schmunk
Why oh why oh why?
Got me thinking, so I checked Whoscored who bases their ratings on statistics (obviously doesnt tell it all or even enough for a fair grade, but still interesting) and they had Montoya at 7.0, only behind Ryan (7.5) and Burn (7.2).
In my opinion he got pretty bad end product but great movement and decision making along with underrated defensive qualities. Defiinitely understand why people are divided though, he is by no means perfect.
Sofascore fairly similar - Ryan top at 8.1, then Grob 7.3 and Montoya 7.2 - others below.