Who wouldn't be a punt in your opinion?
Yes, right philosophy, right personality, right experience, educated in the same school bench as Gus Poyet and Graham Potter. I think absolutely he would be the top candidate.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Next Brighton manager
- Thread starter South west gull
- Start date
Who wouldn't be a punt in your opinion?
Yes, right philosophy, right personality, right experience, educated in the same school bench as Gus Poyet and Graham Potter. I think absolutely he would be the top candidate.
The Fits
Well-known member
- Jun 29, 2020
- 10,106
Either Gallardo and Martinez are so out of our league that we wouldn't even consider them or it's very quiet on those fronts. Why would you not approach the absolutely best managers that you have even a (albeit VERY) small chance of getting?
We seem to be being linked with almost reassuringly realistic options. I wonder if Bloom has a little more ambition than that.
We seem to be being linked with almost reassuringly realistic options. I wonder if Bloom has a little more ambition than that.
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
Our manager salary budget is £X.
Managers requiring £>X aren't on the list. It probably is that simple.
Nobby Cybergoat
Well-known member
- Jul 19, 2021
- 8,770
I agree with the thought process of the poster you quoted.
The prospect of the new manager being someone with a consistent and proven record in English football or a comparable league is receding. That means we are taking a punt with a new manager. Personally i'm fine with that, we take a punt of up and coming players all the time and it mostly works out. But we are taking punt.
The line of logic continues that if we're taking a punt, it may as well be on someone, we know the characteristics of and who would represent a certain level of continuity.
I think it's what I would do. I would try to get through until after the world cup with Crofts and Lallana. See how they do. But I say that as someone who knows nothing about De Zerbi, Knutsen etc etc. I don’t know if we can get them, I don’t know what English they speak, I don’t know if they would demand players we won’t pay for. I guess the club know this stuff more than I do. I still think the most likely scenario is we appoint someone who (incredibly) hasn't been mentioned so far on this thread
Paul Barber very clearly talked about "the process" and "having time on our side" in his press conference. It meant I wouldn't be expecting a name until late next week at the earliest. Just thinking about Knutsen for example, we'd have to get permission to speak to him, he'd have to want to, his backroom would all be in a position to leave Norway (or else he also has to recruit) and even then he might not pass the interview process, which will be rigorous. And that's ONE candidate. However.......
If we've had a word with Martinez to take over after the WC then it makes perfect sense to stick with Crofts and Lallana until then, who know the club and system well enough. That's not information we're going to shout about all over. Martinez would be ideal IMO. Probably the best manager out there still in a job where we might have a reasonable chance. However, it would need some kind of pre-agreement. If he wins it (and Belgium could) we'd probably get gazumped.
Exactly, it’s very risky. And if I was the Belgian FA I’d probably not want to go in to World Cup thinking the manager is already on his way out and not 100% focussed
It would have to be after the World Cup.
Gallardo and Martinez are in very different positions. Gallardo is managing his boyhood team, one of the biggest clubs in the world, and doing very well over there. It would take something extraordinary to get him away and I don't think Brighton fits that description.
Martinez on the other hand is only 49 years old and has been managing Belgium for six years and most likely feel the urge to return to club football.
I think he'll look for something suitable in England and the top clubs are unlikely to come calling when he has been out of club football for so long. He likes a dirty good vision, it was one of the major reasons Dan Ashworth managed to bring him to Wigan back in the days.
rogersix
Well-known member
- Jan 18, 2014
- 8,232
could well be in competition with leicester, villa and everton by then!
Taking us to the next level won't be quick and easy and won't be with the staff we have got left with. At best we would be ponderous in attack and vulnerable to a breakaway counter attack whilst holding a single goal lead, and a bit short in strength in depth with the player sales. Pressing is over rated, passing is what counts, which means running around a lot.
Maybe. Think Lampard is pretty safe. Leicester would probably have sacked Rodgers if they could afford to do it and hire a replacement but judging from the summer window it just looks like they can't afford it. Villa could be a candidate I suppose.
Tyrone Biggums
Well-known member
This will end up like our search for strikers. Make a lot of approaches, make some offers, get our 6th choice.
Blimey - same old big babies on this thread already spitting out their dummies and assuming the worst because we haven't appointed anyone yet in spite of knowing precisely nothing about who we've approached and what conversations have been had other than a very few tidbits leaked out to Naylor and us having time on our side.
HastingsSeagull
Well-known member
Even if we know our number 1 choice, we will wait and speak to our number 5 people incase they surprise us with some added value. Anyone on our list will have some upside and there is no reason to rush. They probably have different benefits and potential issues as well that need considering and weighing up. If we get to next weekend and still not appointed someone then fair enough to worry or start asking questions but we do things correctly and thoroughly not just snap at the first person we like who turns up for an interview who could ‘do a job’.
It’s horrible waiting but worth it for that extra bit of diligence.
It’s horrible waiting but worth it for that extra bit of diligence.
Ⓩ-Ⓐ-Ⓜ-Ⓞ-Ⓡ-Ⓐ
Hove / Παρος
If we wait too long we risk Chelsea hiring our target from under our noses
- May 8, 2018
- 10,844
Exactly
I get to experience the hyperbole from our front office (on boarding) on a daily basis working in 2nd line financial crime, asking why it’s taking so long, why are you asking for this, there’s no concerns with their UK footprint etc.
Quite often it’s not until you complete your enhanced due diligence that you actually undercover concerns that need to be considered and addressed if you are to have a business relationship with any longevity or sustainability.
Well considering their number 1 target Potter is now impossible for them I suspect they'll start tap tapping away somewhere sooner rather than later.
mike1901
Active member
- May 12, 2017
- 281
Sounds promising if true. https://amp.sportsmole.co.uk/footba...-de-zerbi-over-managerial-vacancy_494464.html
mike1901
Active member
- May 12, 2017
- 281