[Albion] Player ratings v Leicester

[SeagullinExile]

I agree with the sentiments expressed by most on here.

One point: not sure what Lamptey has to do to get a 10, but no one has given him one. I'm always reluctant to give a maximum as there's always something that takes that little bit of sheen off a performance - in Lamptey's case though, I genuinely can't think of a single thing he did where I even gently shook my head for a second. On that basis, it seems churlish to dock him a point; thus Little Gem: 10.

Clumsy challenge on Vardy leading to a free kick in a dangerous position. Went to ground when he shouldn't have.

 

[schmunk]

One point: not sure what Lamptey has to do to get a 10, but no one has given him one.

He's not getting a 10 from me until he runs between someone's legs. This needs to be his signature move.

 

[Goldstone1976]

Clumsy challenge on Vardy leading to a free kick in a dangerous position. Went to ground when he shouldn't have.

Ah yes. OK, I'll amend my score to a low '10' then.

 

[Goldstone1976]

He's not getting a 10 from me until he runs between someone's legs. This needs to be his signature move.

B'stard. I have to wipe the tea off my laptop keyboard now.

 

[Machiavelli]

I agree with the sentiments expressed by most on here.

One point: not sure what Lamptey has to do to get a 10, but no one has given him one. I'm always reluctant to give a maximum as there's always something that takes that little bit of sheen off a performance - in Lamptey's case though, I genuinely can't think of a single thing he did where I even gently shook my head for a second. On that basis, it seems churlish to dock him a point; thus Little Gem: 10.

Assists? Pre-assists? 'Key passes'? Goals? Goal-saving challenges?
I've rarely given anyone a 10 (but it has happened). That said, I'm nowhere near as generous as you are

 

[Machiavelli]

He's not getting a 10 from me until he runs between someone's legs. This needs to be his signature move.

Another of NSC's finer comments

 

[Goldstone1976]

Assists? Pre-assists? 'Key passes'? Goals? Goal-saving challenges?
I've rarely given anyone a 10 (but it has happened). That said, I'm nowhere near as generous as you are

Four of the five things you proffer require at least one of the following two things: goals, and the opposition threatening to score. In a game absent of either, is it reasonable to mark an individual down because the other 21 (plus subs) players didn't play their part? I'd assert that you have to mark an individual's performance at least partially in the context of the game as whole. And, in that context, I'll stick with my 10

 

[SeagullinExile]

Ah yes. OK, I'll amend my score to a low '10' then.

Hehe. Tbf, that was the only obvious error i saw. I splendid debut from a promising young player.

 

[lawros left foot]

For the first time in ages, I can say there is a PL player shorter than me.

 

[lawros left foot]

Wrong thread

 

[aolstudios]

Ryan - 6
Lamptey - 8
Webster - 6
Dunk - 7
Burn - 7
Mooy - 6
Bissouma - 6
Stephens - 6
MacAllister - 6
Maupay - 6
Connolly - 7

Duffy - 6
Propper - 7
Trossard - 6
March - 5.5
Murray - 5