Seasidesage
New member
Good luck to Ben but he hasn't even been the best central defender at the Albion this season so its a ridiculous decision really. Potential? For sure, but its an insult to Dunk it really is...
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Football] Arsenal’s Ben White
- Thread starter Paulie Gualtieri
- Start date
Can't argue with that. Delighted for White but a bit gutted for Dunky.
And no, I don't think we can put the Southgate being Palace and not picking Dunk to bed.
I've seen some JCLs on here bleating that they don't get the rivalry and hatred of Palace. They just don't get it. Dunk does. Big time. And that's why Southgate ignores him.
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
I doubt he will make the final squad (but pleased if he does) but maybe he's been included because he isn't just a CB but can play in midfield?
Not the best but certainly the most versatile. Has played in midfield when needed and, at times, drifted into a right back / RWB role for periods. Young, comfortable on the ball and quicker than Dunk.
Of course we all know how good Lewis is but for whatever reason Southgate doesn't agree. That doesn't mean White shouldn't be selected as he offers all of the above.
Well done young man
Papa Lazarou
Living in a De Zerbi wonderland
I've seen mention that Dunk didn't impress in the training camp when he was selected. I have no idea is this is true, but that video of Rashford making him look foolish can't have helped.
BadFish
Huge Member
- Oct 19, 2003
- 18,184
Could it be that Southgate is planning for the future with this. Maybe he sees White as one for the future and would like to give him some tournament experience to stand him in good stead if he continues knocking on the door?
I have never understood that Dunk hasn't played for England more. When you put him up against the other centre backs available for England he compares well with most and is far better than some.
Sadly the accepted Wisdom is that international players should play for the highest possible placed club.
I have never understood that Dunk hasn't played for England more. When you put him up against the other centre backs available for England he compares well with most and is far better than some.
Sadly the accepted Wisdom is that international players should play for the highest possible placed club.
hampshirebrightonboy
Well-known member
- Sep 3, 2011
- 1,023
Enough about Leeds already, it is boring, can we move on, let them bang on about it and seem small minded and petty.
He has had an immense season for us, surely next season Sky wont be saying during commentary "Great tackle by young Ben White, who was on loan at Leeds two seasons ago"
Let's move on Icy Gull.....
He is ours (for now)
Well done Ben
Of course they will. Along with "Brighton have only won x games at home in 2021"
I don't know why there seems to be some bitterness about this just because Dunk is not there? This is a nice surprise and great news for Ben and the club, just enjoy that. He won't play and probably won't even make the final cut but it is a logical call up for now due to his versatility and the fact that he is the future, this is great experience for him.
I believe Dunk does deserve a call up as do most of us but most neutrals don't. This won't be popular but I think as Brighton fans we do have a tendency to over rate Dunk at times due to his status within the club, as the player of the season thread shows, whereas I think both White and Webster are generally under rated.
I believe Dunk does deserve a call up as do most of us but most neutrals don't. This won't be popular but I think as Brighton fans we do have a tendency to over rate Dunk at times due to his status within the club, as the player of the season thread shows, whereas I think both White and Webster are generally under rated.
Frankie
Put him in the curry
The squad hasn't officially been announced yet but we all know England have previous for selecting injured players in preference to fit ones for major tournaments.
No doubt Maguire will be included in the squad and if I'm being honest I'd probably pick him as well , the issue for me is if Mings is selected at the expense of pretty much anyone, he's a complete liability imo and Stones always has that mistake waiting to happen in his locker , of the two I'd take Stones all day long but leaving out Dunk for Mings is simply illogical and plain daft .
The news that White will be included is fantastic for him and the club but White's inclusion actually makes sense considering his ability to play pretty much anywhere on the park .
I'm sure Dunky will be over the moon at White's inclusion in the squad , even at his own expense, but if and it probably looks like it will mean Dunk misses out I think he will be devastated and rightly so , he has been superb and to my mind deserves to start at the Euros , I think the pull back sending off v Wolves will be the main reason he's not selected ,this made the news , not the other 37 games he's been outstanding this season .
It must be hard to take for Dunk as he can't possibly do anymore than he has to make the squad , there's not a single team in the EPL that wouldn't want him on thier books I would imagine , luckily for us he's Brighton through and through , hopefully he gets over the disappointment quickly if not selected and we have the pleasure of seeing one of the best CBs in the country playing his heart out again for Brighton and Hove Albion next season .
No doubt Maguire will be included in the squad and if I'm being honest I'd probably pick him as well , the issue for me is if Mings is selected at the expense of pretty much anyone, he's a complete liability imo and Stones always has that mistake waiting to happen in his locker , of the two I'd take Stones all day long but leaving out Dunk for Mings is simply illogical and plain daft .
The news that White will be included is fantastic for him and the club but White's inclusion actually makes sense considering his ability to play pretty much anywhere on the park .
I'm sure Dunky will be over the moon at White's inclusion in the squad , even at his own expense, but if and it probably looks like it will mean Dunk misses out I think he will be devastated and rightly so , he has been superb and to my mind deserves to start at the Euros , I think the pull back sending off v Wolves will be the main reason he's not selected ,this made the news , not the other 37 games he's been outstanding this season .
It must be hard to take for Dunk as he can't possibly do anymore than he has to make the squad , there's not a single team in the EPL that wouldn't want him on thier books I would imagine , luckily for us he's Brighton through and through , hopefully he gets over the disappointment quickly if not selected and we have the pleasure of seeing one of the best CBs in the country playing his heart out again for Brighton and Hove Albion next season .
Cowfold Seagull
Fan of the 17 bus
Absolutely this, craziness in the extreme to pick White, yet leave Lewis Dunk at home.
Badger Boy
Mr Badger
- Jan 28, 2016
- 3,658
Not really. There's every chance that White will be a serious contender for the World Cup Squad in 2022 and maybe getting him some International experience this time will help him and the squad for next year? It's not the worst idea in the world to involve younger players you're expecting will play a bigger role in future. Other countries do it, and we shouldn't think only about this one tournament but the next and the following. I think White has more potential to improve than Dunk or Webster, but I absolutely would take Dunk in this squad as well as White because today Dunk is one of the best English CBs.
Papa Lazarou
Living in a De Zerbi wonderland
I wonder whether a fit Lamptey might also have made the squad.
Badger Boy
Mr Badger
- Jan 28, 2016
- 3,658
I don't. Southgate's mates Walker and Trippier are both fit and National Champions, so they're guaranteed plus his other mate Reece James. There's no place for Trent Alexander-Arnold and there wouldn't have been for Tariq Lamptey I'm sure.
Originunknown
BINFEST'ING
On ability in the here and now of course but White is a long term prospect for England and this is very much the start of his journey.
HitchinSeagull
Active member
- Aug 9, 2012
- 414
So does Southgate think White will move to a big club this summer? [emoji848]
Sent from my EVR-N29 using Tapatalk
Sent from my EVR-N29 using Tapatalk
Papa Lazarou
Living in a De Zerbi wonderland
He hopes.
It's not just that though but I agree that it's Dunk's disciplinary record counts against him. He's the only PL player to pick up two red cards this season. In his entire career he has four times as many red cards as Maguire, Stones, Keane and Mings put together. No matter how well he plays for Brighton, you can certainly see why an England manager wouldn't pick him.
Lamptey has no chance of making the squad. Apart from Trippier and Walker, there's James, TAA, Justin and AWB in the queue (Godfrey has also played RB). Southgate has also gone out of his way to praise Cash as someone he's looking at.
What a shame that this thread has been taken over by people slating Southgate for not picking Dunk rather than celebrating him possibly picking White. Jesus, Mary, Joseph and the little donkey, how are people going to react if the rumour isn't true?
If true, and he does get picked, it's a great achievement for White. This is what the thread should be about.
If true, and he does get picked, it's a great achievement for White. This is what the thread should be about.