[Albion] Jack Hinshelwood [9/4/24: new deal to 2028]

[Goldstone Guy]

He did really well today, but up to this point, he's looked like a player that other teams target

But he's taken his chance. Had Fati, March, Enciso and Welbeck not all sustained long term injuries, it's a chance he probably wouldn't have got

But it's not surprising they've targeted him - he's 18 (I think), playing out of position, in a position where getting exposed can quickly lead to conceding goals. The fact that he's got through these games without costing us goals (ok a marginal penalty decision Vs forest) reflects even better on him.
Edit - sorry perhaps you're talking about Buonanotte, I'm referring to Hinshelwood.

 

[dwayne]

Thought he was excellent again today. Kept Sterling very quiet. Assured and great decision making.

Surprised he got hooked for Milner, that pen situation never happens otherwise.

I must be watching a different player. Sterling beat him time and time again and walked through him once in the second half ... He did make one good tackle at the end of his time on the pitch but nothing else. For me he just doesn't have the raw ability of our other youngsters

 

[Change at Barnham]

I must be watching a different player. Sterling beat him time and time again and walked through him once in the second half ... He did make one good tackle at the end of his time on the pitch but nothing else. For me he just doesn't have the raw ability of our other youngsters

I was reading this comment without initially seeing who it was written by.
It then clicked.

And yes, I was right.

 

[tstanbur]

I must be watching a different player. Sterling beat him time and time again and walked through him once in the second half ... He did make one good tackle at the end of his time on the pitch but nothing else. For me he just doesn't have the raw ability of our other youngsters

You seem to do that a lot

 

[tstanbur]

.

 

[herecomesaregular]

I must be watching a different player. Sterling beat him time and time again and walked through him once in the second half ... He did make one good tackle at the end of his time on the pitch but nothing else. For me he just doesn't have the raw ability of our other youngsters

Change your username to Mr Magoo.

 

[Jimmy Grimble]

He was on a yellow, smart move I think

For a foul that was never a yellow.

 

[CAPTAIN GREALISH]

I must be watching a different player. Sterling beat him time and time again and walked through him once in the second half ... He did make one good tackle at the end of his time on the pitch but nothing else. For me he just doesn't have the raw ability of our other youngsters

Guess you would expect

You seem to do that a lot

guess you would expect a English international footballer to do this

 

[Zeberdi]

And to be fair, most players get their first chance because of an injury etc.

I think the other point about why Facu gets questioned, is that at the start of the season he looked to most (well i'll just speak for myself) as though he's a year behind Sarmiento in his development, so it's a little unclear why he was kept to play out of position when there was a player who has performed at this level, who would be playing in the correct position who got sent out. I'm not saying I could do better than RDZ, I just think that plays a part in the thought process of those judging him

I think any one who watched his promos (well forget those highly edited pieces of shite) but knew a little of his background with Rosario, read some of the scouting reports and listened to MacAllister’s assessment of the lad, would know, he was very much ahead of Sarmiento in raw talent. Sadly, he seemed to have struggled emotionally with reports of depression in the early months which I think impacted on his game. Sending him out on loan after he was finally getting settled at the end of last season would have been a set back imo. But RDZ isn’t perfect - it is hard to manage the expectations of these young players - Gilmour probably should have got far more time than he did earlier last season but we don’t always know what they are going through emotionally which impacts them in training and which impairs their mental fitness for PL football? - the coaches do and they also know if they have turned a corner emotionally.

 

[Questions]

I thought he did damn well today but did pull back from a tackle after his yellow and he was subbed at the right time.
Gilmour was super.

 

[dwayne]

I thought he did damn well today but did pull back from a tackle after his yellow and he was subbed at the right time.
Gilmour was super.

Yep gilmour was awesome today stunning performance along with bonny and baleba

 

[Questions]

Yep gilmour was awesome today stunning performance along with bonny and baleba

Baleba and Gilmour will be quite a partnership soon

 

[Bakero]

It makes me feel very old that I remember his Dad as a young player coming through

So of our fellow posters remember his great grandad, Willie, making his debut for Fulham.

 

[Flounce]

For a foul that was never a yellow.

I have no idea how that warranted a yellow, I’m not sure how Caicedo stayed on the pitch either though

Pawson, without doing anything game changing was his usual look at me self who was far too noticeable

I thought Hinsh did OK, Sterling on form is a challenge for even the best FBs

 

[Uh_huh_him]

He did really well today.

Had his name sung by the fans from his performance, not as a sympathy vote.
Boy will be a big player for us

Also considerably taller than i thought.
he has a kid's face so assumed he was a 5ft 6 er, but must be over 6ft, I'd guess

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

I must be watching a different player. Sterling beat him time and time again and walked through him once in the second half ... He did make one good tackle at the end of his time on the pitch but nothing else. For me he just doesn't have the raw ability of our other youngsters

Just back.

You must be, Hinsh largely gave him absolutely nothing

 

[Uh_huh_him]

Just back.

You must be, Hinsh largely gave him absolutely nothing

THIS!!

first 5 sterling looked to have the edge, then Hinsh disposessed him nicely and after that he was in control.

 

[albionalex]

I must be watching a different player. Sterling beat him time and time again and walked through him once in the second half ... He did make one good tackle at the end of his time on the pitch but nothing else. For me he just doesn't have the raw ability of our other youngsters

You must be, as the stat providers have Hinshelwood being dribbled past 0 times.

 

[nicko31]

So impressed with him, can only improve

 

[dwayne]

You must be, as the stat providers have Hinshelwood being dribbled past 0 times.

Definitely 1000% did in the second half watch it back just before he came off. Woeful.