Lynch to Forest then...

[blockhseagull]

Dunno, Lynch has just moved to a club in the division above...

Well a player of the season award goes to show more consistancy than Lynch has shown.

Also you telling me that if Elphick was avaiable no one from the Championship would be interested

 

[Jimmy Grimble]

Dunno, Lynch has just moved to a club in the division above...

As would Elphick if he was put on the transfer list.

 

[Les Biehn]

Well a player of the season award goes to show more consistancy than Lynch has shown.

Lynch was injured for a fair portion of last season.

 

[Barnham Seagull]

No he's not. We've had poll after poll on here and people just don't agree with you. Please stop pedalling this myth as a fact.

Not being funny but albion fans have a history of not being very good at judging players ability, I think Curbishly remarked on it when he was playing for us.

To me it seems most albion fans like headless chickens running around looking busy who deliver nothing but totatly overlook the more thoughtfull intuative players IMHO

 

[Les Biehn]

As would Elphick if he was put on the transfer list.

That's a fact is it?

 

[The Large One]

Agreed.

Adams has always had a keep the shirt policy.

Yet Lynch plays well at Northampton, then gets dropped for the Scunthorpe game. Work that one out.

Yes, he may be a bit immature but I think he's a right to be pissed off.

I just hope when he goes we get a good fee and a decent sell on clause.

Mind-meltingly and brain-fryingly simple. Lynch was only there as a cover. Defender gets back to 'fitness' and re-claims the shirt.

The place is not his by right, and by the sounds of things, had little intention of fighting for it. So he has little call for being pissed off.

It's a pity because he does offer something on the pitch. Sadly, he seems to offer something off it as well. Good luck to him if it works out for him at Forest, cos he's no use to us at present.

As for blaming Micky for this... risible.

 

[blockhseagull]

Lynch was injured for a fair portion of last season.

Fair point, but had some very poor games when played.

 

[Les Biehn]

Not being funny but albion fans have a history of not being very good at judging players ability, I think Curbishly remarked on it when he was playing for us.

To me it seems most albion fans like headless chickens running around looking busy who deliver nothing but totatly overlook the more thoughtfull intuative players IMHO

Bit like England fans then. No passion = no talent.

 

[Southover Street Seagull]

It was Andy Whing's man. Andy Whing therefore has the responsibility of marking that man. Andy Whing failed in marking his man.

How do you know it was Andy Whing's man? Are you in the know to Mickey Adams' tactics and team talks?
For all you and I know Whing could have been covering for Elphick, when Elphick should have been in the position.
Or you could be correct and Whing was the defender making the mistake.
I love this speculation!

 

[Les Biehn]

Fair point, but had some very poor games when played.

So one injury plagued season of a few bad performances means he is now not very good?

 

[Jimmy Grimble]

That's a fact is it?

I think it is a fair assumption seeing how Championship clubs have been interested in him which is a fact.

 

[Stat Brother]

One thing in Lynch's favour is that he is a defender.

Not letting the truth get in the way of a good theory, I shall say:-

Albion defenders move up divisions.
Albion forwards move down.

 

[Les Biehn]

I think it is a fair assumption seeing how Championship clubs have been interested in him which is a fact.

But not an actual fact though?

 

[Elder for England]

I was just about to say a similiar thing myself. No-body on here knows what goes on all they can do is speculate. Lynch's attitude may be the problem or is not willing to put in the effort in training.

Yes but then aren't you now speculating?

Hence the word 'may' - I'm saying no-one knows! So to criticise Adams for 'driving out such a wonderful player' with lack of knowledge of the situation is ludicrous.

 

[blockhseagull]

So one injury plagued season of a few bad performances means he is now not very good?

Did i say that ?

Nope, just said he isn't our most talented defender

 

[Les Biehn]

Did i say that ?

Nope, just said he isn't our most talented defender

But lets be honest, he probably is. Mentally not there yet but is good in the air, can tackle, is quick, tall, strong and is very good on the ball.

 

[Barnham Seagull]

Mind-meltingly and brain-fryingly simple. Lynch was only there as a cover. Defender gets back to 'fitness' and re-claims the shirt.

The place is not his by right, and by the sounds of things, had little intention of fighting for it. So he has little call for being pissed off.

It's a pity because he does offer something on the pitch. Sadly, he seems to offer something off it as well. Good luck to him if it works out for him at Forest, cos he's no use to us at present.

Or he does not want to waste his time playing reserve team football twice a month collecting his pay packet.

Maybe he wants first team football, a team from a higher level think he is worth looking at.

Hawkins career is going one way and it's not up and will not be worth much to us when we want to get rid of him that said he will do a solid enough job.

 

[Chester Drawers]

Well a player of the season award goes to show more consistancy than Lynch has shown.

Also you telling me that if Elphick was avaiable no one from the Championship would be interested

Wolves were interested as were the non Championship side Everton ...

 

[Southover Street Seagull]

Mind-meltingly and brain-fryingly simple. Lynch was only there as a cover. Defender gets back to 'fitness' and re-claims the shirt.

The place is not his by right, and by the sounds of things, had little intention of fighting for it. So he has little call for being pissed off.

It's a pity because he does offer something on the pitch. Sadly, he seems to offer something off it as well. Good luck to him if it works out for him at Forest, cos he's no use to us at present.

I thought keep the shirt meant if you come in when a player is injured and you play well, you keep the shirt?
How come this didn't happen to Lynch after Northampton, also bearing in mind Hawkins was carrying a hernia injury.
This contributed to Hawkins having a nightmare against Scunthorpe IMHO.

 

[Monkster]

Will Dick Knight release any money for January signings if he does go? or is this another fill the falmer hole sale?