Last minute pen against Man Utd....
[Albion] Alexis Mac Allister: Albion legend?
- Thread starter Bozza
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
vegster
Sanity Clause
- May 5, 2008
- 28,272
I always thought that Bobby would come back and that he was only out " on loan " !
vegster
Sanity Clause
- May 5, 2008
- 28,272
Yes, a penalty. 8 out of the eleven on the pitch could have scored that from the spot and cemented " Legend " status surely ?
surely being a world cup winner while player for us is enough to make him a legend ?
dejavuatbtn
Well-known member
One of our best ever players, perhaps. Legend, nah. It takes a lot more to be in that exclusive club.
Oh, I thought you simply said "not sure I can recall many memorable goals".
My mistake (bothering to respond).
portslade seagull
Well-known member
Left us after having a wad waved in his face. Nowhere near legend status
Garyoldfan
Well-known member
- Jun 14, 2023
- 591
No chance. Seems a nice chap though. You got to be there through thick and thin.
Crawley Dingo
Political thread tourist.
- Mar 31, 2022
- 1,080
This is something judged with hindsight. If we go into decline then he will be a legend as being here at the peak, think Peter ward. If we go onto better things he could become the Talisman of when we soared to greatness. So yes, either way I think he will be.
vegster
Sanity Clause
- May 5, 2008
- 28,272
I'm thinking classy finishes, thunderbolt shots, cheeky chips and Mitoma's goal against Liverpool.
keaton
Big heart, hot blood and balls. Big balls
- Nov 18, 2004
- 9,972
The Liecester free kick? The best goal ever he scored just before that was ruled out?
- Jul 10, 2003
- 27,766
I think he'll be remembered as a 'great player' and the first ever (and maybe only) 'world cup winner' to play for us.
But ultimately, like Mark Lawrenson, he'll be remembered as a great player and not a 'legend'. (I mean the Holy Trinity of Lewis, Solly and Pascal have all played more games, at a higher level, than Lawrenson). There were three legends in our team last season, and all being well, this season as well, and surely that is enough for anyone.
Sorry, but AliMac is not amongst them. Still love him though as a footballer and person
*edit* See the post below. Genuinely lovely bloke
But ultimately, like Mark Lawrenson, he'll be remembered as a great player and not a 'legend'. (I mean the Holy Trinity of Lewis, Solly and Pascal have all played more games, at a higher level, than Lawrenson). There were three legends in our team last season, and all being well, this season as well, and surely that is enough for anyone.
Sorry, but AliMac is not amongst them. Still love him though as a footballer and person
*edit* See the post below. Genuinely lovely bloke
Last edited:
I do miss Mac.
I also hope that he has been advised that doing this sort of thing in Liverpool is not going to end well.
phoenix
Well-known member
- May 18, 2009
- 2,867
People like Dunky and Solly are my legends I don't ask for much but these two have given their lives to the club i love there may be others like the tea lady whose been there for 30 years (if indeed one has) obviously Mr Bloom. But someone turning up for a few seasons on massive wages nah ! Bobby came back so i'm ok with that.
Edit: A lot of you Guys and Girls are also legends for all your service and i respect you for your dedication to the club and making me proud to be a Brighton supporter I raise my glass to you.
Yes i understand what the op meant
Edit: A lot of you Guys and Girls are also legends for all your service and i respect you for your dedication to the club and making me proud to be a Brighton supporter I raise my glass to you.
Yes i understand what the op meant
Mad as my Mother
Well-known member
I asked my 12yo (who comes to every game with me) this question.
He didn't hesitate to reply that yes of course he is a legend.
His quote was " When I'm an old man like you, and I am taking my own son to a game for his first time, on the way there I will be telling him about the day I was there to see a player who had won the world cup be welcomed home and I will tell him of the time that I looked at you and saw the tears in your eyes and that moment changed football for me forever. Yes of course he is a legend"
I can't argue with that.
He didn't hesitate to reply that yes of course he is a legend.
His quote was " When I'm an old man like you, and I am taking my own son to a game for his first time, on the way there I will be telling him about the day I was there to see a player who had won the world cup be welcomed home and I will tell him of the time that I looked at you and saw the tears in your eyes and that moment changed football for me forever. Yes of course he is a legend"
I can't argue with that.
Just the injury time penalty v Man U and a few others that people will mention, I'm sure
He came to us from the oher side of the world, in difficut circumstances (lockdown), worked hard, did everything asked of him and (eventually) became a very good PL player for us. In his tme as an Albion player he also won the World Cup (the lad he was playing with in midfied was sold for £105M, give or take) so great kudis to both Alexis and the club.
He left us after a pretty short Albion career to join one of the biggest clubs in the world - unfortuantely for a bargain basement fee (we all know the reasons and circumstances why, and don't need a lecture about it - whichever way you want to nuance it, Liverpool got one hell of a bargain - and they think so too). That doesn't diminish the pleasure we had from him playing for us.
Bloody good player, glad to have had him for a short time, truly hope he has a stellar career (except against us!) at the big club he's gone to - but at the end of the day, it was a short Abion career, So, Albion legend? No.
Milano
Well-known member
12? As if
Good timing.
last game my son came to was HUddersfield at home, 1-1 .2018? . . My lad told mum I swore a lot, he didn't like it.
Anyway, AliMac is nowhere near a legend, good player. Hugely Improved under BHA wings, really hit his stride early 2022, but still developing. . . . Got a break in the world cup, played well, and with a bit of WC luck . . . his world is made. He's been very professional (unlike his father who comes accross like a complete twunt, or a bit of a 'Maradona') He may get even better, he may not . . . I care not now, he's not BHA. Best of luck, but legend? Never.