I think the question with him is whether he had the talent at that level and was lazy, or just wasn't all that good at football, combined with being lazy and overweight.
Its often one of those ones where you need a fan from a club 'before he was shit' to step up and say he was actually capable.
I saw him for the reserves a few times and frankly he was non-league. The first team performances weren't good of course. Clearly overweight with us. Wonder if he regrets that now....