[Albion] Decisions that have gone against us
- Thread starter kevo
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Indeed. And simply looking at VAR decisions that go for or against us isn't particularly useful...VAR could have got it right! Plus, even where VAR decisions have gone against us, they may not have changed the result (eg: Liverpool at Home, Leicester at Home, Wolves Away....we won all these, despite VAR decisions going aganist us). There are also "dodgy" decisions that don't go to VAR (for example, Bournemouth could easily have had two penalties in the game at our place).
Of course the really egregious errors (at Spurs and Palace) will rankle. But it's a complete waste of time harking back to them.
I am still not having we should not have had a very late pen against Brentford. His arm was out. It hit his arm. Players stopped blocking (even from close) with their arms out because they keep giving pens for that. It was a stone wall pen imo. I don’t care how close you are. If you arm is there and it gets hit then it is a pen. Look at the Brentford player’s reaction ffs. He knew it had to be a pen.
Attachments
Garry Nelson's Left Foot
Well-known member
It's not a great look to be constantly banging on about random decisions that don't go our way. Every team has them every single season. They are the decisions that more or less even themselves out over a season.
Our only real complaint should be VAR and the three apologies we've received for their incompetence.
1) Villa. We lost that game but if VAR had got that right we'd potentially be either 2 points behind or 1 ahead of them so it's an error that could cost us a European place.
2) Palace. An almost definite two lost points thanks to someone drawing the lines from the wrong defender. This is the one that absolutely blows my mind.
3)Spurs. Multiple decisions but the apology was for missing the penalty on Mitoma. If we'd got the correct decision we most likely win or at least draw which would leave us either two ahead of them or one behind.
If we say that we would have drawn with villa and Spurs and beaten Palace that would put us on 53 points, Villa on 52 and Spurs 51. Fifth place with an outside shot at the top 4. If we go best case scenario and say we'd have won them all we'd be on 57 points, 2 behind Man u with a game in hand and 2 behind Newcastle with two games in hand.
These are the decisions that need to be highlighted, not dubious calls that might have gone against us. The clear, solid mistakes, no ambiguity in them, that have cost us. Moaning about anything else is counterproductive and risks losing the wheat in the chaff.
Our only real complaint should be VAR and the three apologies we've received for their incompetence.
1) Villa. We lost that game but if VAR had got that right we'd potentially be either 2 points behind or 1 ahead of them so it's an error that could cost us a European place.
2) Palace. An almost definite two lost points thanks to someone drawing the lines from the wrong defender. This is the one that absolutely blows my mind.
3)Spurs. Multiple decisions but the apology was for missing the penalty on Mitoma. If we'd got the correct decision we most likely win or at least draw which would leave us either two ahead of them or one behind.
If we say that we would have drawn with villa and Spurs and beaten Palace that would put us on 53 points, Villa on 52 and Spurs 51. Fifth place with an outside shot at the top 4. If we go best case scenario and say we'd have won them all we'd be on 57 points, 2 behind Man u with a game in hand and 2 behind Newcastle with two games in hand.
These are the decisions that need to be highlighted, not dubious calls that might have gone against us. The clear, solid mistakes, no ambiguity in them, that have cost us. Moaning about anything else is counterproductive and risks losing the wheat in the chaff.
Mo Gosfield
Well-known member
- Aug 11, 2010
- 6,362
Well....we need the next four seasons of two more VAR decisions going for us than against us each season, just to even up this season. I will keep a record and if we are both still here in 4 seasons time, we can compare notes.
VAR can change. Fans can put pressure on clubs. Clubs can put pressure on the PL. The media can keep highlighting it. Firstly, deal with the officials involved. Use more ex-players and managers. Show clearly, within the ground, the picture used to determine the decision and communicate that audibly to the fans. Consider an appeal system. Each side gets two reviews a game ( yes, I know the time factor....stop the clock....that should be in every ground in the country....so we all know how much time is really remaining )
The problem with this is you've ignored decisions that other teams haven't got which has cost them points as well.
If the three cock-ups we have received apologies for cost us a place in Europe, it will never even up. Not only will it deprive us of a Euroean adventure, it will make keeping the band together in the summer even harder - and if certain players do go (they might anyway, but more likely to do so if we can't offer them European football), there is no guarantee that we'll be able to repeat, let alone better, what we've achieved this season.
Last edited:
AstroSloth
Well-known member
- Dec 29, 2020
- 1,380
Against Fulham, Mitoma getting round Tete and being pulled so hard his number was on the front of his shirt, then tripped by Tete's leg so he couldn't get to the ball that was his for the taking.
Should have been a pen.
Should have been a pen.
- Apr 5, 2014
- 25,940
There is, of course, no guarantee that the outcome of those games would have been better, although our position in those games would have improved. Butterfly effect.
I would balance this by saying that fans of other clubs may well have their own lists.
What we can establish is that VAR is not doing the intended job.
Deleted member 37369
Well-known member
- Aug 21, 2018
- 1,994
It’s a really tough thing to do … but you are right!
Coldeanseagull
Opinionated
Manure might still get a VAR decision from last year!
sussex_guy2k2
Well-known member
- Jun 6, 2014
- 4,082
And these are just the ones that are so bad that they have to actually apologise for.
I can think of loads more that have been pretty blatantly wrong that they’ve not apologised for.
Indeed. I would guess that there isn't a set of fans anywhere saying how they have done well with decisions going their way. We all see the ones that go against us and forget the ones that don't.
Yes, of course it is.
Our 2 goals’ against Spurs wind me up the most.
They didn’t award the first one( Mitomas) because it wasn’t given on the pitch and wasn’t a clear and obvious error.
The 2nd one was chalked off because of a handball by MacA. Although the decision wasn’t clear and obvious, they still disallowed a goal that had been given on the pitch. There is no definite image of the ball striking Macs arm.
If you disallow the first goal, for the reasons given, you can’t disallow the second goal.
They didn’t award the first one( Mitomas) because it wasn’t given on the pitch and wasn’t a clear and obvious error.
The 2nd one was chalked off because of a handball by MacA. Although the decision wasn’t clear and obvious, they still disallowed a goal that had been given on the pitch. There is no definite image of the ball striking Macs arm.
If you disallow the first goal, for the reasons given, you can’t disallow the second goal.
The Wookiee
Back From The Dead
A couple of the top of my head:
Sanchez handball outside the area against Grimsby ?
Leicesters disallowed goals for ‘offside’ last season ?
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
It wasn’t handball as proved by VAR. The full circumference of the ball wasn’t out of the area.