If we had to sell either Ince or Dunk this summer, who would it be?

[casbom]

Talk of Ince and Dunk attracting interest this summer got me thinking that we are one of those Clubs who probably has to sell at least one player each season. I can't imagine we would sell both of these so who would you sell?

For me it would be Dunk as I think he "should" be easier to replace than Ince.

What do you think?

ps I wouldn't be surprised if Kayal was subject to bids this summer

 

[BensGrandad]

Ince as easier to replace as a DM but probably wouldnt get as much money. There will be a number of experienced DM available in the summer. should CH decide he needs to replace him

 

[Prince Monolulu]

Ince as easier to replace as a DM but probably wouldn't get as much money.

Good point, well made

 

[Trevor]

Voted Dunk, If we still have Ince next season I think he'll be one of the best in the league. But, we should always allow players to leave for career progression in a higher division

 

[studio150]

The one that attracts the highest bid

 

[TheDuke]

So tough. Both great young players who WILL move on to better things. But out of the two, for me, I think Dunk is the better prospect. Ince is still fledgling and may not fly but Dunk is already flexing his wings

 

[Wellesley]

I really hope we keep Dunk, but I believe keeping Ince is even more crucial. He is already a superb player for us and his potential is massive.

 

[JBizzle]

Ince as easier to replace as a DM but probably wouldnt get as much money. There will be a number of experienced DM available in the summer. should CH decide he needs to replace him

I'd say it's the other way around. Decent centre backs are everywhere. We've currently got Halford, Hughes, Greer AND Dunk. Wouldn't surprise me if CH wanted someone like Bassong to come in as well as keep Halford and probably release Hughes. That's looking at it from a very narrow view. In terms of DMs, we've got Ince and Holla. We need one more even without Ince going.

 

[BensGrandad]

I would expect Hughes to be released, Halford signed and Greer relegated to back up. We also have Glen Rea coming through and Maksimenko to possibly come back. Experienced DM are two a penny and will be available in the summer released by Prem clubs and looking for their last contract at 32 /33 + years old

 

[Murray 17]

If we get reasonable offers we will sell both. Experience of the past 18 months tells you that once a Premier Club comes in we sell. Worst case scenario would be we sell to that lot up the road. Oh well, will keep this board busy for months!

 

[Hampster Gull]

Dunk. Then ask for one of our Muff secondees back

 

[Tory Boy]

I believe Dunk leaving is an almost certainty.

TB

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

Sell Dunk, and save the wages of CMS, Kemy, McCourt and Hughes.

Surely enough to get 1 or 2 decent strikers in.

Sign up Halford as Dunk's replacement and bring Rea into the squad.

 

[OGH's Libido]

Murray

 

[mona]

Neither of them did themselves any favours at Rotherham.

 

[SteveTheSeagull]

Bloom will probably sell both if an offer comes in.

 

[Justice]

I would expect Hughes to be released, Halford signed and Greer relegated to back up. We also have Glen Rea coming through and Maksimenko to possibly come back. Experienced DM are two a penny and will be available in the summer released by Prem clubs and looking for their last contract at 32 /33 + years old

You think Halford is more capable than Greer?

 

[CheshireSeagull]

Ince has not improved this season terrible performance from him on Saturday gave the ball away to often and was poor defensively if a premiership club wanted to give us anywhere north of 3 million for him I would take it and run

 

[Horton's halftime iceberg]

Wheres the option for both, both would be pure profit - I would like to keep both but everything has its price and Barber has proved he can make a lot on these deals.

They would both be better off staying anyway as they will play regularly here, in hopefully a better squad

 

[Lifelong Supporter]

Neither are going anywhere. They are not good enough for the Premiership and would not be regularly starting for a top Championship team.