Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Register Log in

[Albion] Alexis Mac Allister: Albion legend?

Is Alexis Mac Allister an Albion club legend?

  • Of course he is!

    Votes: 144 52.6%

  • Nah.

    Votes: 130 47.4%
  • Total voters
    274
  • Poll closed .


peterward

peterward

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Nov 11, 2009
12,237
He is a fantastic player and an even better human being, he was very good for us, but I don't think he fits in legend category.

You need either huge amount of time/dedication to the club, like Hart, Dunk, Gross

Or to be a total X factor of the club when here/record breaker Ward, Zamora, Muzza
 




Insel affe

Insel affe

HellBilly
Feb 23, 2009
24,304
Brighton factually.....
rippleman said:
Loved him as a player for us and has always come across as a thoroughly decent chap.

But when I look around at other transfer fees (including the £110m for Caicedo) I will forever have the feeling that we gave him away. For only £35m Liverpool got a WC winner and one of the most versatile midfielders in world football.
Click to expand...
Ah did we....

Listening to the albion roar podcast this week, they were discussing our profit announcement and I think Kieran Maguire alluded to about 40 million pounds included that seem to be added and Macallister seems to be the one that could bring a lot more money in if the win in Europe, or the League, possibly an extra 25million
 


J

jordanseagull

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2009
4,151
The fact the poll returned a 50/50 split, it's a fact that he's not a legend. The title must come with unanimous or near unanimous backing!

I'd be shocked if Dunk returned worse than 99/1 scores.
 




herecomesaregular

herecomesaregular

We're in the pipe, 5 by 5
Oct 27, 2008
4,644
Still in Brighton
peterward said:
He is a fantastic player and an even better human being, he was very good for us, but I don't think he fits in legend category.

You need either huge amount of time/dedication to the club, like Hart, Dunk, Gross

Or to be a total X factor of the club when here/record breaker Ward, Zamora, Muzza
Click to expand...
This is probably factually true. But Ali Mac played so well for us and acted like such a gent that he is one of the few players I'd like to hit the heights for another club. He will always be fondly remembered by Albion fans whenever he visits, the sort of respect that for me is worth more than money/how much he might earn. Call me an old romantic but money can't buy you love.
 






G

Garyoldfan

Well-known member
Jun 14, 2023
591
Bozza said:
Some think the "legend" term is tossed around too freely these days. But Alexis Mac Allister became a World Cup winner whilst playing for the club.

Alternatively, some think he's a bit pedestrian, not all that and will be easily replaced.

Club legend or not?
Click to expand...
No chance. Was on the bench a lot until he scored against Everton then f***ed off end of the next season. I like him but shit thread.
 


G

Greg Bobkin

Silver Seagull
May 22, 2012
15,985
dwayne said:
Yep the hype on here is ridiculous. He struggled the first half of the season but now he's a had a few good games against the likes of us Sheffield united etc (us!) he's a monster player.

Watch very carefully when he plays a real big boy like city or arsenal and things don't quite go the same way. He's a very good player but if I'm being really harsh he's not quite good enough for someone like city.
Click to expand...
Given that they are both clubs are currently competing for the title – and Ali Mac's team are ABOVE the other lot in the table – I would probably say that he is *already* good enough for 'someone like city'.

Oh – and 'new signing struggles in first few months with their new club' is hardly the 'gotcha' you think it is :lolol:
 






Sarisbury Seagull

Sarisbury Seagull

Solly March Fan Club
NSC Patron
Nov 22, 2007
14,992
Sarisbury Green, Southampton
dwayne said:
Yep the hype on here is ridiculous. He struggled the first half of the season but now he's a had a few good games against the likes of us Sheffield united etc (us!) he's a monster player.

Watch very carefully when he plays a real big boy like city or arsenal and things don't quite go the same way. He's a very good player but if I'm being really harsh he's not quite good enough for someone like city.
Click to expand...
You mean big boys like France in a World Cup Final. Is that not big enough for you? And countless other international games for Argentina plus PL games for us and Liverpool against other big clubs.

He didn't struggle at the start of the season, he was decent but still obviously finding his feet there in the first few weeks and and he has been outstanding recently. In fact there was a neutral article in The Athletic yesterday saying he is now Klopp's most important player. City would LOVE to have him.

Come on now, just admit you're wrong (like you were about Kudus and Hinshelwood), you're just looking silly now.
 


M

martin tyler

Well-known member
Jan 25, 2013
5,963
dwayne said:
Yep the hype on here is ridiculous. He struggled the first half of the season but now he's a had a few good games against the likes of us Sheffield united etc (us!) he's a monster player.

Watch very carefully when he plays a real big boy like city or arsenal and things don't quite go the same way. He's a very good player but if I'm being really harsh he's not quite good enough for someone like city.
Click to expand...
He didn’t exactly struggle early on but was played deeper. I’m sure city would love him CM alongside Rodri. At the moment he’s the one digging Liverpool out of any trouble most weeks. 3 goals 4 assists in past 6 league games and there not just goals to add onto a big score line they have genuinely been game changing. Deserves more credit than he gets it can’t always be coincidence teams play better with him in it whether it is us, Liverpool or Argentina.
 




maltaseagull

maltaseagull

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
13,355
Zabbar- Malta
Weststander said:
Very average player who somehow lucked out with a WC. Liverpool fans don’t rate him. I just don’t get NSC’ers rating him. :mad:
Click to expand...
1712315400531.png
 


Herr Tubthumper

Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
62,601
The Fatherland
one has to question his off-field decisions as well as his onfield. He dumped the lovely Cami

BED02643-D3FF-4829-8021-8658081870A7.jpeg

For this

28870B23-2628-4551-BC20-5E246EFDEE10.jpeg
 








Weststander

Weststander

Well-known member
Aug 25, 2011
69,138
Withdean area
Farehamseagull said:
You mean big boys like France in a World Cup Final. Is that not big enough for you? And countless other international games for Argentina plus PL games for us and Liverpool against other big clubs.

He didn't struggle at the start of the season, he was decent but still obviously finding his feet there in the first few weeks and and he has been outstanding recently. In fact there was a neutral article in The Athletic yesterday saying he is now Klopp's most important player. City would LOVE to have him.

Come on now, just admit you're wrong (like you were about Kudus and Hinshelwood), you're just looking silly now.
Click to expand...

When played as a defensive midfielder, something new to him. He soon mastered that too, until Endo took over.
 












You must log in or register to reply here.
Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports

Share this page


Top
Link Here