BensGrandad
New member
Has Balance not had plenty of opportunities to show his metal and failed generally so perhaps he joins Mark Ramprakash and others as a good county player who cannot cut it at test level.
2nd Test: England v South Africa at Nottingham, Jul 14-18, 2017
- Thread starter Titanic
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Current form aside, Haseeb Hameed is surely nailed on to be a part of England's top order plans?
If he could develop his leg spin, so much the better.
If he could develop his leg spin, so much the better.
And on the subject of occasional spinners - further to the 'what is the point of Dawson?' debate - I reckon Joe Root's spin looks more threatening than his does.
Sack him off now, for an extra batter, or Woakes, if fit.
Sack him off now, for an extra batter, or Woakes, if fit.
Thing with Buttler is he's only played 1 first class game this season, and scored 3 runs across 2 innings.
BensGrandad
New member
Surprised nobody has suggested Luke Wright at No 3
Luke Wright who is about 33, has never played a Test, is not a top order batsman, has never shown any interest in patiently building an innings in his entire career, and has got off the mark in 2 of his last 3 Sussex innings with a straight six?
Yes, me too.
Although, if you'd said Luke WELLS, that might be worthy of debate at some point.
He is the second-highest averaging English batsman in the County game this summer (after Ballance), with 88.00.
He is the second-highest averaging English batsman in the County game this summer (after Ballance), with 88.00.
BensGrandad
New member
I was taking the p..s suggesting him but it obviously passed over some peoples heads.
I was thinking this and then read that Woakes is probably out for the series. Definitely an option if fit.
How could anyone possibly tell, in light of your serious suggestions over the years?
#JLloydSamuel
Marshy
Well-known member
Woakes would oust Wood from the side if fit for sure. Hell of a No9 bat too !
BensGrandad
New member
Even he would have been an improvement on what we had at the time but Luke Wright wouldnt be as he is a hit and miss big score or nothing batsman the likes of which we are complaining about.
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
debatable
BensGrandad
New member
Isnt that the point if NSC?
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
Ok bl*x then ..i say u r wrong re your left back prognosis and therefore your whole post
We only need 5 bowlers plus some occasional off spin from Root if required.
Dawson out and Stoneman in, moving Ali down to 8. If Balance makes way why isn't the young lad who impressed in India selected he had something about him.
Anyone know how Ian Bell is performing? IVO the lack of viable alternatives he has a technique that can still score runs at test level if required.
Dawson out and Stoneman in, moving Ali down to 8. If Balance makes way why isn't the young lad who impressed in India selected he had something about him.
Anyone know how Ian Bell is performing? IVO the lack of viable alternatives he has a technique that can still score runs at test level if required.
BensGrandad
New member
Can somebody help and find the up to date averages in county cricket this season for both Ian Bell and Jonathan Trott who would both be in the running if the recall of an oldie is considered.
Trott has retired from International cricket so he is out of the running.
Certainly the best number 3 we've had for a number of years. Really missed his stability at the top of the order.
Before him the last 4/5 years of Mark Butchers career were successful after a fairly mediocre start, but typically it's always been a problem area for us.
BensGrandad
New member
Is that definite or could he perhaps be talked around to reconsider. How is Bells average going this season.