London Irish
Well-known member
Toad, feel free to list those mistakes and we'll have a debate about them, it will help us all to make an informed choice. As for my "number three", you'll have problems I feel hanging many of our goals conceded on him, but sure, give it a go.
The problem with promoting Hinsh is that all his mistakes have come in quick succession, the miskick for the crucial Derby goal, beaten by the ginger Cardiff guy for the killer second, McGhee blaming him for the first Plymouth goal, not strong enough to deal with Chadwick and then giving away a soft handball penalty for the second in that game.......
If we're debating player of the season we need the highest of standards and although Hinsh has done superbly in his first season as first choice, I just feel his overall performance doesn't quite rise to that meteoric level, young player of the season though certainly, he's done better than Harding, El Abd, etc.
The problem with promoting Hinsh is that all his mistakes have come in quick succession, the miskick for the crucial Derby goal, beaten by the ginger Cardiff guy for the killer second, McGhee blaming him for the first Plymouth goal, not strong enough to deal with Chadwick and then giving away a soft handball penalty for the second in that game.......
If we're debating player of the season we need the highest of standards and although Hinsh has done superbly in his first season as first choice, I just feel his overall performance doesn't quite rise to that meteoric level, young player of the season though certainly, he's done better than Harding, El Abd, etc.
Last edited: