[Albion] Newcastle away: would you take a point?

[Bozza]

 

[brighton_tom]

We could get all three, but a point is also very very helpful, so will feel content with either.

 

[Official Old Man]

Still worried that it may come down to Villa away and needing a draw and I'd rather it was all over by then. A point means a point from Man City as well, plus 3 against Saints.
So it's a NO from me. 3 or zero is the only option.

 

[Bozza]

Still worried that it may come down to Villa away and needing a draw and I'd rather it was all over by then. A point means a point from Man City as well, plus 3 against Saints.
So it's a NO from me. 3 or zero is the only option.

The bit in bold - it could mean that, but it's by no means a certainty, is it?

It's quite possible that even if we lose tonight, we go into Sunday's game knowing that a win would secure a European spot either beyond all mathematical doubt, or all-but-done because of our goal difference superiority.

 

[Official Old Man]

The bit in bold - it could mean that, but it's by no means a certainty, is it?

It's quite possible that even if we lose tonight, we go into Sunday's game knowing that a win would secure a European spot either beyond all mathematical doubt, or all-but-done because of our goal difference superiority.

You're quite right. Should Villa lose at Liverpool, who have won 7 straight, then 3 points will do it. But Europa League requires 5 pts. Spurs dropping 2 at Leeds is possible but I'd rather not wait until the last day to hope. But I'm taking my Daughter Sunday and embarrasingly I know I'm going to be in peices should we qualify.

 

[Sheebo]

Still worried that it may come down to Villa away and needing a draw and I'd rather it was all over by then. A point means a point from Man City as well, plus 3 against Saints.
So it's a NO from me. 3 or zero is the only option.

I voted yes but I did also realise if results go as expected, a point doesn’t change things that much… That said, getting a point v City in our last home game to claim 6th would be amazing!

 

[Bozza]

You're quite right. Should Villa lose at Liverpool, who have won 7 straight, then 3 points will do it. But Europa League requires 5 pts. Spurs dropping 2 at Leeds is possible but I'd rather not wait until the last day to hope. But I'm taking my Daughter Sunday and embarrasingly I know I'm going to be in peices should we qualify.

I'm not sure I agree on the 5 points bit.

If we assume that Liverpool beat Villa then us beating Southampton takes us out of reach of them.

Following that same assumption, if we beat Southampton, Spurs need 5 points to make us need another point, so they need two wins. They've been so ropey this season that it's not a given that they'll even beat Brentford. Even if they do, assuming Leeds still need something from the final day, I'd back them to get something from Spurs. The combination of peak Fat Sam and a raucous Elland Road could see a proper Spursy performance from them.

 

[Nobby Cybergoat]

A point would be a very good result.

But we can get all three.

No more injuries is just as important now

 

[Eric the meek]

What would RDZ say?

There's your answer. 3 points.

 

[Sarisbury Seagull]

I would yes.

I don’t think I will ever shake the - win your home games, draw your away games - thing I was first told as a kid!

 

[Giraffe]

I have to be honest, I am finding it hard to let go of the Champions League dream. I know, ridiculous. But if we beat Newcastle, and then Southampton which is not completely unrealistic and Leicester fluke a win over Newcastle (highly unlikely!) we would be 2 points behind them with a game in hand. It's Man City but who cares, we can do them too. Win at Villa and the Champions League is ours.

EDIT: and yes I know we also need Liverpool to not beat either Villa or Southampton, but Villa is certainly possible at least.

So yes, no taking the draw for me.

 

[Krafty]

Looking at the table, I don't think one point has much significance for our European push.
It would be a step forward, and I would consider it a good result, but personally we should just go for all 3.
Then we would need a win against Southampton, and if we somehow do not get it, we would still be in the best position over Spurs and Villa.

 

[Midget]

I've gone for all 3, because I want us to play for all 3.

Big balls time.

(Although if you ask me afterwards & we got a point, I probably won't be unhappy!)

 

[Hamilton]

I would.

De Zerbi won’t.

 

[Sheebo]

I'm not sure I agree on the 5 points bit.

If we assume that Liverpool beat Villa then us beating Southampton takes us out of reach of them.

Following that same assumption, if we beat Southampton, Spurs need 5 points to make us need another point, so they need two wins. They've been so ropey this season that it's not a given that they'll even beat Brentford. Even if they do, assuming Leeds still need something from the final day, I'd back them to get something from Spurs. The combination of peak Fat Sam and a raucous Elland Road could see a proper Spursy performance from them.

I read yesterday that spurs are 12th on one of the form tables - 10th on another. Their form has been shocking. Another thing I’ve just thought of is a point tonight and a point Sunday would be enough to finish above Villa and / or Spurs if they were to both lose at the weekend. I’d take a point, I don’t think we’ll get it though, bad feeling.

 

[Bozza]

I guess I can't see Spurs picking up six points from their remaining two fixtures.

They've got three wins in their last 12, and that includes the unjust victory over us. The other two were home wins against the hapless pair of Palace and Forest. Additionally, they've not won away in the League since January 23rd.

 

[Rugrat]

..0

Looking at the table, I don't think one point has much significance for our European push.
It would be a step forward, and I would consider it a good result, but personally we should just go for all 3.
Then we would need a win against Southampton, and if we somehow do not get it, we would still be in the best position over Spurs and Villa.

I thought that about the significance of 1 but (and does assume we beat Stains ofc) it leaves us only needing 1 from City or Villa to be guaranteed.

As it is I think Villa lose at Liverpool and Spuds lose at Leeds in which case a win anywhere is enough (likely Stains)

 

[Reinelt12]

I have to be honest, I am finding it hard to let go of the Champions League dream. I know, ridiculous. But if we beat Newcastle, and then Southampton which is not completely unrealistic and Leicester fluke a win over Newcastle (highly unlikely!) we would be 2 points behind them with a game in hand. It's Man City but who cares, we can do them too. Win at Villa and the Champions League is ours.

EDIT: and yes I know we also need Liverpool to not beat either Villa or Southampton, but Villa is certainly possible at least.

So yes, no taking the draw for me.

The only problem with that (as that is a plausible scenario) is that Liverpool likely win out, which will then overtake us and Newcastle…

EDiT - hadn’t read your edit before I sent this!

 

[GallodiMare]

I guess I can't see Spurs picking up six points from their remaining two fixtures.

They've got three wins in their last 12, and that includes the unjust victory over us. The other two were home wins against the hapless pair of Palace and Forest. Additionally, they've not won away in the League since January 23rd.

Yes Sir, mille grazie.

 

[Kuipers Supporters Club]

I'm not sure I agree on the 5 points bit.

If we assume that Liverpool beat Villa then us beating Southampton takes us out of reach of them.

Following that same assumption, if we beat Southampton, Spurs need 5 points to make us need another point, so they need two wins. They've been so ropey this season that it's not a given that they'll even beat Brentford. Even if they do, assuming Leeds still need something from the final day, I'd back them to get something from Spurs. The combination of peak Fat Sam and a raucous Elland Road could see a proper Spursy performance from them.

Bozza speaks words of wisdom.