Mike Small
Well-known member
- Dec 26, 2008
- 2,975
Schelloto needs between 1-3 otherwise there is no need for these numbers as an option when rating.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Player ratings - from the telly
- Thread starter goldstone
- Start date
Albion Robster
Well-known member
Average - 5.
Ryan - 7. Some good saves to keep the score down. Could do nothing with any of the goals.
Schelotto - 4. Headless chicken comes to mind. Some hapless defending and passing. We missed Bruno’s composure.
Duffy - 5. Headed and blocked all afternoon. Some awful stray passes. Lucky to get away with penalty in first half. Typical Duffy performance.
Dunk - 6. Sightly better than Duffy. Unlucky with fourth goal.
Bong - 5. Awful positional sense all game. Let Solanke get goal side for his goal. Get the cheque book out for a new LB in the summer.
Stephens - 6. Calm and composed but the Liverpool midfielders pressed him hard all game. Tough day for the Albion CM.
Propper - 6. Same as Stephens. Managed to carry the ball out a couple of times.
Kayal - 5. Game just passed him by in the middle of the park. Don’t recall many passes or tackles made. Probably last appearance in an Albion shirt.
Knockaert - 6. Full of running and energy. Provided a wide outlet. Good battle against TAA.
March - 5. Was he even playing?! Went missing. Couldn’t make a cross all game. Another disappointing game from him.
Locadia - 4. Lazy and disinterested. Couldn’t be bothered to run the channels to provide an outlet. Seems to be carrying too much timber for me. Another Dutch Dud (Manu)? The jury is out!
Groß - 6. Better ball retention when he came on. Why was he dropped (rested)? He’s got the whole summer to rest up.
Murray - 5. Not great. Couldn’t pick a pass or make the ball stick.
Goldson - 5. Looked rusty, can’t blame him really. Tough game and score line to come into.
The Scouse Pie: 4. Utter slop! Reminded me of my school dinner.
Fans: 8. Loud and proud.
Ryan - 7. Some good saves to keep the score down. Could do nothing with any of the goals.
Schelotto - 4. Headless chicken comes to mind. Some hapless defending and passing. We missed Bruno’s composure.
Duffy - 5. Headed and blocked all afternoon. Some awful stray passes. Lucky to get away with penalty in first half. Typical Duffy performance.
Dunk - 6. Sightly better than Duffy. Unlucky with fourth goal.
Bong - 5. Awful positional sense all game. Let Solanke get goal side for his goal. Get the cheque book out for a new LB in the summer.
Stephens - 6. Calm and composed but the Liverpool midfielders pressed him hard all game. Tough day for the Albion CM.
Propper - 6. Same as Stephens. Managed to carry the ball out a couple of times.
Kayal - 5. Game just passed him by in the middle of the park. Don’t recall many passes or tackles made. Probably last appearance in an Albion shirt.
Knockaert - 6. Full of running and energy. Provided a wide outlet. Good battle against TAA.
March - 5. Was he even playing?! Went missing. Couldn’t make a cross all game. Another disappointing game from him.
Locadia - 4. Lazy and disinterested. Couldn’t be bothered to run the channels to provide an outlet. Seems to be carrying too much timber for me. Another Dutch Dud (Manu)? The jury is out!
Groß - 6. Better ball retention when he came on. Why was he dropped (rested)? He’s got the whole summer to rest up.
Murray - 5. Not great. Couldn’t pick a pass or make the ball stick.
Goldson - 5. Looked rusty, can’t blame him really. Tough game and score line to come into.
The Scouse Pie: 4. Utter slop! Reminded me of my school dinner.
Fans: 8. Loud and proud.
Weststander
Well-known member
You're generous. Is 4 your base for turning up?
Weststander
Well-known member
And left back?
Aveacarlin'
New member
- Jul 5, 2011
- 1,177
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
All too short and too slow.
Nixonator
Well-known member
I always think sub 4 rating is space to work into for truly abysmal performances. For instance if Schellotto had, in addition to his terrible performance today, smashed one into his own net then got sent off, a 1-3 could be applied.
Trelford Mills Guide Dog
Active member
- Jun 14, 2008
- 575
Matty Ryan my MoM by a country mile.
Just got home. We were really pretty crap, Liverpool could have had 6 or 7 easily. Good weekend away otherwise though.
Ryan - 8 - stopped us getting embarrassed
Bong - 5 - second poor game in a row
Dunk - 7 - wouldn’t be surprised if he’s in a red kit next time we play them
Duffy -7 - amazing goal line block, usual array of headers
Schelotto - 4 - awful
Stephens - 7, very poor for their first (I think) but otherwise carried us a bit
Kayal - 6 - tried hard but struggled
March - 4 - loads of mistakes, poor crosses when he had the chance, failed to run forward when we had the ball, completely ignored Lovren’s run for his header. Big, big disappointment this season
Propper - 6 - struggled to make any impression
Locadia - 5 - our tactics were daft, no point lumping the ball to him in the air when he has VVD to deal with. Feel a bit sorry for him....also had a couple of fantastic first touches. His workrate looks poor though.
Knockaert - 7 - one of the few that looked up for it
Murray - 6 - did ok, at least he got his head on a few
Goldson - 6 - looked rusty
Gross - 6
Ryan - 8 - stopped us getting embarrassed
Bong - 5 - second poor game in a row
Dunk - 7 - wouldn’t be surprised if he’s in a red kit next time we play them
Duffy -7 - amazing goal line block, usual array of headers
Schelotto - 4 - awful
Stephens - 7, very poor for their first (I think) but otherwise carried us a bit
Kayal - 6 - tried hard but struggled
March - 4 - loads of mistakes, poor crosses when he had the chance, failed to run forward when we had the ball, completely ignored Lovren’s run for his header. Big, big disappointment this season
Propper - 6 - struggled to make any impression
Locadia - 5 - our tactics were daft, no point lumping the ball to him in the air when he has VVD to deal with. Feel a bit sorry for him....also had a couple of fantastic first touches. His workrate looks poor though.
Knockaert - 7 - one of the few that looked up for it
Murray - 6 - did ok, at least he got his head on a few
Goldson - 6 - looked rusty
Gross - 6
Mo Gosfield
Well-known member
- Aug 11, 2010
- 6,362
4/10 is the accepted mark for ' poor '
So, on that basis.......
3/10....' very poor '
2/10....' abysmal '
1/10....' for putting his kit on the right way round and walking out the tunnel in a straight line '
- Apr 13, 2015
- 3,855
About sums it up for me... though I would have given March a lower score, he looked like a Sunday league player...... a hungover one at that.
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
- Apr 13, 2015
- 3,855
I think March may have just taken his fat Prem contract, stopped working hard and is coasting knowing that he has a shit load of cash in the bank..... I bet he has a 'footballers' sports car.... he just seems to have stopped trying.
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
Last I saw he had one of the most boring cars in the squad, an uninspiring Audi estate, whereas Bruno showing his class with a Porsche (Cayman I think)
Originunknown
BINFEST'ING
Ryan 8
Schelotto 2
Duffy 6
Dunk 7
Bong 3
March 2
Pröpper 6
Stephens 7
Knockaert 6
Kayal 3
Locadia 2
CH 4 - Why experiment against that type of opposition. We had no outlet, we were exposed down both wings and it could have been 7-0 by the time he changed anything.
Subs couldn't affect the game but no real mistakes, all 5.
Schelotto 2
Duffy 6
Dunk 7
Bong 3
March 2
Pröpper 6
Stephens 7
Knockaert 6
Kayal 3
Locadia 2
CH 4 - Why experiment against that type of opposition. We had no outlet, we were exposed down both wings and it could have been 7-0 by the time he changed anything.
Subs couldn't affect the game but no real mistakes, all 5.