Objectivity Or Subjectivity When Talking About Albion Players?

[Race]

just saying , he has proved me wrong

fortunately for him hes always been very good at that

 

[Brighton Boy]

i think harding is class and Butters was player of the year last year

 

[Yorkie]

It depends if they have had a good game or a bad game.

 

[Brighton Boy]

It depends if they have had a good game or a bad game.

actually i agree with that

 

[Race]

It depends if they have had a good game or a bad game.

what depends on whether they have had a good game or not?

 

[Yorkie]

what depends on whether they have had a good game or not?

Talking about Albion players and being objective or subjective.

Some people are against a player full stop. Others are for a player full stop.

Some are more objective and say a player had a lousy game but it was loss of form etc not that he is 'rubbish'

 

[Hunting 784561]

I think some 'constructive' criticism of players can be a very good thing, as it seems to spur some of them on, Mrs Race's hubby is probably a good example, and I'm sure Big Mac has had a point to prove recently...

It should however never be done during a game , as it can kill a players confidence, on balance an club internet message board is probably the right forum.

 

[Franks Wild Years]

Objectivly : Butters for pope.

 

[Stinky Kat]

Yelldell is history.
Harding is a class player for his age and will go on to bigger and better things. Butters is a legend and will go down in Albion folklore.
McPhee was in the team to do as Virgo did up front and In my opinion did OK and as well as I expected.
Who ever plays being picked by Mr McGhee will get my 100% support because Mr McGhee knows a damn sight more then I will ever know.
Guy Butters for prime minister.

is yelldell history? Chris May played for Hastings on Saturday and Shabban has not signed yet. Yelldell can stay for 3 months and probably will. By the way I think he is not very good but clkap him and support him at games

 

[Yorkie]

Shaaban is signing today for the rest of the season and Roberts should be training again from this week.

 

[Schrödinger's Toad]

Harding - two games ago i would've agreed but hes starting to look much much stronger in defence , not 26th best player outside the premiership , but not as shit as everyone makes out he is

That's about the sum of it - neither as good as the hype, nor as bad as the moaners would have you believe. Certainly been much improved since his nightmare against Stoke, and shown his versatility in playing well in both defence and midfield. Let's hope he (along with the other remaining non-signees) commits to a new contract. Important player, but still young.

 

[Lady Bracknell]

Talking about Albion players and being objective or subjective.

Some people are against a player full stop. Others are for a player full stop.

Some are more objective and say a player had a lousy game but it was loss of form etc not that he is 'rubbish'

And some people would just grizzle on regardless. Because they can.

 

[Titanic]

Shaaban is signing today for the rest of the season and Roberts should be training again from this week.

That's two bits of very good news!