Best Brighton player you have seen play in each position?

[keaton]

Kuszczak
Upson or Bridge
Vicente
Zamora

 

[Hove Seagull]

Tomas in goal
Mark Lawrenson in defence
Vicente in midfield
Peter Ward up front.

What he said

 

[catfish]

Peter Grummitt
Mark Lawrenson
Brian Horton
Peter Ward.

 

[spring hall convert]

1. Peter Ward
2. Peter Ward
3. Peter Ward

As the song goes....

 

[wallyback]

Tomas in goal
Mark Lawrenson in defence
Vicente in midfield
Peter Ward up front.

Agreed

My dad the same but would have Bobby Smith up front!

 

[Icy Gull]

Tomas in goal
Mark Lawrenson in defence
Vicente in midfield
Peter Ward up front.

Probably agree but I'm still not convinced that Tomas is better than Grumitt, tough one. The other three I cannot argue with.

 

[TSB]

Nicky Rust
Glenn Thomas
Doug Loft
Federico Turienzo

 

[Icy Gull]

Nicky Rust
Glenn Thomas
Valur Gislason
Federico Turienzo

Corrected for you

 

[withdeanwombat]

Dave Hollins
Mark Lawrenson
Peter O'Sullivan
Peter Ward.

 

[BN9 BHA]

Peter Grummitt
Mark Lawrenson
Brian Horton
Peter Ward.

What he says.
I was going to say Tom in goal but I saw Peter Grummitt play more games and I enjoyed the football more when I was a kid.
Mark Lawrenson, consider myself lucky to see him play.
Brian Horton, 100% player for me. Vicente was nice to watch but a luxury player.
Peter Ward, also consider myself lucky to see him play, a hero for anyone that was a kid when he first played for us.

 

[TSB]

Corrected for you

True dat.

 

[beakyburn]

Can't imagine who exciting it must have been for Albion fans when they signed Smith.

Was for us oldies that remember that day. I am going for Eric Steele, Mark Lawrenson, Barry Rees and Peter Ward.

 

[willyfantastic]

PIG
Upson
Vicente
Ulloa

 

[Guinness Boy]

GK - Kuszczak
Defender - Bridge
Midfield - Vicente
FW - Zamora

I am old enough to remember Ward, Mosely and Lawrenson play but not well enough to compare them to the ones I remember well. I would be going off what people have told me. None of the four above are my "crowd favourite" though. The players I had a real rapport with were John Keeley, Kerry Mayo, Garry Nelson and Johnny Byrne. Stretching it to call Nelse a midfielder though he played left wing on occasion but they are the four for me who combined either ability or loyalty and knowing how important the fans were and they're the four I'd prefer to see in some ways. Vicente in particular just played for Vicente, Zamora doesn't really like football and Bridge was here rebuilding a career.

 

[and smith must score]

What he says.
I was going to say Tom in goal but I saw Peter Grummitt play more games and I enjoyed the football more when I was a kid.
Mark Lawrenson, consider myself lucky to see him play.
Brian Horton, 100% player for me. Vicente was nice to watch but a luxury player.
Peter Ward, also consider myself lucky to see him play, a hero for anyone that was a kid when he first played for us.

I was thinking same people and same reasons. I started in 1976 and 3 people from that time seems excessive and so maybe rose tinted specs.

I will go for Moseley in goal but so difficult to compare.
Lawrenson is the best and most complete player I have ever had the privilege to watch for BHA
Horton as a player and a leader and more effective than the more skillful Vicente
Ward, all time favourite player and even if Robinson was more successful in the top division and Zamora later played for England, I will always think Ward was the best striker I have seen

 

[Superphil]

Is the answer Adam Virgo?

 

[Mellotron]

Can't imagine a bigger signing in the Albion's history - or that sort of coup ever happening again in English football.

How did it happen? Why did he go to a Div 4 club?

 

[Albion_Dave]

Some tough choices but mine are.

Beeney
Lawrenson
Vicente
Ward

 

[Diego Napier]

Tomas in goal
Mark Lawrenson in defence
Vicente in midfield
Peter Ward up front.

Gets my vote

 

[Luke93]

Goalie: Tomaz, though I quite liked Ben Roberts

Defender: Bridge

Midfielder: Vicente


Striker: Zamora or Forster