James MacArthur

[Insel affe]

For 2 million quid as quoted that would be a steal, If fully fit would sit alongside Stephens very nicely

My first reaction was feck off, but actually 2million is not bad Buisness and would enable to add someone else in the same position, so it's a yes from me as back up not a main player unless he proves himself worthy.

 

[AmexRuislip]

Jimmy Mac made an instant impact after signing for Wigan and had an excellent first two years with the club. In that time I'd say he was probably one of our best players. Unfortunately he sustained ligament damage last season and hasn't been the same player since his return. If he could return to his form of 2015, he'd be a massive upgrade on your current midfielders. He's a solid box to box midfielder; he can tackle, he can carry the ball and he'll chip in with the odd goal as well.

Hardly a selling point TBH

 

[Arkwright]

I saw him last season against Saints at Selhurst and I thought he was the best player on the pitch. He won every tackle and was always positive with his passing. I would sign him.

 

[Mr Putdown]

I'd doubt he can play every game of a season these days but he is a cracking player.

I'd be gutted if we sell him and, assuming you don't expect him to play every game, he'd be a quality addition to a premier league squad.

He's one of those players who rarely makes the headlines but can be absolutely relied on to perform well if he's fit. He's turned plenty of games for us, whether it be him going off injured and us imploding, or him coming on and stabilising our midfield.

Please don't buy him.

At £2m he'd be well worth it and, personally, Id be gutted if you bought him for so little money.

 

[turienzo's lovechild]

wouldn't say no to be honest. Solid with a decent amount of prem experience which is what we require

 

[Seasidesage]

Once we had him de-loused he could be a useful signing at that price. The idea these Palace ***** want to spread that he is better than our midfield though makes me want to puke. Stephens and Kayal if he's fit will both hold their own at this level. We may and probably will have problems staying up, but not everyone we have is shit. Can't someone just ban the mugs?

 

[Mackenzie]

A hobbling palace chuck out......no thanks.

 

[Insel affe]

I'd doubt he can play every game of a season these days but he is a cracking player.

I'd be gutted if we sell him and, assuming you don't expect him to play every game, he'd be a quality addition to a premier league squad.

He's one of those players who rarely makes the headlines but can be absolutely relied on to perform well if he's fit. He's turned plenty of games for us, whether it be him going off injured and us imploding, or him coming on and stabilising our midfield.

Please don't buy him.

At £2m he'd be well worth it and, personally, Id be gutted if you bought him for so little money.

Hang on.....

Somethings not right here....

Why are you lot being nice, and recommending him adding he is value for money.....

This is either what the Premier League does to fierce rivals or a feckin wind up....

 

[Bruntburger]

I think Kayal will be like a new signing this season. Expecting bids in January for him!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

Jimmy Mac made an instant impact after signing for Wigan and had an excellent first two years with the club. In that time I'd say he was probably one of our best players. Unfortunately he sustained ligament damage last season and hasn't been the same player since his return. If he could return to his form of 2015, he'd be a massive upgrade on your current midfielders. He's a solid box to box midfielder; he can tackle, he can carry the ball and he'll chip in with the odd goal as well.

Another failed medical then.


We could do with finding a midfielder who could pass one.

[emoji38]ol:

 

[Mr Putdown]

Hang on.....

Somethings not right here....

Why are you lot being nice, and recommending him adding he is value for money.....

This is either what the Premier League does to fierce rivals or a feckin wind up....

It's neither. As I said I'd be gutted if he left; even more gutted if he left to join your lot for only £2m.

He's one of those players who just does his job well and without fanfare. One of those players who, those who watch him week in, week out, really appreciate yet the media ignore because he's not famous or fashionable.

If we are selling him, I'd rather he went to any other premier team than you lot.

Does that answer your conundrum?

 

[We're the Stripes]

He's one of those players who just does his job well and without fanfare.

So what's he not doing so well since his injury then? Or is that being overstated?

 

[Mr Putdown]

So what's he not doing so well since his injury then? Or is that being overstated?

When he came back from injury and played he was still sound. I'd suggest that our management were more focused on premier league survival rather than easing a player back into the first team after injury.

 

[banjo]

Impossible.

 

[Dougie]

Impossible.

For £2 m I agree .

 

[Postman Pat]

Naylor says this rumour is "nonsense"

 

[GreersElbow]

Snodgrass & McArthur...living the PL dream aren't"t we.

Snodgrass? There hasn't been any news on this since the first week it came out.

 

[BensGrandad]

I would hope that he is not on our radar. Perhaps good enough for an annual struggling Palace side but wouldnt want him in ours.

 

[Napper]

Naylor says this rumour is "nonsense"

FFS Naylor.

Pissing on fireworks.

Who are we in for then Andy , use your investigative skills to tell us

 

[Easy 10]

Wasn't it McArthur who let the cat out of the bag over it being a Palace employee who shat all over the dressing room floor ?