Aretha is a bloody good call. Think you’re right about Bush too, she’s an amazing unique talent and artist and I love her but in vocal Ability terms, whilst unmistakable, is she one of the greats? I’m not so sureTop thread [MENTION=663]portlock seagull[/MENTION].
It seems to me you can break this down into sub categories.
Technically. Franklin is the greatest.
In terms of overall artisteness, you can't look beyond turmoil and damage. Winehouse and Joplin being the front runners.
You then have the quirky performers. Bush and Guðmundsdóttir being the obvious choices.
I can't bear singers that lose their edge. I hope that Bird doesn't go melodic. She's got great potential.
Lennox and Dion? Fukk me. Bland beyond belief. Nice can fukk right off.
Roberta Flack and Gladys Knight. Early Tina Turner with Ike, the album Come Together in particular .
Top thread [MENTION=663]portlock seagull[/MENTION].
It seems to me you can break this down into sub categories.
Technically. Franklin is the greatest.
In terms of overall artisteness, you can't look beyond turmoil and damage. Winehouse and Joplin being the front runners.
You then have the quirky performers. Bush and Guðmundsdóttir being the obvious choices.
I can't bear singers that lose their edge. I hope that Bird doesn't go melodic. She's got great potential.
Lennox and Dion? Fukk me. Bland beyond belief. Nice can fukk right off.