Beach Hut
Brighton Bhuna Boy
Not a goal as the illusion of the rippled net is created by Painter the ball hit the bar - clever of Savage to do that though
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Dagenham aggrieved by 'goal' that wasn't
- Thread starter clippedgull
- Start date
Should have gone to specsavers big nuts! Watch it on replay and in slo-mo, it definitely, DEFINITELY hits the bar. However, at the same time, the net is pulled out of shape, and the bar pulled lower, by Painter falling into the net.
jordanseagull
Well-known member
- Feb 11, 2009
- 4,151
Why so much confusion!? Just like every other "bar hit", it hit the bar and flew out? Only a tennis racket would produce a strong enough defence to make the ball react in the way it did.
A goal?
A goal?
jordanseagull
Well-known member
- Feb 11, 2009
- 4,151
And how can a solid bar be pulled down by an attatched net? No chance.
NMH
Banned
It's a marvelous sound, kind of "ffl-bew-fshhhh"
Unless it's in our net, then it sounds like shit.
Have you never seen a goalkeeper jump up and touch the cross bar before a match and seen it wobble? Or even tipping a shot/cross over the bar or grabbing the bar as if to check where it is when a ball is going over and seen it shake? It's a long poll of lightweightish material that is held at each end, it isn't usually solid and unbendable
Is my screen cap not showing up for people? I thought it showed conclusively that the ball hit the crossbar. (post 54 in this thread)
Yes it looks odd, but after seeing replays, how can anyone really believe that hit the net and came flying back out? We all like to take the piss out of the officials, but fortunately they seem to have a much better grip on physics than the bright sparks here.
Goal? Are you blind (or joking)? It clearly hits the bar. And do you really think Savage wouldn't have been up screaming at the ref and linesman, instead of lying on the floor thinking 'oh shit, they're going to stick this on howler of the week'?
I think you missed his follow up post:
Weird. Watched it AGAIN, and changed my mind.
Bar.
No Goal.
I did, thanks.
Guy Fawkes
The voice of treason
- Sep 29, 2007
- 8,297
I was there in the stand behind the goal but in one of the front rows towards to opposite side of the pitch from the TV cameras, it definitely hit the bar and not the net.
Looking at the tv coverage you can see why their manager might think it went in but in slow motion you can clearly see it hit the front of the bar and came back out and never even got close to crossing the line. I would also add that there is no way the ball could have hit the net at the top of the goal and bounce back out as it did, and it never got anyway near the back of the goal to hit the net there and come back out, so the only logical place it could have hit and rebounded as it did was the bar.
Looking at the tv coverage you can see why their manager might think it went in but in slow motion you can clearly see it hit the front of the bar and came back out and never even got close to crossing the line. I would also add that there is no way the ball could have hit the net at the top of the goal and bounce back out as it did, and it never got anyway near the back of the goal to hit the net there and come back out, so the only logical place it could have hit and rebounded as it did was the bar.
I watched it again on the Sky Sports website and it clearly hits the bar. Fair enough!
Hove Seagull
Well-known member
It hit that invisible shield thing we've had in place over our goal for the last 7 months!
c0lz
North East Stand.
oh dear Bas savage howler of the week confirms it was a miss
jordanseagull
Well-known member
- Feb 11, 2009
- 4,151
Yes of course but that is direct contact with the bar, not the net. I don't believe that flying into the BACK of the net affects the bar whatsoever. Especially as the video shows that the net actually pulls the bar toward the away fans (if at all) and there is hardly any downward force. If someone fell on top of the net that's a different matter
Joe Gatting's Dad
New member
I looked across and for once we had a linesman who was up with play and in the right position to give the correct decision.
Sam Ovett
The New Manager Bus
Bar!
Lord Bamber
Legendary Chairman
The sound I heard was the sound of a footie ball hitting a crossbar as it rebounded away.
Anyway, bar or net, that excellent ref type chap did not give it and in the years to come Daggers 0 - 1 Albion is all that will remain in the record books of the game.
Savage's reaction show's exactly what he thought and I would say he was perfectly placed to analyse what was a hilarious f*ck up it was.
Anyway, bar or net, that excellent ref type chap did not give it and in the years to come Daggers 0 - 1 Albion is all that will remain in the record books of the game.
Savage's reaction show's exactly what he thought and I would say he was perfectly placed to analyse what was a hilarious f*ck up it was.
Yes of course but that is direct contact with the bar, not the net. I don't believe that flying into the BACK of the net affects the bar whatsoever. Especially as the video shows that the net actually pulls the bar toward the away fans (if at all) and there is hardly any downward force. If someone fell on top of the net that's a different matter
But the net should be securely attached, or else it could come loose allowing for the ball to slip through. It's why the linesmen check the nets before the game.
The way painter fell into the net would have pulled back initially and then down as he fell to the ground.