Pavilionaire
Well-known member
- Jul 7, 2003
- 31,273
This is such a nonsense argument. Ulloa wasn't playing. I could ping balls into the box in my 6-a-side team and say 'well if Van Persie had been playing we would have scored". If his game is just hitting the ball into the box and hoping that there is a big strong striker in there to put the ball in the net then he isn't up to standard. This is Championship football, not Sunday League.
Just to be clear, I'm not saying that is his game at all, he doesn't deserve some of the criticism be comes in for, but the whole "if Ulloa was playing" argument doesn't stack up. If Ronaldo was playing instead of Crofts then we probably would have scored a couple of our outside the box half chances.
My remark was made in the context of the thread title that he is the worst loan signing we've ever made. The fact he can get repeat crosses into the 6-yard box by itself disproves the OP.
And I disagree that the fact Ulloa is out is irrelevant. If you have a guy who can cross the ball then hang on to him. We let Noone go because he couldn't cross, Conway is clearly better in that department. I'm sure if Chas and Dave were up front for Spurs Andros Townsend's stats would look shabby too.