Deadline day bids for Ulloa, Bridcutt, Barnes and KLL from Palace

[yxee]

Camana Chamackh Gayle and Puncheon would stroll into most Championship sides including ours.

Chamackh scored his first goal in about 3 years, Gayle scored once in the premier league and never played above league 1 before.... that's crazy

No idea who camana is, Puncheon is the only player with a decent record in that entire list

They have one player who'd walk into every championship club (bar QPR), and he's not walking anywhere for the time being (ba dum tss)

 

[deletebeepbeepbeep]

Chamakh has four goals in 3 years so doubt it.

Campana has pace of a snail.

Puncheon is hit or miss much like Buckley or Lua Lua.

Yes a limited return but playing for a team where he was second fiddle to RVP or injured, would still be an incredible signing for a championship team.

Campana is the Spanish u20 Captain.


Puncheon is a proven premier league quality winger.

To say they wouldn't walk into our side is just deluded, sorry.

 

[nwgull]

Sounds like petty revenge for Poogate to me. Make 4 average bids knowing they probably won't be successful. This though serves well to opening up an unsettling process for those 4 players and makes January even more nerve wracking in my eyes. It would matter not if the Caravaners bid again or not.

Chances are that going to Palace in January won't be a very attractive prospect to a player with Premier League aspirations.

 

[middletoenail]

Yes a limited return but playing for a team where he was second fiddle to RVP or injured, would still be an incredible signing for a championship team.

Campana is the Spanish u20 Captain.


Puncheon is a proven premier league quality winger.

To say they wouldn't walk into our side is just deluded, sorry.

Walk into our squad yes, into our starting 11, I'm not so sure.

 

[albionite]

Do we need another thread on who has the best players? Been a nice nigel free day this thread will just attract them back.

 

[Albion Dan]

Occasional poster here diskodoctor actually bumped into Steve Parish in Soho yesterday and asked him about the bids. From the horses mouth was £2m for Bridcutt (which is also what they paid for the Forest lad) and £4m plus add ons for Ulloa. Nothing on bids for the others.

 

[Hyperion]

Chances are that going to Palace in January won't be a very attractive prospect to a player with Premier League aspirations.

Maybe so, but agents and hungry players mean it would not need to be Palace they offer themselves to for their services

 

[Barrel of Fun]

Occasional poster here diskodoctor actually bumped into Steve Parish in Soho yesterday

I hope the bump left a mark after such derisory bids.

 

[SeagullSongs]

Sounds like petty revenge for Poogate to me. Make 4 average bids knowing they probably won't be successful. This though serves well to opening up an unsettling process for those 4 players and makes January even more nerve wracking in my eyes. It would matter not if the Caravaners bid again or not.

Surely a bid only unsettles a player if they want a move to that club?

Palace don't really seem like the sort of club to place 'unsettling' bids

 

[Insel affe]

£4m plus add ons for Ulloa. Nothing on bids for the others.

That add on would have to be add on another £6m you pikey feckers !

 

[churley1]

Calling us petty for revengeful bids after the 'poogate' incident? Not only is that a baseless opinion, it sounds like you're trying to make sense of the disgusting nature of one of your so called officials behaviour.

We made bids, they were rejected and that's it, do you think Reading hold a grudge against Palace after we bought 2 of their best players? Doubtful

Some of the comments on this thread are incredibly wide of the mark.

 

[Insel affe]

Arsenal were willing to pay Bendtner £3m just to fook off, and he still wouldn't go to Palace

I heard that Bendtner turned up at Selhurst park with his agent and refused to get out the car, he sent his agent in to tell them nah, he must have thought I will sit in the reserves rather than play here.

 

[Barrel of Fun]

Calling us petty for revengeful bids after the 'poogate' incident? Not only is that a baseless opinion, it sounds like you're trying to make sense of the disgusting nature of one of your so called officials behaviour.

We made bids, they were rejected and that's it, do you think Reading hold a grudge against Palace after we bought 2 of their best players? Doubtful

Some of the comments on this thread are incredibly wide of the mark.

Poohgate. Are you going to post some facts and evidence?

 

[hans kraay fan club]

Calling us petty for revengeful bids after the 'poogate' incident? Not only is that a baseless opinion, it sounds like you're trying to make sense of the disgusting nature of one of your so called officials behaviour.

We made bids, they were rejected and that's it, do you think Reading hold a grudge against Palace after we bought 2 of their best players? Doubtful

Some of the comments on this thread are incredibly wide of the mark.

You paid good money for players they didn't want, and were not using. I'm sure they are happy enough.

 

[Hyperion]

Surely a bid only unsettles a player if they want a move to that club?

Palace don't really seem like the sort of club to place 'unsettling' bids

I don't think that is the case. If a player thinks a team in a Division above wants him, he will probably want to set his ambitions a little stronger

 

[Barrel of Fun]

Raiding Reading for their best players?

 

[churley1]

You paid good money for players they didn't want, and were not using. I'm sure they are happy enough.

One was injured and scored 1 in 3 at Prem level last season, the other the fans say was their best defender last season but has a disagreement with Adkins, like many on here actually!

Relieved we didn't get Barnes or KLL, the latter especially as he seems a bit of a loose cannon.

 

[Horses Arse]

What a bizare club - I wonder whether Holloway is suffering from some sort of breakdown. Paying 800k + for Dobbie is very odd, then sending him straight out on loan is odder. I then hear he signed Lorein Marange from Bordeaux on 16th Aug on a years contract and then omits him from the 25 man squad!

Absolute lunacy!

 

[churley1]

What a bizare club - I wonder whether Holloway is suffering from some sort of breakdown. Paying 800k + for Dobbie is very odd, then sending him straight out on loan is odder. I then hear he signed Lorein Marange from Bordeaux on 16th Aug on a years contract and then omits him from the 25 man squad!

Absolute lunacy!

I'm inclined to agree with you about Marange, clearly a panic signing but fitting 25 players into a squad is something Championship clubs don't have to worry about and until recently, we were one.

The Dobbie transfer was set in stone from when we loaned him, I feel for the bloke though.

 

[Stat Brother]

I heard that Bendtner turned up at Selhurst park with his agent and refused to get out the car, he sent his agent in to tell them nah, he must have thought I will sit in the reserves rather than play here.

Nah:-
they pulled up,
SSN got very excited,
Nicky B got out and walked in,
SSN ramped it up still further,
10 mins later Nicky B returns to the car and they leave as fast as humanly possible.