I understand we have to let players move on if Premiership clubs come sniffing, but our situation has changed drastically in a very short space of time. If clubs want our best players now we shouldn't be letting them go to better themselves, we should be demanding top dollar for them. I want £8 million plus for someone as quality as Dunk, if we let him go like we did Bennett and Crofts then we'd be mugs. I should point out that we had to let EB and AC go, but I think we under valued them, we shouldn't have to now.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Brighton boss Gus Poyet warns Lewis Dunk suitors BBC Website
- Thread starter Smirko
- Start date
Lush
Mods' Pet
World of difference between the price of top League 1 player and the price of a top Championship player, even when they are effectively the same player.
If we sold Elliott Bennet now, we'd get more for him.
If we sold Elliott Bennet now, we'd get more for him.
Discodoktor
Active member
Villa tabs on Dunk
Villa are also eyeing up Championship talent with January in mind, keeping tabs on Brighton’s rising defensive star Lewis Dunk.
http://www.expressandstar.com/sport/2011/09/14/latest-transfer-rumours-sept-14-2/
Also in the sun
Villa are also eyeing up Championship talent with January in mind, keeping tabs on Brighton’s rising defensive star Lewis Dunk.
http://www.expressandstar.com/sport/2011/09/14/latest-transfer-rumours-sept-14-2/
Also in the sun
The Large One
Who's Next?
This is astounding. How many league starts does he have under his belt?
NINE.
NINE.
Albumen
Don't wait for me!
Presumably he's supported the Albion all his life? Now that we're on the up I doubt he'd want to leave. If we go up then he'll stay, if we don't we may need the extra cash. He's only 19, he wont go anyway.
Left Footer
Well-known member
But he is absolute quality, in comparison to Chris Smalling he is a far more composed player.
grummitts gloves
New member
The Large One
Who's Next?
Agreed. We know what he can do - but he hasn't proved it over a given period.
Who is going to cough up silly money for someone so... inexperienced?
Jimmy's gonna get ya!
New member
- Oct 6, 2010
- 548
I hope the club are drawing up an improved contract for him sharpish. He is one of the lowest paid in the squad currently.
theonesmith
Well-known member
- Oct 27, 2008
- 2,337
Aspinall carried a fair bit of that in his time
Never had a chance to see him play, was he particularly good?
theonesmith
Well-known member
- Oct 27, 2008
- 2,337
Stumpy Tim
Well-known member
Of course, some young Championship-established players go for a lot less than the £10 million being mentioned here. We picked up a useful winger for £1m from Watford for example
Twinkle Toes
Growing old disgracefully
If I hadn't been born & raised a Villa supporter I'd cheerfully tell Big 'Eck to f***ing well do one! That said, if we (The REAL Albion) can't hold on to Master Dunk when crazy lucre is flying around in January, I think he'd be a brilliant aquisition & I'm sure his talent would be carefully nurtured at Villa Park. The worse case scenario for me (& probably for young Lewis) is if he went to a club with more money than is healthy & hardly gets any first team football. I bloody well hope he stays put though, at least for this season...
Left Footer
Well-known member
I give you Chris Smalling.
From Maidstone to a handful of games for Fulham then £12 million i think to Man Utd.
Your right we will probably get £3 million plus add ons.
northstandsteve
Well-known member
If we remain top, it stands to reason his value will go up. He is a local lad, and if we were in the premiership next season i suspect he would stay. Either way it is a win win for the Albion. All clubs have to sell when the price is right. Will be interesting how he copes with the next four games, could be a good indicator. Quality strikers like Carroll, Suarez,Beckford,Becchio and Murray !!
Good luck Lewis glad to have you here and long may it continue.
Good luck Lewis glad to have you here and long may it continue.
Craig4004
New member
I think if he was gonna leave, 1: he would go to a premiership club that's unlikely to go down. 2, not go until next summer (dependant on where we finish this season) and 3, if Gus would let him go for the right price. He's been amazing so far thus season and I really hope he doesn't go. If we go up thus year, I don't reckon he will leave anyway 
fingers crossed!
fingers crossed!
NMH
Banned
Great defenders are rarer treasure than goalscorers, and there's no doubt he'll be a wanted man if he keeps playing so well. It's the sorry fact about success - we have to watch the team getting cherry-picked by 'big' clubs - and maybe even the manager.
However, Dunk isn't going to want to be in a struggle, even in the Prem - so the longer we stay at the top the more chance players like him may consider staying as a better option.
Come the end of the season, Bennett might be glancing to the club he left and thinking the grass wasn't necessarily greener.
However, Dunk isn't going to want to be in a struggle, even in the Prem - so the longer we stay at the top the more chance players like him may consider staying as a better option.
Come the end of the season, Bennett might be glancing to the club he left and thinking the grass wasn't necessarily greener.