[Politics] Elton John... Brilliant?

[jcdenton08]

You're a decent lad. That is clear

(Sorry for flaming you recently. But you were wrong.)

Wouldn't be the first or last time, also have big respect for your opinions, however fierce! Rarely openly told someone I "like" them on an internet forum, nevermind a fella!

 

[Albion in the north]

Thread is titled "Brilliant" but the Poll says "Talented". Undoubtedly one and occasionally both.

 

[clapham_gull]

Yeah I imagine Elton John is an absolute ****ing nightmare professionally.

I do like him, if not all his music.

He knows he an ordinary lad who became an impossible diva through drugs and fame.

He's never forgotten where he came from. I love his story about knowing when he had absolutely lost it when he called down at his hotel in London and asked them to do something about the wind.

Wasn't that impressed with his autobiography to be honest.

 

[jcdenton08]

Thread is titled "Brilliant" but the Poll says "Talented". Undoubtedly one and occasionally both.

My apologies. I tried to give everyone an option when it came to voting by including "sometimes", so as to encourage debate. It wasn't a deliberate trick or anything sinister!

 

[Bold Seagull]

I wouldn't say brilliant, just a little bit funny.

but then again no.

 

[jcdenton08]

I do like him, if not all his music.

He knows he an ordinary lad who became an impossible diva through drugs and fame.

He's never forgotten where he came from. I love his story about knowing when he had absolutely lost it when he called down at his hotel in London and asked them to do something about the wind.

Wasn't that impressed with his autobiography to be honest.

I found Be an interesting read, albeit not sympathetic.

My opinion of the guy is that he is exceptionally talented, wonderful pianist, songwriter and singer. The last sort of person I'd want to know in real life - and that is just based on his own words, nobody else's.

 

[Icy Gull]

I was a MASSIVE Elton fan in his early days. Nothing wrong with the music he did when he went all outrageous but it wasn’t for me. My favourite album was Tumbleweed Connection, still sounding good today to me

https://youtu.be/EdEQkRq_xrw

 

[vegster]

I do like him, if not all his music.

He knows he an ordinary lad who became an impossible diva through drugs and fame.

He's never forgotten where he came from. I love his story about knowing when he had absolutely lost it when he called down at his hotel in London and asked them to do something about the wind.

Wasn't that impressed with his autobiography to be honest.

I remember him doing an interview and he was asked about Bernie Taupin and their partnership....

he said " Bernie was always very understanding over the years".... " He wrote the lyrics to probably one of the greatest songs ever, Candle In the Wind,and he never batted an eyelid when I performed it in front of 100,000 people at The Dodgers Stadium dressed as Donald Duck."

 

[clapham_gull]

but then again no.

 

[jcdenton08]

Thriker!

 

[clapham_gull]

I found Be an interesting read, albeit not sympathetic.

My opinion of the guy is that he is exceptionally talented, wonderful pianist, songwriter and singer. The last sort of person I'd want to know in real life - and that is just based on his own words, nobody else's.

Oh come on. I'd love Elton to live next door. Keep a spare set of keys, the odd barbeque etc..

 

[Cotton Socks]

I went to see him and Eric Clapton at Wembley in '92. I went to see Eric and it seemed like a bizarre combination (which it was). He is good live but some of his releases make me want to turn the radio off, on the flip side a couple of them make me want to turn the volume up.

 

[jcdenton08]

Oh come on. I'd love Elton to live next door. Keep a spare set of keys, the odd barbeque etc..

I'd really like his money...?

 

[French Seagull]

He is good, even if you don't like his songs

 

[clapham_gull]

I'd really like his money...?

I'd say all right, Elton.

- Hello, didn’t know you moved in.

Yeah, just moved in, last week. I’m having a barbecue, fancy coming over?

- I’d love to, do you mind if I bring my piano ?

I’d rather you didn’t, it’s not that kind of an evening. Do like Mini Kiev’s?

- I love them, but David's a vegetarian.

Doesn’t matter he can have fish.

- No, he won’t eat that either.

OH FORGET IT! You people!

 

[DavidinSouthampton]

Saw him at Wembley circa 75. He was headline. On the bill were The Eagles, The Beach Boys, Joe Walsh, Chakka Khan and Stackridge.

Thousands (including me) walked out during BBBBenny.BBBBenny.BBBBenny.BBBenny... (etc) Tw@t.

This is good though.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3p_xAToFzck

We saw him at St Mary’s Stadium about 10 years ago - maybe more. He opened with Pinball Wizard, but soon after came Funeral for a friend. Whole family, me, wife and two daughters, thought it amazing. He also did Tiny Dancer, which has been a favourite of mine since I first heard it in 1972.

We also saw him about 30 years ago - maybe more - when he was on stage by himself for about 45 minutes, and then the percussionist Ray Cooper was revealed when the set opened up. Tremendous.

Great music for the most part and a very talented performer and a showman.

 

[herecomesaregular]

I was a MASSIVE Elton fan in his early days. Nothing wrong with the music he did when he went all outrageous but it wasn’t for me. My favourite album was Tumbleweed Connection, still sounding good today to me

https://youtu.be/EdEQkRq_xrw

This is the only Elton John album I own (on replica gatefold mini sleeve CD from Japan) because it is utterly brilliant from start to finish. Although you've not posted the strongest song on it imho.

 

[Tyrone Biggums]

My Grandma listened to him.

 

[Insel affe]

My Grandma listened to him.

So did mine up until his 2nd marriage that is.

 

[Live by the sea]

Further to Swansman's recommendation, I have to second it. Probably the best act I've seen live (or top 5 in the hundreds I've seen).

One of the best. Agree?

Have seen him live on a couple of occasions, he is very good . Billy Joel is equally as good in my opinion , seen him 5 times at Madison square garden over the years .