I prefer to do exactly the same regarding the 2 reflex saves in injury time, which could have forced extra time had the last kick been 2 inches to the right.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Maty Ryan
- Thread starter OSRGull
- Start date
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,120
A lot of revisionist nonsense on here.
Maty made far fewer errors than Sanchez has.
In fact that was really the main thing in his favour.
Sanchez has him beaten hands down in every other department.
His biggest problem was always that he conceded more than he should and he was heavily dependent on the centrebacks.
As Stat has said above, without him, we wouldn't have got to where we are now.
He was comfortably good enough for a perma-relegation threatened side, but not good enough to push on from there.
Maty made far fewer errors than Sanchez has.
In fact that was really the main thing in his favour.
Sanchez has him beaten hands down in every other department.
His biggest problem was always that he conceded more than he should and he was heavily dependent on the centrebacks.
As Stat has said above, without him, we wouldn't have got to where we are now.
He was comfortably good enough for a perma-relegation threatened side, but not good enough to push on from there.
Cowfold Seagull
Fan of the 17 bus
Indeed fine margins, if that late Aussie chance had gone in the end result could have been very different.
Very debatable….. I’m sure Stocko saved a number that Ryan wouldn’t have got close to, but then Ryan would probably have saved the Grealish shot at Villa Park that Stockdale made a mess of….
Both had errors in them, and had Stockdale stayed, he’d been told he would be starting, but we were only prepared to offer 12 months.
willalbion
Well-known member
On the subject of goalkeepers, Martinez (whom I now detest) was far less of a time wasting thunderc*(t against the Aussies - If this is the direct result of hours being added to the 90 mins, then bring it on. Much as I love Ali Mac I want Martinez to suffer after his last visit to the Amex. What a bell end
Spot on.
I went to Gillingham yesterday (something to do), and the Salford goalie adopted a similar approach even at 3-0 up, literally diving on back passes - I mean WTF!
The sooner ball in play timekeeping is implemented the better for me.
Cowfold Seagull
Fan of the 17 bus
Agreed.
Yep, 30 minutes each way with the ball actually in play. Matches would take about the same time as they do now.
Cowfold Seagull
Fan of the 17 bus
Was watching the American version of football when in the States a few weeks ago.; The ball is hardly EVER in play there.
Just stoppage after stoppage for tv advertising.
Tom Hark Preston Park
Will Post For Cash
- Jul 6, 2003
- 72,321
This is the truth. Don't care if you're an EPL manager or a national team manager, it's still pretty f*cking dumb to try and insist on your keeper and defenders stroking the ball to each other across the 18 yard line when every bit of their instinct is screaming for them to clear their lines. They'll be professional and follow the manager's orders for sure, tho very few seem comfortable doing it. As a tactic it's almost as dumb as the two-man corner whereby you voluntarily reduce your team to ten men at a set play
Yes, to be fair, it was a bit of a hospital pass really - it put him in a very tight situation. Agree that he should have wellied it, regardless of any instructions from the manager.This is the truth. Don't care if you're an EPL manager or a national team manager, it's still pretty f*cking dumb to try and insist on your keeper and defenders stroking the ball to each other across the 18 yard line when every bit of their instinct is screaming for them to clear their lines. They'll be professional and follow the manager's orders for sure, tho very few seem comfortable doing it. As a tactic it's almost as dumb as the two-man corner whereby you voluntarily reduce your team to ten men at a set play
The issue with Ryan is his lack of consistency, I never felt comfortable whenever the opposition put him under pressure. But yes he has had a bloody good career, made some great saves and helped get us to where we are. All I said when he stuffed it up was, "and that is why we got rid of him".
The diving on the ball thin is hugely fcuking annoying - but ‘in play timekeeping’ isn’t going to help stop that kind of time wasting, is it? The ball IS in play.
Good point, but depends if the seven second rule is strict applied (if it even still exists), bit like foul throws - (though Salford did get called for one of those).
So the ref was giving a load of indirect freekicks in the box?
If that happens, we'll have the game stopped for adverts while the ball's out for a throw-in.
The game really isn't that broken. Have refs add plenty of time for time wasting, and don't **** up the world's greatest sport
Last edited:
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
I agree, refs need to stamp down on time wasting with cards and additional time. Most of the time wasting is very obvious and is generally a team trying to break up play to hang on to a point or a lead
I don't actually think his problem was consistency... In his first couple of seasons he was actually very consistent, his form just completely abandoned him all in one big chunk when Potter came in. The change from having Dunk and Duffy heading everything away to the insistence on playing everything along the floor seemed to absolutely disintegrate his ability to save shots.
I may be finding something that isn't there on this next point, but I also think that Potter's may of playing meant that when the defenders made errors the opposition were invariably 1-on-1 with Ryan, which in turn has a far lower expected save ratio than say a shot from a headed corner. We were a lot deeper under Hughton and Ryan was more of an extra defender, rather than a key part in breaking the press like Sanchez is now.
His specialism was reaction saves based on his agility, rather than his command of the box and distribution. Sanchez is definitely an upgrade, but I wouldn't say he's more consistent. Sanchez is a fantastic keeper but some of his errors are laughable and seem to happen 1 every 3 or 4 games, it's just they result in goals less of the time
Absolutely spot on. He was such an upgrade on Stockdale at the time and was a big reason we survived those first couple of seasons.
Nobby Cybergoat
Well-known member
- Jul 19, 2021
- 8,624
Wasn't Maty in the running for player of the season, for every full season he played for us?