[Albion] Player ratings v Palace (h) - FA Cup

[Hammer15]

I don't put cup scores into the spreadsheet, so these ratings are just for fun. I'll join in today...

Krul 6
Schelotto 7
Hunemeier 7
Goldson 6
Bong 6
March 7
Kayal 8, MOM
Stephens 7.5
Izquierdo 7
Brown n/a
Hemed 6

Baldock 7
Propper 6
Murray 7

 

[RM-Taylor]

Schelotto, Kayal, Stephens and Baldock were the outstanding players.
March is so inconsistent, in and out of the game, good in the final 10 mins or so.
Krul had nothing to do except collect the ball out the back of the net from a great strike by Sako.
Uwe was better than Goldson

 

[djentist]

Krul 7

Schelotto 7
Hunemeier 7
Goldson 6
Bong 6

March 7
Kayal 8
Stephens 8
Izquierdo 7

Brown n/a

Hemed 6

Baldock 7
Propper 6
Murray 7

Pretty similar to yours, I don't do half ratings though so rounded the Stephens one up

 

[British Bulldog]

I don't put cup scores into the spreadsheet, so these ratings are just for fun. I'll join in today...

Krul 6
Schelotto 7
Hunemeier 7
Goldson 6
Bong 6
March 7
Kayal 8, MOM
Stephens 7.5
Izquierdo 7
Brown n/a
Hemed 6

Baldock 7
Propper 6
Murray 7

Agree with that apart from March who I'd just give a 6

 

[Bodian]

Schelotto, Kayal, Stephens and Baldock were the outstanding players.
March is so inconsistent, in and out of the game, good in the final 10 mins or so.
Krul had nothing to do except collect the ball out the back of the net from a great strike by Sako.
Uwe was better than Goldson

Not tall enough??

 

[Bald Gull]

Not tall enough??

Too tall - couldn't get down quick enough to the shot...

 

[Sarisbury Seagull]

Krul - 6

Schellotto - 8
Goldson - 6
Uwe - 7
Bong - 6

March - 6
Stephens - 7
Kayal - 9 - MOM
Jose - 7

Baldock - 7
Hemed - 6

 

[Paris]

Not tall enough??

Small hands.

 

[Bladders]

Is March getting a 7 for the chipped free kick for the 2nd goal?

Cause that was about all he did all game


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Sheebo]

Everyone marking Bong too low imo. Thought he was very good tonight...

 

[Petee]

Krul 6

Schelotto 6.5
Goldson 7
Hunemeier 7
Bong 7.5

March 7
Stephens 6.5
Kayal 7.5
Izquierdo 7

Brown N/A

Hemed 7

Baldock 7
Propper 6
Murray 10 - Anything less is wrong.

 

[sllugaes]

Everyone marking Bong too low imo. Thought he was very good tonight...

Agree - Blinkered as usual.

Sent from my Zxt 203 Dci

 

[loco61]

kayal 8.5

Sent from my SM-A510F using Tapatalk

 

[big nuts]

Krul - 6
Stiletto - 6
Bong - 7
Goodson - 6
Hunemeier - 7
Stephens - 8
Kayal - 9
March - 6
Izquierdo - 6
Hemed - 6
Brown na

Baldock - 7
Propper - 5
Murray - 8

 

[Nobby]

Agree - Blinkered as usual.

Sent from my Zxt 203 Dci

Bong always good - much better than Suttner


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[dazzer6666]

Krul - 6
Stiletto - 6
Bong - 7
Goodson - 6
Hunemeier - 7
Stephens - 8
Kayal - 9
March - 6
Izquierdo - 6
Hemed - 6
Brown na

Baldock - 7
Propper - 5
Murray - 8

This looks about right to me, possibly a bit generous for March who was stinking the place out in the first half.

When MOM was announced a loud voice just behind us said ‘Kayal ? He’s been shit all game’..........

 

[Algernon]

History will show that in 2018 BHA knocked Crystal Phallus out of the FA Cup.
No matter the circumstances, It means we can remind them of this for years to come.
I reckon that alone is worth an extra point (at least) on each rating surely.

 

[Biscuit Barrel]

Is March getting a 7 for the chipped free kick for the 2nd goal?

Cause that was about all he did all game


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

He put it on a plate for Kayal to blast over the bar. He put it on a plate for Hemed to head straight at the keeper.

 

[Harry Wilson's tackle]

How many points did Conroy Goldstone get?

 

[drew]

He put it on a plate for Kayal to blast over the bar. He put it on a plate for Hemed to head straight at the keeper.

Did that after retrieving a ball that everyone thought was going out. However, the rest of his game was very poor/inconsistent.