Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Loans Out









looney

Banned
Jul 7, 2003
15,652
I would not loan a player out to a play off rival, even to another team in this division. Thats just f***ing dumb.
 


paul pring

Member
Aug 11, 2011
736
tonbridge
noone to cardiff,you're aving a laugh. Adgestein and jfc are going to be stars for the future and are doing fine under gus but maybe a loan to div 1 could help them for now
 










SeafordBHA

New member
Aug 13, 2011
410
Can't understand why we would loan any first team player out? Especially Nooney!

I would not loan a player out to a play off rival, even to another team in this division. Thats just f***ing dumb.

And on this, if we have a player like Agdestein not anywhere near the first team, I don't have a problem with loaning him out to someone like Doncaster or Forest, who pose no threat to us as long as he doesn't play against us. If anything they could take points off teams around us, and getting game time whilst they may not here.

Also if JFC gets knocked down the pecking order, why not loan him out to someone like Bournemouth, gets game time and experience which he wouldn't be getting here, and recall him if we need him?
 








BensGrandad

New member
Jul 13, 2003
72,015
Haywards Heath
I think Noone will go on a loan to buy deal. Also we will now have 3 other wingers to chose from as well as Buckley and just wonder why has Gus signed another winger on loan, has a deal for Noone been done. Adgestein, JFC & Barker will not get many ooportunities with us for this season so send them out to a Div 1 side to continue their football education and Harley needs games which he wont get with us so again Div 1 or a lower Championship side.
 




HawkTheSeagull

New member
Jan 31, 2012
9,122
Eastbourne
If Noone was to go he would have left by now, he is still 1st team - cant rely on 2 young players on loan all the time and Vicente is injured quite a bit. JFC is still a young player so if he isnt in the first team then he can play in the Dev Squad but hes a good back up at the moment, as is Toby.

Harley and Barker should go on a loan though.
 


bhawoddy

Well-known member
Jan 25, 2011
3,621
I think Noone will go on a loan to buy deal. Also we will now have 3 other wingers to chose from as well as Buckley and just wonder why has Gus signed another winger on loan, has a deal for Noone been done. Adgestein, JFC & Barker will not get many ooportunities with us for this season so send them out to a Div 1 side to continue their football education and Harley needs games which he wont get with us so again Div 1 or a lower Championship side.

Noone is quality -why do people keep doubting this. He scares the shit out of defenses. Ok, so in half a season he hasnt delived pin point crosses everytime but he offers just as much by taking oppo players out of the game and creating openings that way. Im amazed that other fans cant see his OBVIOUS quality.
 


Sheebo

Well-known member
Jul 13, 2003
29,319
With the 2 new loans now signed who, if anybody, are we likely to loan out.

I would suggest:
Noone to Cardiff
Harley
JFC
Adgestein
Barker

I assume this is very poor fishing. Especially the Noone one.
 




Bob!

Coffee Buyer
Jul 5, 2003
11,936
I think Noone will go on a loan to buy deal. Also we will now have 3 other wingers to chose from as well as Buckley and just wonder why has Gus signed another winger on loan, has a deal for Noone been done. Adgestein, JFC & Barker will not get many ooportunities with us for this season so send them out to a Div 1 side to continue their football education and Harley needs games which he wont get with us so again Div 1 or a lower Championship side.

You are either completely mad, or on a very poor fishing trip!
 


looney

Banned
Jul 7, 2003
15,652
Can't understand why we would loan any first team player out? Especially Nooney!



And on this, if we have a player like Agdestein not anywhere near the first team, I don't have a problem with loaning him out to someone like Doncaster or Forest, who pose no threat to us as long as he doesn't play against us. If anything they could take points off teams around us, and getting game time whilst they may not here.

Also if JFC gets knocked down the pecking order, why not loan him out to someone like Bournemouth, gets game time and experience which he wouldn't be getting here, and recall him if we need him?

Agree with this, we should loan Flapper out to Palace.
 


Acker79

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 15, 2008
31,921
Brighton
I think Noone will go on a loan to buy deal. Also we will now have 3 other wingers to chose from as well as Buckley and just wonder why has Gus signed another winger on loan, has a deal for Noone been done. Adgestein, JFC & Barker will not get many ooportunities with us for this season so send them out to a Div 1 side to continue their football education and Harley needs games which he wont get with us so again Div 1 or a lower Championship side.

Nah.

If Noone is to go to Cardiff it won't be on loan. We're not trying to unload him. They are not unsure if they want him. Either they will raise their offer and buy him out right, which Gus doesn't want. Or They won't and we'll keep him.

Assulin is a winger like Reyes and Vincelot are midfielders. They are options for the player, not necessarily their preferred role, or that of the manager for them.

Yes we have three wingers in Lualua, Noone and Buckley, but how many injuries have they had between them? Have all three ever been available at the same time this season?

Agdestein player last night. He has featured in three of the last 5 league matches, in total this season he's been in 7 match day squads. JFC has been in the match squad 8 times out of 37, almost once every 4.6 games.

I can't see either of them going out.

Barker, Bergkamp, Sampayo, Kasim, Rodgers would be potential loanees (as well as other DS players who haven't made a matchday squad this year)
 


BensGrandad

New member
Jul 13, 2003
72,015
Haywards Heath
I think a deal similar to that agreed with Bennett has been done as regards Noone. I dont want it but if as has been suggested Cardiff have offered above £1m I think it would be good business. Still come back to the signing of Ausilin why did we sig him on loan whenwe have plenty of wingers; unless one is going out on loan.
 






AMEXican Wave

AMEX Ruffian
Sep 21, 2010
1,226
Why in the whole of reality would we loan Noone to a playoff rival?

It's not April 1st yet...
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here