If people didn't vote on who they had seen then Charlie Webb would win hands down. I didn't know quite how long he was manager. Add in the Charity Shield winning goal.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_Webb
I love the quote - A Guardian retrospective on the club, written in 1973, described how "Brighton had a skilful team usually playing to the top six" under Webb, "whose transfer acquisitions were as often as not costed on the price of his train ticket and buffet sandwiches"
Webb is really the clear winner: player, manager and, I believe, secretary too. He was with the club for nearly 40 years - there can't have been many greater servants of any club. He's certainly the only player on the list who's been called Mr Brighton.
Quite honestly it should be Webb first and the rest nowhere ... but we know it won't be