[Misc] How do you do?

[el punal]

"I'm good" makes perfect sense and is grammatically correct.

Yes, I know. I was of course referring to one's well being and health rather than have they been a model citizen.

 

[maffew]

The correct reply is to also say how do you do?

The correct reply is in here

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EWf_UMvbFBM

 

[Bodian]

"I'm good" makes perfect sense and is grammatically correct.

It might be. But it's no answer to 'would you like a cup of tea?' which is when I get it from the younger generation in my office. What does, 'I'm good' mean in relation to that? (generally, it means 'no thanks). I must admit to getting irritated by 'I'm good' as a response to various questions - I do sometimes retort along the lines of something like 'isn't that for us to judge, not yourself?'

Anyway - with regard to How do you do; " 'Ow Do?" (with a nod of the head) is quite a common greeting when out in the countryside up here - and a good way of greeting grumpy farmers. Who usually respond with "What're you on with now then?"

 

[Bakero]

It might be. But it's no answer to 'would you like a cup of tea?' which is when I get it from the younger generation in my office. What does, 'I'm good' mean in relation to that? (generally, it means 'no thanks). I must admit to getting irritated by 'I'm good' as a response to various questions - I do sometimes retort along the lines of something like 'isn't that for us to judge, not yourself?'

Would "I'm OK, thanks" be a suitable response?

 

[Thunder Bolt]

The correct reply is to also say how do you do?

Exactly. When being introduced, it is a rhetorical question.

 

[Bodian]

Would "I'm OK, thanks" be a suitable response?

Probably, yes!! - even though it is arguably also an Americanism as well, and with a similar meaning. It's that subtle isn't it. But 'I'm OK' just doesn't have the behavioural connotations that 'I'm good' has. I think my problem with 'I'm good' isn't that it is an Americanism, it just that it always seems to me to be a comment on moral character rather than a response to a query about health or thirstiness!

However, the English language is fabulous, and it's constant changes like this that keeps it so.

 

[Garage_Doors]

"I'm good" makes perfect sense and is grammatically correct.

Really ? When i ask any of my children questions like, you do want a cup of tea they respond with "i'm good".

The correct grammatical response is "no Thank you"

 

[Bakero]

Really ? When i ask any of my children questions like, you do want a cup of tea they respond with "i'm good".

The correct grammatical response is "no Thank you"

My reply was regarding using "I'm good" to mean "I'm well".

But anyway, yes, saying I'm good to mean no thanks is fine. English has a descriptive grammar. "Rules" are governed by common usage. If people are saying it, it's grammatically correct.

 

[Thecoffeecake]

Ayyy, ahwar ya?

 

[Juan Albion]

I thought everyone back in Blighty just asked "You alright?" these days.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Would "I'm OK, thanks" be a suitable response?

How do you do is not the same as how are you.

 

[Bakero]

How do you do is not the same as how are you.

I know. I was responding to this-

It might be. But it's no answer to 'would you like a cup of tea?' which is when I get it from the younger generation in my office. What does, 'I'm good' mean in relation to that? (generally, it means 'no thanks).