I looked online to see if I might have been too hasty and saw a tweet on it from Stu Holden. It looks like the keeper is much further towards his goal than halfway. There are also players between the ball and goal.The big difference is that the keeper was near the half way line, and there were no defenders in front of Bale. That makes that situation considerably less rare than rocking horse shit. I think it was clearly a goal scoring opportunity, which is something different from a nailed-on goal.
It does seem like this is a goal scoring opportunity for a player like Bale but it would still need to be a great strike. My point is really that most PL teams play sweeper keepers and we’d often see Sanchez or Ederson 25 to 35 yards out. Wiping out, say, a left back who has the ball nicely set and wants to have a go at the lob from 50 or out should only ever be a yellow. This is fractionally different to be fair but I still come down on the side of yellow. Just