Andy Naylor
- Thread starter MACROBLUE
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
thisistips
New member
It was rocking, right from the start, never seen it that good.
BHAFC4EVER
BOO!
D
Deleted member 18477
Guest
Doncaster?
brightonrock
Dodgy Hamstrings
- Jan 1, 2008
- 2,482
Because he'd rather wait for the first time the crowd groans at a backward pass and then write 500 words about how we should remember where we came from and should appreciate what we've got. I know it's fashionable to dislike the man but I genuinely do, with a passion. Has a chip on his shoulder about Albion support and needs to f*** off back to Stoke- Brian Owen is 10x a better journo than him anyway.
Man of Harveys
Well-known member
Ridiculous thread: slating the man for something he hasn't done or might or might not do? Risible.
supaseagull
Well-known member
I have it on good authority that Andy Naylor and the Argus are no longer given "preferential" treatment as they were in years gone by. This is for various reasons, but mainly because the club don't want stories leaked by Argus "insiders" anymore.
When Poyet took charge, the club lost out on a few players due to "leaks" at the Argus and it's because of this, The Argus will know no more than any other media source.
Sent from my iPhone using a goat
When Poyet took charge, the club lost out on a few players due to "leaks" at the Argus and it's because of this, The Argus will know no more than any other media source.
Sent from my iPhone using a goat
IMO he does a good job and reports what has happened. Just because he does not report the self congratulatory wankathon about the singing does not make him a bad reporter. It was a mediocre match, but because we won that is quickly forgotten by us and rightly so.
Art Vs Science
Banned
- Sep 1, 2010
- 6,419
Has he ever mentioned anything about our singing ?
I get it. This forum doesn't like Andy Naylor, but dear God get a grip! Sure, he hasn't lavished praise on us for getting behind our team more vociferously than normal but why should he?
Its not his fault we've only really had three or four home games (Burnley, Newcastle, Donny and Liverpool) this season with a massive atmosphere is it?
Do we really need a pat on the back from the local rag every time we make some noise?
Its not his fault we've only really had three or four home games (Burnley, Newcastle, Donny and Liverpool) this season with a massive atmosphere is it?
Do we really need a pat on the back from the local rag every time we make some noise?
D
Deleted member 2719
Guest
I do hope your right.
The Large One
Who's Next?
To be fair it is only a few who don't like him, but they do make their opinions known! I think El Pres had it right, some people would prefer to read a match report along the lines of "Chant after chant rolled from the stands as the best fans in Britain showed why the Amex is rated as one the top stadiums in the world for atmosphere. Song after song pounded down onto the opposition players until they covered their ears and screamed for mercy whilst desperately signalling to their own mute fans to try and do something to counter the immense wall of blue and white noise ..."
ROSM
Well-known member
That's HB&Bs next report opening written. Albeit he would have said ' I ensured song after song.......' and 'the opposition players told me.......'
Spot on - nothing wrong with Naylor, IMO. There really are some f***ing tools on here.
shaolinpunk
[Insert witty title here]
I thought it was a good atmosphere but it didn't blow me away - I've seen better this season. Namely the Doncaster and Burnley games as have already been mentioned
hoveboyslim
Well-known member
I agree. I was in WSL and during the first half I thought the atmosphere went as flat as the match in periods during the first half. It picked up a hell of a lot in the in the second but it certainly wasn't the best I have experienced, but I can only comment on where I was sitting.
As stated above I don't quite understand why some want to be congratulated on the level of singing and atmosphere. We are supporters - that is what we are supposed to do; it is our only role at a football match.
- Jul 7, 2003
- 47,630
I don't really understand what the O/P expects him to write? He's doing a report on the game, he's not there to offer pats on the back to those evidently desperate for affirmation of their singing abilities. What on earth are you hoping for in his pieces?
The whole Naylor thing strikes me as a ridiculous bandwagon that a few people are jumping on because they're completely blinded by their loyalty to the Albion. The second something appears in press that questions the all-powerful cult of Albion, Naylor is vilified.
He's just a bog standard local newspaper reporter, no more, no less. His reports are, in the main, perfectly acceptable. If you want to start your own, North Korean government style reporting agency for match reports, feel free to do so.
The whole Naylor thing strikes me as a ridiculous bandwagon that a few people are jumping on because they're completely blinded by their loyalty to the Albion. The second something appears in press that questions the all-powerful cult of Albion, Naylor is vilified.
He's just a bog standard local newspaper reporter, no more, no less. His reports are, in the main, perfectly acceptable. If you want to start your own, North Korean government style reporting agency for match reports, feel free to do so.