Justice
Dangerous Idiot
We will look a bit silly if we loan him to a PL side and he bangs in 20 goals and we start to struggle, long way to go.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] If Ferguson is now worth £51m, maybe Hürzeler might consider letting him play?
- Thread starter greachain
- Start date
seagull_si
Active member
Surely every club in the premiere league is a probable rival for Europe. If they are in the same league as us the probability of them rivalling us for Europe will never be none.
pigmanovich
Good Old Sausage by the Sea
West Ham signed Fullkrug in the summer for £27.5m and he's managed only 63 minutes in the league so far owing to injury. I could see them going for Evan so as not to be reliant on Antonio and Ings but we would be gambling on a) Fullkrug recovering later rather than sooner and b) them not being in the race for Europe, which they could well end up being if Evan's loan turned out to be a success.
Wardy's twin
Well-known member
- Oct 21, 2014
- 8,960
If his 'drop' in form is purely confidence then sure a loan to a top championship team would help not sure playing in a PL relegation threatened team would help. If the issue goes back to his physical issues (playing with an injury and/or long covid(or similar) ) then going out on loan might be best as he would be seen as expendable by the loaning club.
Personally would look to give him more game time and not just the last 5-10 mins and also game time with via the U21s.
At the end of the day the club should know more about what's going on and the best solution.
Is it possible to recall Mark o'Mahony as he doesn't seem to be getting much game time at Portsmouth?
Personally would look to give him more game time and not just the last 5-10 mins and also game time with via the U21s.
At the end of the day the club should know more about what's going on and the best solution.
Is it possible to recall Mark o'Mahony as he doesn't seem to be getting much game time at Portsmouth?
seagull_si
Active member
Its a bit catch 22. We would want his loan to be a success, which would mean improving any teams league position. Ipswich are only 6 points behind West Ham, so if he went there and had a successful loan, they could then be considered a threat?
We want him to go to a team that need a striker short term and will be playing attacking football . I think West Ham are one of the few teams that fit the bill.
Wardy's twin
Well-known member
- Oct 21, 2014
- 8,960
Not all , think the bottom 4 or 5 would struggle , not impossible though. the league is certainly more open than it has ever been.
Marshy
Well-known member
its not even prove he deserves to Play. Until Danny either gets injured or form falls off there is literally nothing Evan can do to get into the side on a perm basis, Same applies for Simon, Julio, Gruda etc... its a tough gig when the starting 11 are doing so well.
Mancgull
Well-known member
A loan to Celtic could be ideal. Lots of chances to score goals and I expect that Evan wouldn’t be averse to it.
If it was a lower Premier League team then I doubt he’d get the same opportunities to score, which is what I think he needs.
If it was a lower Premier League team then I doubt he’d get the same opportunities to score, which is what I think he needs.
seagull_si
Active member
Leicester can not loan him, he would not get the minutes at Wolves or Ipswich (IMO). I dont think we would loan to Palace, or Palace would loan a player from Brighton. Which leaves Southampton and I dont think going there would help his development. Next in league are Everton that have 3 strikers, then next is West Ham who need a short term option to cover the injuries they have and manage the minutes of an aging Antonio.
Milano
Well-known member
I don't bet. Anyway:
1. WHU are 7 points behind us after 12 games and still to play us twice.
2. They are capable of beating us twice with or without Evan (as are we of beating them)
3. Or help them finish above us.
Perhaps if the gap is a lot more than 7 points come Jan 1st then maybe, but I think it's an unneccessary risk.
Loan him to a top Championship side or abroard or keep him. I would not loan him to another EPL side.
Can a loan be structured so that a Club can immediately recall a player at anytime if required ?
- Oct 17, 2008
- 15,058
Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo
I believe in Joe Hendry
- Oct 4, 2003
- 12,220
Recalls outside of the transfer window are not permitted for any player.
There is an exception for goalkeepers and you’d need to a) have a recall clause in the loan deal and b) have the FA and Premier League agree to the recall under emergency recall rules.
- Oct 17, 2008
- 15,058
Would it not also be the case for a) that both sides can agree to cancel a loan without a cancellation clause, given that the clause is there in service to the parent club?
Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo
I believe in Joe Hendry
- Oct 4, 2003
- 12,220
I believe a cancellation can be agreed upon by both parties outside of the window without a pre agreed clause. Recalls have to be pre agreed.
However the players registration would still be with the club he’s been loaned too and cannot be transferred back to us outside of the transfer window. Therefore the player would still be unable to play for us.
With the option of a recall of a goalkeeper in an emergency that would have to have been pre agreed.
- Oct 17, 2008
- 15,058
Yes, I knew the second bit, I was just pointing out that both sides can agree to cancel a loan at any time without there being a clause in the contract someone needs to activate.
No, not in the way that the player can play for the parent club. There can be mutual agreement that the player will return home because they're not going to play because of injury or illness and it's to everyone's that they recover 'at home'. This happened, I believe, to Sima and Offiah in recent years - they were still officially on loan though.
Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo
I believe in Joe Hendry
- Oct 4, 2003
- 12,220
When a player is on loan if they suffer an injury it is almost always the case that they’ll return to their parent club for treatment, at least for an initial assessment. This has nothing to do with any loan cancellation or recall clauses and if they recover they can return to play for their loan club.
Comrade Sam
Comrade Sam
It's nice list of potential suitors in rumour land: Man Utd, Spurs, Arsenal, Chelsea, West Ham, Rangers, Celtic, Sunderland, Leeds, Millwall, Burnley, Leicester. I may have missed a dozen.