Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Bournemouth vs Brighton & Hove Albion *** Official Match Thread ***
- Thread starter Dick Head
- Start date
Obviously, it's easy to have a pop at Atwell, but from his angle it's a clear yellow. He sees Baleba go in late, catch the player on the shin and then writhe in agony, which is a yellow from his perspective.
I don't think he can see that he makes no contact and can only call what he sees
I don't think he can see that he makes no contact and can only call what he sees
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,425
Just seen our second. The Pedro assist is filthy
magnifique
- May 8, 2018
- 10,844
Baleba’s first yellow was avoidable so there’s some blame there.
The second yellow was a classic 1st yellow but not enough to be sent off
Oh well, we need to get use to rotating the squad and it’s only a game
Did anything else thing there was something up with M O’R in the final 5 min, looked like he had sprained something, but the stream wasn’t great?
The second yellow was a classic 1st yellow but not enough to be sent off
Oh well, we need to get use to rotating the squad and it’s only a game
Did anything else thing there was something up with M O’R in the final 5 min, looked like he had sprained something, but the stream wasn’t great?
schmunk
Well-used member
Not watching it, but the app suggests it's completely against xG / run of play.
smillie's garden
Am I evil?
- Aug 11, 2003
- 2,760
Definitely a harsh second yellow, but I was wanting Baleba yanked at ht as his playing style would obviously be impacted by the first card. Some responsibility lies with Fab there.
Right Brain Ronnie
Well-known member
I agree but, I don't see anything at all in Weiffer, what am I missing? What does he do well?
Hes large, athletic, and in a number of early games was crunching into tackles and producing really crisp passes. He's very nervous, taking a long time to adapt to this league and has made some high profile errors.
Just home. MOR struggled a little bit after he got fouled - was on the floor for a bit. Looked like he took a knock to the knee.
schmunk
Well-used member
No, any second yellow can be reviewed but there's a fairly high bar for getting it overturned - one slam dunk is, as you say, mistaken identity.
Here's an example which wasn't overturned on appeal:
Premier League panel make 'unanimous' decision on Declan Rice's controversial red card
The Premier League's Independent Key Match Incidents Panel have given their verdict on Declan Rice's controversial red card against Brighton.
search.app
Is it PotG?
Thrifty non-licker
Well quite but I have to think there is much more to come.
Right Brain Ronnie
Well-known member
I hope so, but what do you think it could be.
Goals,assists, great tackler, great in the air. Honestly I don't understand why we bought him, how much is he on? More or less the Collen Rooney?
Normandy seagull
Well-known member
I agree it was a harsh yellow but you always run the risk on a yellow going in for a tackle from distance. Even if you catch the player even a tiny amount. We won so who cares, but 10 men could have cost us
I’ll reserve judgement for nowI hope so, but what do you think it could be.
Goals,assists, great tackler, great in the air. Honestly I don't understand why we bought him, how much is he on? More or less the Collen Rooney?
Normandy seagull
Well-known member
I agree but sadly you do have to legislate these days!
Is that an official appeal though or just a post match referees “media“ opinion?No, any second yellow can be reviewed but there's a fairly high bar for getting it overturned - one slam dunk is, as you say, mistaken identity.
Here's an example which wasn't overturned on appeal:
Premier League panel make 'unanimous' decision on Declan Rice's controversial red card
The Premier League's Independent Key Match Incidents Panel have given their verdict on Declan Rice's controversial red card against Brighton.