dejavuatbtn
Well-known member
Too unpredictable for Potterball.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Knockaert joins Fulham on initial one-year loan
- Thread starter BUTTERBALL
- Start date
Cowfold Seagull
Fan of the 17 bus
Indeed.
Trossard is miles ahead of Knockaert. Silly
I don’t think he is. I did at first, but following his first injury in Potters first season, he has only shown glimpses.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Doc Lynam
I hate the Daily Mail
- Jun 19, 2011
- 7,348
I think Trossard looks a bit heavy at times.
Too much Belgian chocolate
He was asked by the club to hit the weights he's done this he's fine. Much more difficult to knock off the ball these days.
AmexRuislip
Retired Spy 🕵️♂️
Doc Lynam
I hate the Daily Mail
- Jun 19, 2011
- 7,348
Yes agree, but that's if he keeps hold of it
True and needs to stop looking like a kid who's had his ball taken away, but then you come full circle to knocky again.
AmexRuislip
Retired Spy 🕵️♂️
I bet if you dive into the gene pool, they may be related in a Francophonie styleeeeee
And contribution off the ball and to the rest of the team?
I saw Knockaert clear a few off the line.....
What defines a second assist? Clear pass or inadvertent touch?
Edit - does this include Leicester as well for Knockaert?
Compare Knockaert last season with us and Trossard’s first. Similar appearances, Trossard 3 more goals (he did start well), Knockaert 3 more assists.
Last edited:
Whilst I think Knocky wasn’t great at this level, he was playing in a Hughton team. That said, I think they’ve both under performed.
There’s definitely a solid case that Trossard is a better player. Being a Belgium international suggests that. Technically, on the ball he is brilliant. But Tross is woefully, woefully inconsistent. At first I thought he was going to be an immense player in this league. And he is.. every 5-6 games!
His early appearances at the Amex were electric. If he could add consistency to his game he’d be incredible.
Of course other things matter as well.
As for second assist, not sure. The only site I know that counts "second assists" is the oldest Premier League stat site around, http://www.premiersoccerstats.com and I dont know how they measure it.
Does not include Leicester.
A bit selective with the stats. You can use any stats to fit an Agendas so much so that it you go to tenth assist, you could be looking at having touched the ball before half time and and the goal is scored in the second half or in the previous game
Whats the stats with assists only ?
Wardy's twin
Well-known member
- Oct 21, 2014
- 8,874
stats are what you make of them. We have many games where we have had more possession but have not won... It does not reflect AKs overall contribution.
Thanks - just looked on the PL site and compared Knockaert’s last season with Trossard’s first. Really very little in it. 3 goals and 3 assists difference in favour of each player. 31 and 30 appearances respectively.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
A bit selective with the stats. You can use any stats to fit an Agendas so much so that it you go to tenth assist, you could be looking at having touched the ball before half time and and the goal is scored in the second half or in the previous game
Whats the stats with assists only ?
I dont have an agenda really as I have no clue if Trossard is better than Knockaert or not, I just reacted to the "Knocky got better end product" thing as its not exactly what I've seen from the little I've seen of him and these stats support it to some extent though of course things like goal conversion and successful crosses/key passes etc would perhaps be more accurate... and more time consuming to pull out.
I am not even bothered about the stats I asked for - These are all about opinions and all very personal.
You ask people who is the best player in the PL nd you would get 1000s of different answers. You get most people claiming that De Breuyne being the best midfielder in the PL - Many would disagree.
I actually think that Ilkay Gundogan is a more influential player than De Breuyne but I don't think he gets the same praise in that side because he does a lot of what he does ''Less Spectacularly''
My opinion is nether better or worse than anyone else's - It's just my opinion.
Umm.. yes?
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
When Trossard has a PL MOM performance then we can compare the two, Knocky was unplayable against Man Utd at home ruined them, also against City in the semi what a performance. Unfortunately both very inconsistent players in the PL.
Machiavelli
Well-known member
Interesting, if hardly surprising.
Knockaert was absolutely stunning for us in the Championship, was our best player when we got promoted, and was its PotS. He had one or two cracking games for us in the PL -- most memorably the home game we won against United that secured survival, when he put Rojo on his arse, and similar delicious exploits -- but too impetuous to take things further. He remains a legend.
Trossard is quite comfortably a superior player, but similarly frustrating.