 6

 

[Barnham Seagull]

Stockdale - 5

Bruno - 6
Bennett - 6
Greer - 6
Dunk - 7.5

Holla - 6.5
JFC - 5
Crofts - 5

Tex - 7
Corluga - 5
CMS - 5

Gardner - 6
KLL - 6
Baldock - Not on long enough

 

[Napier's Knee]

Stockdale 6
Bruno 6
Dunk 8
Greer 7
Bennett 7

JFC 7
Holla 6
Crofts 5

Tex 8
Colunga 7
CMS 6

Switch the Holla and JFC marks and agreed. Baldock was making some excellent off the ball runs when he came on. Tex is clearly different class but maybe a tendency to showboat when he tires? Crofts does not fit in the system. A great match and all is looking very promising

 

[nwgull]

Stockdale 3 - didn't touch the ball apart from a few pass backs. 2 shots; 2 goals.
Bennet 5 - crap final ball
Dunk 9 - outstanding even without the goals.
Greer 7 - solid. Helped restrict them to 2 dangerous shots.
Bruno 7 - see Greer plus got into their box a few times.
Holla 8 - reason we were so dominant in midfield and nearly always won the ball back quickly.
JFC 6 - did ok, took an early yellow for the team.
Crofts 6 - did nothin wrong but didn't really feature for me.
Tex 8 - 9 in first half; 7 in second.
Columga 6 - am I being harsh in saying that he should've scored from 6 yards?
CMS 6 - lively and almost scored but otherwise outmuscled.

Gardner 6
KLL 7 - ran at defenders and assisted the equaliser. One comedy shot that went for a throw in!
Baldock 5 - did he touch the ball in 15 mins?

NWGull 10 - left at full time whistle, got on first train to Brighton, ran across Victoria and Euston concourses and escalators and managed to get on 6-40 train to manchester.

 

[Biscuit]

Wow. All about opinions I guess but I couldn't disagree more with some of your scores.

Bennett 4? Did you not see him getting up and involved? Won some crucial headers and constantly offered width or an option .. A very solid display indeed,

Tex a 6? He was our main man, almost every attack went through him and his footwork was sublime! As was his movement, passing.. He seemed to be everywhere at once! He tired towards the end but that was hardly surprising.

 

[bhawoddy]

Stockdale 5 not much to do other than pick the ball out of the net twice.
Bruno 5 didn't get forward until the last 10 mins when both full backs pushed on.
Bennett 6 similar to Bruno but this lad is a good left back and will be a real asset to us
Greer 5 seemed to dive in on vetokele when standing his ground would have been a better option. Steady generally.
Dunk 9 this is what I call development. Probably one of the best performances I've seen from a bha centre back for a long time.
Holla 7 seems like an excellent addition and showed again that he's a decent player in the holding role
Crofts 4 I like crofts attitude but I'm not sure how many more games he will be used in the starting 11.
Texeira 8 real quality, and tried hard to get us playing. Seemed to have to drop extremely deep to get the ball 2nd half.
JFC 5 misplaced passes when well placed late on. Hoping his game improves with much better quality around him.
Colunga 7 looked dangerous and had good vision. Tired late on.
CMS 5 tries so hard but not sure if he can deliver the goals we need this year.

Gardner 5
Lua lua 6
Baldock no mark... Not enough time

 

[BensGrandad]

Stockdale 5

Bruno 6
Greer 7
Dunk 9
Bennett 7

Holla 7

Crofts 6
JFC 6
Teixeira 8

Corlunga 6

CMS 6

Subs
Gardner 6
Lua Lua 6
Baldock 6

 

[Mayonaise]

Switch the Holla and JFC marks and agreed. Baldock was making some excellent off the ball runs when he came on. Tex is clearly different class but maybe a tendency to showboat when he tires? Crofts does not fit in the system. A great match and all is looking very promising

Agree with this...

 

[SweatyMexican]

Stockdale 5.5 - Probably could have done better with the first.

Bruno 6 - Reasonable game

Dunk 9 - All round play, and then his 2 goals count for a few points.

Greer 7 - Good passing, headed well when he needed to.

Bennett 6.5 - Expected a bit more, but didn't really happen for him today.

JFC 6.5 - Had a reasonably okay game, but nothing of note I can think of.

Holla 7 - Kept the midfield ticking on, and made some nice passes at time. I think Holla was a decent signing.

Crofts 7 - Battled really well, and a nice tackle in the first half to set us on the counter.

Tex 6.5 - A few nice interchanges, but didn't produce anything deadly.

Colunga 6.5 - A few nice interchanges, and should have done better with his 1 on 1 opportunity when it was 1-1, and he tried to pass it across.

CMS 6.5 - Tried to get into the game, but couldn't, really.

 

[dingodan]

Stockdale - 5 - Okay game, but made some errors for the first goal.
Bruno - 7 - Had a good game. Composed, good passing.
Bennett - 6 - Had an decent game, available for a pass, good control.
Greer - 6 - Could have done better for the 2nd goal, otherwise played well.
Dunk - 8 - MOM Played well, scored two, always very composed on the ball.
Holla - 7 - Did well in an otherwise weak midfield.
JFC - 5 - Not a good game today, gave away possession too much.
Crofts - 5 - Not a great game for him, not composed enough, some poor decisions.
Tex - 8 - Very good at times, maybe a little over complicated some times, not his day today but played pretty well even so.
Corluga - 7 - Looked good. Hungry & some nice passing.
CMS - 6 - Didn't get the kind of service he can work with, worked hard, wasn't strong enough at times for me.

Gardner - 7 - Came on, did Okay.
KLL - 7 - Came on, did what he does, good assist.
Baldock - Unfair to score him today, not enough time.

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

Wow. All about opinions I guess but I couldn't disagree more with some of your scores.

Bennett 4? Did you not see him getting up and involved? Won some crucial headers and constantly offered width or an option .. A very solid display indeed,

Tex a 6? He was our main man, almost every attack went through him and his footwork was sublime! As was his movement, passing.. He seemed to be everywhere at once! He tired towards the end but that was hardly surprising.

Re - Bennett - saw him waste possession on numerous occasions in the second half, mess up badly (with other on the second), just had an off-day for me.

Tex as per my comment some good, some bad....

As you say all opinions

 

[HantsSeagull]

stockdale 6 - thought he was poor on first goal - not made a save yet
bruno 6 - thoiught calde should have played
greer 7 - poor second goal
dunk 9 - great
bennett 7
holla 8
jfc 5 - adds nothing
crofts 6
teixeira 8 - quality
cms 6 - poor
colunga 7 - thought he looked good

gardner 7 - better than jfc
baldock? not long enough
lua lua - 7

 

[Bladders]

Bennet was far more effective on the left than Bruno on the right.

 

[Bladders]

stockdale 6 - thought he was poor on first goal - not made a save yet
bruno 6 - thoiught calde should have played
greer 7 - poor second goal
dunk 9 - great
bennett 7
holla 8
jfc 5 - adds nothing
crofts 6
teixeira 8 - quality
cms 6 - poor
colunga 7 - thought he looked good

gardner 7 - better than jfc
baldock? not long enough
lua lua - 7

Spot on for me