If T2 is narrower, it effectively becomes more of the much-maligned ‘closed shop’……agree it can be argued both ways, with many probably clouded by their own circumstances. There is no solution that suits all of the people all of the time unfortunatelyI flip-flopped on this when discussing it last year.
For the low-capacity aways (Bournemouth, Brentford and Luton etc), I did initially think the size of Tier 2 was a bit unfair to those just below the Tier 1 threshold.
However, I then decided this large Tier 2 group might be more fair, in that it gives more people a chance of going to one of these high-demand fixtures. If Tier 2 was shrunk down, and the following was a suggestion, there'd be a lot of people who would not get a chance to go to one of these games:
Window 1 – the allocation (using an example of 1k allocation – 1k)
Window 2 – double the allocation (around 2k)
Window 3 – 50% of STHs &1901 (around 12k)
Window 4 – all STHs & 1901 (around 24k)
I guess I can see the pros and cons of each approach.