Paul Mcshane would that please you?

[Richy_Seagull]

Was great here before but pretty sure he is not a 'Gus' type of player. Then again, I would have said the same thing about El-Abd before Gus worked his magic, so who knows!

 

[mona]

One of the most error-prone defenders in the Championship.

Well said, HM!!
No positional sense. Rated by people who only follow the ball when watching football. No football brain. Yes, I did say this when we had him on loan.

 

[Geriatric Seagull]

No. You have to ask why he hasn't really stopped anywhere for any length of time. Admittedly only based on what I've seen on television but he seems to make far too many mistakes and seems very headstrong - not a calm, measured defender.

 

[Ernest Newman]

Five years ago, maybe. But since he left us, he has only gotten worse. Bringing back old players never works, we just need to remember the happy memories of his Palace goal

 

[seagullsovergrimsby]

I thought this thread was about McShane not Hawkins.

 

[Discodoktor]

Hairy muff seems like most wouldn't want him. Could be uncomposed a bit headless. Felt we could turn him around. Who is worth buying then.

 

[B.W.]

Too small too...

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Five years ago, maybe. But since he left us, he has only gotten worse. Bringing back old players never works, we just need to remember the happy memories of his Palace goal

He was player of the season at West Brom when he left us. He may have gone downhill since then but it wasn't after our loan spell from Man Utd.

 

[Ernest Newman]

Trust me, I have friends who are WBA fans, and he was definitely not their player of the season.