Pevenseagull
meh
- Jul 20, 2003
- 20,666
Top pop fact
Sugarbabes went full 'Trigger's broom' then did a full reverse TB.
Sugarbabes went full 'Trigger's broom' then did a full reverse TB.
Can NSC settle a pub argument please
When is a band not a band?
Do Roger Daltrey and Pete Townsend represent a Who gig?
But if Paul and Ringo played with a backing band would you call that The Beatles?
Do only 2 of the original Stones still carry the same gravitas?
Can Mike Love and a stage of session musicians really call themselves The Beach Boys and charge £80 at the Brighton Centre?
Or is life too short, and everyone deserves to make a living?
Top pop fact
Sugarbabes went full 'Trigger's broom' then did a full reverse TB.
99% agree with you but then there is AC/DC
When van Day joined Nolan in Bucks Fizz, it was seamless.
On the other hand, from a personal point of view, I couldn't go and see Queen without Freddie Mercury and say I'd seen the real thing.
It's a good question. Years ago I saw Dr Feelgood without Wilko Johnson and was told by 'proper' Feelgood fans that I hadn't seen the real thing. I disagreed, but I sort-of understood as I saw the Stranglers with Hugh Cornwell, so I've seen the 'real' Stranglers. (I'm not sure what I'd think about seeing Feelgood now as they're still going without any of the original members!)
I don't think there is a hard and fast rule. I saw Lynyrd Skynyrd and Gary Rossington was the only surviving member from the 'classic' lineup, but yeah, I've seen Lynyrd Skynyrd. On the other hand, from a personal point of view, I couldn't go and see Queen without Freddie Mercury and say I'd seen the real thing.
When van Day joined Nolan in Bucks Fizz, it was seamless.
The Stranglers only have JJ left from the original line up, I’ve read that they are still very good but I’m glad I saw the band with the original line up a few times.
A letter in Viz once argued the case for Paul and Ringo to replace The Who's deceased rhythm section. To be renamed The Bho or The Whotles.
The Stones weren't quite the Stones after Brian Jones died. Mick Taylor kept them going for a bit longer. Never the same creative force once Ronnie Wood joined. Sadly a better artist than guitar player.
.
I have never listened to anything by Ruts DC, often listen to The Ruts though.