clippedgull
Hotdogs, extra onions
It's fair to say he was poor last night but to crucify him is a bit over the top. He's a young player still learning his craft. Much too early to write him off.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Forster-Caskey
- Thread starter Dorset Seagull
- Start date
albionalex
Well-known member
He had a shocker last night, no doubts about it. Also, looks like his goal of the season award has gone to his head as he has been shooting from some ridiculous positions lately. However, the reaction has been OTT. People saying he can only pass sideways or backwards must not be watching when he's played 45 yard balls from our half to the left wing, whilst he's put in some superb performances this year that largely go unnoticed, like against Forest on Saturday.
If...
- you don't think JFC is good enough to be playing, blame Oscar for playing him.
- you think Ince should be playing ahead of JFC, blame Oscar for playing him.
- you think JFC played the wrong style of game, blame Oscar for telling him how and where to play.
- you think abusing a young 20 year old who has just played in the biggest game of his career is the right thing to do, you are stupid.
- you think JFC didn't try as hard as he could last night, you are stupid.
- you were given an Albion shirt and told to go and give it your all, you wouldn't say "No, I think you should pick someone else".
- you don't think JFC is good enough to be playing, blame Oscar for playing him.
- you think Ince should be playing ahead of JFC, blame Oscar for playing him.
- you think JFC played the wrong style of game, blame Oscar for telling him how and where to play.
- you think abusing a young 20 year old who has just played in the biggest game of his career is the right thing to do, you are stupid.
- you think JFC didn't try as hard as he could last night, you are stupid.
- you were given an Albion shirt and told to go and give it your all, you wouldn't say "No, I think you should pick someone else".
I think that is the easy way out there. I can understand trying to defend him, any abuse he gets is completely stupid, however he was very poor yesterday and that is his fault.
I agree - I don't think he had a particularly good game. But I recognise he has just turned 20, he is inexperienced, he was playing in the biggest game of his life, he was being asked to play in a position which is not completely natural for him, that we all have bad days at work (maybe you're the exception and don't) and that, as such, some of the abuse that has been dished out is, in my opinion, completely out of order.
Maybe I'm the weird one in holding that view.
He did not have a great game but too many people looking at him in isolation he is part of a poor 3 man midfield and I dont think he knows where he fits - bit of a jack of all trades and master of none. As he is still learning his trade they should be focusing on 1 specific role not moving him around. To counter that I can understand why he was in a deeper role, with Derbys pacey counter attacking and our slow defense plus Andrews I think he was seen as adding a bit more pace when they attacked.
Abuse aimed at him, I agree totally out of order, but being moaned about on here is perfectly acceptable surely thats what the site is for, a place to vent?
He had a shocker last night, his decsion making is terrible, not many people have agreed with me this morning, but the first goal was his fault, the ball fell to him 30 yards out and he had a shot so weak it didnt go out of play and they picked it up at the right back posisition and this had us everyone out of play.
Why when we are 1-0 up would you shoot from 30+yards he had several other options and he want for glory. he then failed to make a tackle on the half way line and then failed again to get behind the ball and allowed their forward to run though into the box. all this when we were in control and just needed to look after the ball.
Dick Knights Mumm
Take me Home Falmer Road
Not at all. I totally agree. He was not great last night - but then he and Andrews look to duplicate each others efforts - which made it look worse.
One thing he can do is retain possession - and last night his touch let him down on occasion. The art of his game I would work on is his forward passing - but he is a young level-headed lad, and will improve.
Having sat on his table at the sponsors dinner - on a personal level he is a credit to himself and the club.
Ex-Staffs Gull
New member
This is BS..... JFC had a poor game, so did Orlandi, they have had excellent games as well. If anyone thinks they didnt give it everything they are idiots.
The way anyone improves is with the support of those around them, I have never seen anyone improve when being picked on.
If Oscar sees fit to play him Sunday then I will trust his judgement far more than my bias amateur views.
The way anyone improves is with the support of those around them, I have never seen anyone improve when being picked on.
If Oscar sees fit to play him Sunday then I will trust his judgement far more than my bias amateur views.
BBassic
I changed this.
- Jul 28, 2011
- 13,028
In the sober light of day I'll admit to possibly being too critical. He wasn't great but he wasn't alone in that.
Really must remember to stay off the internet if drunk. Usually end up looking at tweets and posts the following day and wind up quite embarrassed.
Really must remember to stay off the internet if drunk. Usually end up looking at tweets and posts the following day and wind up quite embarrassed.
JCL666
absurdism
- Sep 23, 2011
- 2,190
He's a decent young player, who when he's on form helps us to tick over by being available for a pass, linking up play and generally working hard. A team that plays possession football need that kind of player (Navarro? Dicker?).
When he's playing at his best, he is good enough to play for a decent Championship side.
He just didn't have a good game last night. That happens. Look at the ex-PL/England international who just won player of the season, he had his worst game for a while as well.
It's clear to anyone who has a brain that the team selection is limited by injuries/those returning from them. Plus the bizarre case of Kemi and the inconsistency of Dave.
Ordinarily Crofts, Stephens or Ince would get the nod ahead of JFC.
When he's playing at his best, he is good enough to play for a decent Championship side.
He just didn't have a good game last night. That happens. Look at the ex-PL/England international who just won player of the season, he had his worst game for a while as well.
It's clear to anyone who has a brain that the team selection is limited by injuries/those returning from them. Plus the bizarre case of Kemi and the inconsistency of Dave.
Ordinarily Crofts, Stephens or Ince would get the nod ahead of JFC.
HawkTheSeagull
New member
He was poor along with pretty much most of the team last night. I would start Ince, if fully fit, on Sunday though.
fat old seagull
New member
Absolutely out of order, and the perpetrators should be ashamed of themselves. Besides it really isn't his fault, he hardly went out there to play badly. It's really nothing more than whether he was the right person for the job on the night. He's got a good future in the game, but wasn't up to the task yesterday. Good luck to him.
severnside gull
Well-known member
Not meaning to be controversial but I actually thought he did okay dropping back to cover and prevent them breaking quickly in the second half. Not a spectacular role with much chance to shine but he didn't let himself down or the team.
severnside gull
Well-known member
Not meaning to be controversial but I actually thought he did okay dropping back to cover and prevent them breaking quickly in the second half. Not a spectacular role with much chance to shine but he didn't let himself down or the team.
seagullsovergrimsby
#cpfctinpotclub
If you're going to criticise JFC you should also be looking in Orlandi's direction too , both had stinkers of a game. Ince could be the answer on Sunday instead of JFC with Solly replacing Orlandi and CMS playing right wing in place of Buckley in the starting line up.
BensGrandad
New member
On 2 occasions he was held back when we had a corner and both times gave the ball away 1 with a very poor header that wasnt necessary and 2nd with a lofted clearance straight to a Derby player.
severnside gull
Well-known member
Far from being the only one guilty of that last night!
He wasn't brilliant but he was in good company in that respect. Upson, Orlandi, Andrews......
Still as a team we were far from being bad and come Sunday we can go into the game knowing we still have a chance.