1983 FA Cup Final - Player Ratings

[Spunk Bubble]

Moseley
Ramsey
Pearce
Gatting
Stevens
Case
Grealish
Howlett
Smillie
Smith
Robinson

Ryan (Sub)

Have your say !!

 

[wehatepalace]

Moseley 9
Ramsey 9
Pearce 9
Gatting 9
Stevens 9
Case 9
Grealish 9
Howlett 9
Smillie 9
Smith 9
Robinson 10

Ryan (Sub) 9

All would have been 10's if we'd won !!

 

[Bakesy]

Stevens worth a 10, 9 for the rest.

 

[Yorkie]

Which one? The first all 8's and 9's.
The replay all 5's.

 

[Bakesy]

Which one? The first all 8's and 9's.
The replay all 5's.

It must be the first game as Foster was serving a ban.

 

[dougdeep]

Stevens worth a 10, 9 for the rest.

Spot on sir.

 

[Col P]

Moseley 8
Ramsey 8
Pearce 7
Gatting 7
Stevens 8
Case 8
Grealish 9
Howlett 8
Smillie 8
Smith 9
Robinson 8

Ryan (Sub) 8

Have your say !!

 

[Deleted User X18H]

Moseley 7 Did drop a cross then let one in
Ramsey 7 Doing all right til stamped on
Pearce 7 Very comfortable
Gatting 8 Excellent partnership with Stevens
Stevens 10 Best perfromance by a Brighton and Hove Albion player ever!!!!
Case 8 Stamped on Wilkins well done him
Grealish 7 Played like a cup final captain a la Beattie and Perryman
Howlett 8 Not overawed played like a mature pro
Smillie 7 Had the beating of Albaston early on anf throughout
Smith 6 would have been a 10 and the freedom of this city for ever could have walked in any pub and had a free drink for life instead of skulking back to Dick Knights ridicule in 2001
Robinson 9 excellent put himself about played on til the 121st
minute

Ryan 8 came on did a job typical Gerry

 

[dougdeep]

Stevens 10 Best perfromance by a Brighton and Hove Albion player ever!!!!

Did I mention that he sent me a birthday card this year?

 

[thedonkeycentrehalf]

The replay all 5's.

That's a bit harsh Yorkie. Last time I watched the replay it seemed that we didn't actually play as badly as I thought at the time but they took their chances whereas we didn't.

I know he was captain but I still wouldn't have put Fozzie back in the side as we had played so well first time but put in a direct replacement for Ramsey.

 

[Seagull Stew]

That's a bit harsh Yorkie. Last time I watched the replay it seemed that we didn't actually play as badly as I thought at the time but they took their chances whereas we didn't.

I know he was captain but I still wouldn't have put Fozzie back in the side as we had played so well first time but put in a direct replacement for Ramsey.

I think the biggest mistake was not bringing Fozzie back for the replay but by moving Steve Gatting to right back.