Dunk or Greer

[GingerBeerMan]

Dunk or Greer for 1st choice CB alongside Upson?

 

[Weststander]

Greer's lack of pace is a concern. Dunk for the moment.

 

[portslade seagull]

Dunk does not deserve to be dropped

 

[supaseagull]

Dunk is the future. Excellent game tonight.

 

[PoG]

Greer; get rid.

 

[Luke93]

Dunk has done nothing wrong. Keep him in the side, and benefit from his improved performances (created by the pressure to not be dropped for Greer)!

 

[Simster]

Dunk. If I'm Garcia, I want Dunk playing as many games alongside a proven ex England international as possible before he has to retire.

Besides, Dunk barely put a foot wrong tonight so really shouldn't be dropped.

 

[catfish]

Dunk has made the most of his opportunity with that performance. He should keep his place as a result.

 

[Blue3]

Dunk is the future. Excellent game tonight.

However Greer is I think the more steady it's a close run thing but Dunk is still young and prone to the odd rush in to tackle he did one tonight missed the ball and player could have left the forward with an open goal but was covered by Andrews

 

[shaolinpunk]

I'd like to see Dunk have a run in the team, but you can't be surprised when Garcia reinstates Greer into one of the best defences in the league

 

[big nuts]

Greer; get rid.

Very harsh I voted for Dunk but I wouldn't write Greer off his been consistently good throughout the season.

 

[Napper]

Dunk class tonight

 

[BrianWade4]

After tonight...... Dunk from now on

 

[Perkino]

Either if them play the roll very well, Greer is overall a better player but Dunk is his obvious long term replacement.

At what point do we look to the future and start developing Dunk with the anticipation he will be there for a long time

 

[Claude samdamme]

Very harsh I voted for Dunk but I wouldn't write Greer off his been consistently good throughout the season.

this

The Greer hate is foolish - him + upson are statistically the best centre backs in the division. Dunk is the future and was excellent tonight but Greer is a top championship centre back, one of our best players and captain

 

[Captain Sensible]

Dunk for the next game at least but 1st choice always? still gotta be Greer. Dunk deserves a few games now though.

 

[brightonmark1234]

Dunk and I would make Greer work for his place back in the team and I wouldnt change the back 5 as I thought they all played well against qpr

 

[Brighton Breezy]

Dunk. His use of the ball is better than Greer's and he is dominant in the air.

Nothing against Greer, just feel Dunk deserves to keep his place.

No doubt there will be some people still churning out the theory that Dunk gives up at least one howler a game based purely on his sending off at Selhurst while ignoring similar mistakes from Greer.

 

[GingerBeerMan]

This wasn't as close as I imagined...

This season El Abd, Greer and Dunk have all been brilliant when they've played, the one constant in this being Upson alongside them. Upson could be the best signing we've made in years, we need to extend his contract; he's my POTS this year.

 

[stss30]

Dunk is the future. Don't think he should be dropped after being one of our best players last night, but I'll trust Oscar in whatever he decides to do.