Cardiff move in for Noone

[ArcticBlue]

hope not. He has become one of my favourite players. A true professional who seems very passionate about the game and always gives his all

Agree with this. Cannot see why he would move on at the moment. Cannot see Gus selling him either. We are not in the position to attract viable alternatives yet. There are plenty of teams with more money and a higher league position. Although that should change next season.

Just read the post above. 400K, you are having a laugh.

 

[PriapismBoy]

500,000 that's insulting

 

[Steve Foster]

500,000 that's insulting

If we throw in Ankergen & Harley for free..........

(cheap joke, I know!)

 

[Mackenzie]

Perhaps we should put in a bid for Whittingham?

 

[hans kraay fan club]

He's very good BUT if we're flying a flag to get him up to £1m or £2m it then gets interesting as to where you put him with Kaz & Buckley as all 3 ain't gonna start...I'd say the 3 we're our best players unfortunately in similar positions...think 3 great, similar goalkeepers, you'd move one on, wouldn't you??

Analogy doesn't work - 3 keepers leaves 2 spares. 3 wingers can mean 2 starting, plus an impact sub.

 

[Billy the Fish]

£400,000 is laughable. We throw that away nearly every game bcause we're too lazy to sell more pies

He's been our best player this season, mabybe at £1.5 mill I would start to think about taking the money, and only then because we have KLL and Buckley in our squad.

 

[New Carpet?]

£400k? Really?

I'm assuming Cardiff are thinking we're heading for administration and are having some kind of fire sale.

 

[public school boy]

why would a club trying to get into the premiership want to sell it's best players?

 

[hitony]

Poppycock, unknown rag from the Valleys. He maybe scouse and tone deaf when it comes to singing, but stupid he ain't...Cardiff ffs!

Far from it.

 

[PriapismBoy]

£400,000 is laughable. We throw that away nearly every game bcause we're too lazy to sell more pies

He's been our best player this season, mabybe at £1.5 mill I would start to think about taking the money, and only then because we have KLL and Buckley in our squad.

It wouldn't think about accepting 1.5 mill, KLL is good but on and off and Buckley seem to get injured all the time. If the club is really thinking about getting us to the PL we need to keep hold of our best players

 

[Captain Sensible]

Do Cardiff think we are still in league2 to offer that sort of money?
2million minimum, otherwise do one!

 

[ees complicated no?]

Wow how stupid can they get.

 

[PriapismBoy]

Do Cardiff think we are still in league2 to offer that sort of money?
2million minimum, otherwise do one!

They can do one anyway

 

[Mendoza]

500,000 that's insulting

why is it though? It's £200k more than we paid for him. He has been off form in recent weeks, and doesnt go round players nearly as easily as Buckley or LuaLua.

I am no means saying Noone is rubbish, but I dont understand how a year later after paying £300k for someone, fans are suddenly thinking we have £1million+ player

How much did we pay for LuaLua, as good if not better than Noone?

 

[British Bulldog]

£400,000 is laughable. We throw that away nearly every game bcause we're too lazy to sell more pies

He's been our best player this season, mabybe at £1.5 mill I would start to think about taking the money, and only then because we have KLL and Buckley in our squad.

£1.5m? No chance I'd be surprised if we got any more than £750k plus add on's.

 

[Trigger]

How much did we pay for LuaLua, as good if not better than Noone?

And he has a final product on the end of his skill!

 

[Mackenzie]

why is it though? It's £200k more than we paid for him. He has been off form in recent weeks, and doesnt go round players nearly as easily as Buckley or LuaLua.

I am no means saying Noone is rubbish, but I dont understand how a year later after paying £300k for someone, fans are suddenly thinking we have £1million+ player

How much did we pay for LuaLua, as good if not better than Noone?

At £300k we ripped off Plymouth! He has been running rings around Championship full backs all season, that's why Cardiff are interested.

 

[bhawoddy]

what a cheeky bid - 500k!!!

He's proven at champ level now and is more than young enough to improve beyond anything we have at brighton - 500k!!!!!! Fking liberty - Thats the craziest offer ive ever seen.

 

[New Carpet?]

why is it though? It's £200k more than we paid for him. He has been off form in recent weeks, and doesnt go round players nearly as easily as Buckley or LuaLua.

I am no means saying Noone is rubbish, but I dont understand how a year later after paying £300k for someone, fans are suddenly thinking we have £1million+ player

How much did we pay for LuaLua, as good if not better than Noone?

Noone has come on in leaps and bounds in the past year and even if his form in the past month or two has been a bit indifferent, surely he's still worth more now than he was this time last year. In the main, he's played very well at a higher level and caused countless problems for opposing teams.

Also, given Plymouth's financial predicament last year, could it also be that we got hold of a player for £300k that should have actually cost us much more had Plymouth not been in so much trouble?

Like you, I don't think Noone is worth a fortune, but £400k is a ridiculously low offer in my opinion.

 

[NMH]

We could put in a bid or 3 million for Lionel Messi - that would be as tangible.

Ken Brown isn't commenting on transfer speculation. Tjhat must mean it's true! .....er.....or that he doesn't want to spend the next month addressing every ridiculour newspaper who needs a few lines to fill their columns, no matter how bizarre and outlandish they may be.
Every club wants to buy every other club's best players - that's it in a nutshell and I can ignore the rest of the transfer period, just noting when the club announce a new signing or sale.