Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Football] Champions League 2023-24











Hotchilidog

Well-known member
Jan 24, 2009
9,162
Referee in the City / Real game has been absolutely superb.

Might bookmark this for the next Brighton ref meltdown thread. It’s not that I hate referees, it’s that our domestic ones are comparatively terrible.
Totally agree, and as anyone who has the misfortune to sit near me knows, I‘m not a huge fan of our refs. I thought the City Madrid ref was fantastic, he never bought the histrionics from both sides and let them serve up a cracking game of attacking football.
 


Hugo Rune

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Feb 23, 2012
23,815
Brighton
Idiots keown and thicky Ferdinand adamant it's a penalty
Ex-Arsenal pundit Upson demonstrating how the no dickhead policy was already in full operation when he signed for the Albion.

Looks like Saka has initiated the contact'

FT: Arsenal 2-2 Bayern Munich
463e8524-38a0-4fad-9ffa-60f1827b7dc1.jpg

Matt Upson
Former England defender on BBC Radio 5 Live
“I think it was the correct call not to award a penalty in the end.
On first instinct you think it has to be given, but having looked at a replay it looks like Bukayo Saka has initiated the contact. Manuel Neuer puts the breaks on as he rushes out and Saka almost kicks him in the end.
A really good call from the referee under incredible pressure.”
BBC
 




METALMICKY

Well-known member
Jan 30, 2004
6,935
Idiots keown and thicky Ferdinand adamant it's a penalty
Curiously having now watched the front on angle replay it does make it look like the keeper hangs his leg out a bit. However, from side angle it clearly shows Saka thrusting his leg out. Even funnier since had Saka had been honest he might have got the decision.
 


















Easy 10

Brain dead MUG SHEEP
Jul 5, 2003
62,465
Location Location
You'd usually expect the games at this stage, first leg, to be cagey affairs. But both of these were absolute BANGERS.

Have UEFA finally made a decent decision in binning off the away goals rule ? It would appear so. The fear-factor has been removed, leading to more of a straight shootout.

Tremendous entertainment.
 


METALMICKY

Well-known member
Jan 30, 2004
6,935
Munich manager said it wasn't given as the ref said it was a kids mistake
You can kind of see what the ref is saying. It's soft and ridiculous in a game of this importance. However, the counter argument is that according to the laws it's a penalty and the ref should not be making subjective ' for the good of the game ' decisions.

It makes you wonder why a Arteta has been uncharacteristically quiet about the Saka penalty shout. Is he just quietly seething or keeping his head down as he knows they got away with one. Just maybe he's given Saka a rollicking for trying to cheat when it was easier to try and score?
 




Kinky Gerbil

Im The Scatman
NSC Patron
Jul 16, 2003
58,808
hassocks
You can kind of see what the ref is saying. It's soft and ridiculous in a game of this importance. However, the counter argument is that according to the laws it's a penalty and the ref should not be making subjective ' for the good of the game ' decisions.

It makes you wonder why a Arteta has been uncharacteristically quiet about the Saka penalty shout. Is he just quietly seething or keeping his head down as he knows they got away with one. Just maybe he's given Saka a rollicking for trying to cheat when it was easier to try and score?
Does it matter what game it is? Can refs decide what games are important?

Its like the argument about booking a player early, if its a booking its a booking
 




Simster

"the man's an arse"
Jul 7, 2003
55,020
Surrey
You'd usually expect the games at this stage, first leg, to be cagey affairs. But both of these were absolute BANGERS.

Have UEFA finally made a decent decision in binning off the away goals rule ? It would appear so. The fear-factor has been removed, leading to more of a straight shootout.

Tremendous entertainment.
The away goals rule should have been removed the minute the back-pass rule was proven to be a complete success (about one season after it was introduced). In my opinion, the risk of boring matches through gamesmanship and cheating was greatly reduced from that point onwards. People complain of time wasting now, but in those days it was on another level. I'll never forget Uruguay 0-0 Scotland in 1986 where Uruguay needed a point, had a man sent off early on, and spent the entire game passing the ball back to their keeper. It was shocking.

Anyway as such, the away goals rule is no longer relevant and arguably you could say the same about 3 points for a win in the league.
 






hans kraay fan club

The voice of reason.
Helpful Moderator
Mar 16, 2005
62,840
Chandlers Ford
Saka….pffft…throws his right leg out ……ridiculous by Saka

Great reffing. Saka tried it on.

Great refereeing not to fall for Saka’s ‘penalty’.

Blatent cheating from Saka who then has the nerve to complain.

Superb by the ref and idiotic by Saka. He quite clearly throws his leg towards the keeper. Instead of initiating that contact it would have been easier to try and take the ball past the keeper.

CHEATS NEVER PROSPER!
My brother in law had £10 on Bayern HT / Arsenal FT @ 30/1 or similar. He's probably not a huge fan of Saka right now!
 


trueblue

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
11,026
Hove
Where was VAR in that? OK - maybe an error by the defender, but then you could say that about all misjudgements leading to free-kicks / penalties?
Really weird one this. Arsenal's best defence - although it doesn't prevent it from being a penalty - is that he simply hadn't heard the whistle. In those circumstances, it would be great sportsmanship to accept the explanation. It's not as if it made any difference to the game or Bayern were about to score.

Ah 'sportsmanship'.. there's a long forgotten concept.
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here