[Albion] Bournemouth vs Brighton & Hove Albion * Official Match Thread *

Right Brain Ronnie · Nov 23, 2024

Oh_aye said:
Hes large, athletic, and in a number of early games was crunching into tackles and producing really crisp passes. He's very nervous, taking a long time to adapt to this league and has made some high profile errors.

I can see the large, but maybe I have missed the other bits.
I have seen him get caught so many times and miss passes and get caught out of position. I really do hope he proves me wrong but he would not be on my bench......at home.

schmunk · Nov 23, 2024

South Stand Bonfire said:
Is that an official appeal though or just a post match referees “media“ opinion?

It's an official appeal. Trossard's recent second yellow, also for kicking the ball away, was also unsuccessfully appealed.

Triggaaar · Nov 23, 2024

Normandy seagull said:
I agree it was a harsh yellow but you always run the risk on a yellow going in for a tackle from distance. Even if you catch the player even a tiny amount.

I disagree with you. 'Harsh yellow' makes it sound like it was a foul by Baleba, but the yellow was questionable, but in my opinion it wasn't a foul by Baleba. He didn't go in for a tackle from a distance, he stayed on his feet and ran across while his opponent went to ground.

Normandy seagull said:
We won so who cares

Delighted we won, but I feel we're getting too many bad decisions, and Baleba missing against Southampton could cost us more points.

Flounce · Nov 23, 2024

schmunk said:
It's an official appeal. Trossard's recent second yellow, also for kicking the ball away, was also unsuccessfully appealed.

Yeah but that’s Arsenal, we are a two bob club, even less chance

LamieRobertson · Nov 23, 2024

I thought the first guy gets it more or less right

Normandy seagull · Nov 23, 2024

Triggaaar said:
I disagree with you. 'Harsh yellow' makes it sound like it was a foul by Baleba, but the yellow was questionable, but in my opinion it wasn't a foul by Baleba. He didn't go in for a tackle from a distance, he stayed on his feet and ran across while his opponent went to ground.

Delighted we won, but I feel we're getting too many bad decisions, and Baleba missing against Southampton could cost us more points.

Agree to disagree then. Sorry it was a foul but not a booking. Look at it another way, he was always going to rack up 5 booking at some point. Southampton H not the worst game to miss!

warmleyseagull · Nov 23, 2024

Driver8 said:
Commentary mentioned that we are yet to concede a goal from a cross this season too.

Flip side of that is conceding too many from central positions.

LamieRobertson · Nov 23, 2024

Spec savers appointment for Attwell

most embarrassing moment of the weekend award goes to the Bournemouth player rolling around in apparent agony having not even been fouled by CB

Oh_aye · Nov 23, 2024

Right Brain Ronnie said:
I can see the large, but maybe I have missed the other bits.
I have seen him get caught so many times and miss passes and get caught out of position. I really do hope he proves me wrong but he would not be on my bench......at home.

Time will tell friend, but I'm confident.

PascalGroß Tips · Nov 23, 2024

schmunk said:
No, any second yellow can be reviewed but there's a fairly high bar for getting it overturned - one slam dunk is, as you say, mistaken identity.

Here's an example which wasn't overturned on appeal:

Premier League panel make 'unanimous' decision on Declan Rice's controversial red card

The Premier League's Independent Key Match Incidents Panel have given their verdict on Declan Rice's controversial red card against Brighton.

search.app

My understanding is that although this panel reviews key match in incidents, it’s not part of an appeals process. Meaning if they disagreed with the award of a second yellow, it wouldn’t negate it and the second yellow still stands. It’s all about feeding back following an assessment of decisions made by officials and VAR.

So the link you’ve shared is not actually part of an appeal.

PascalGroß Tips · Nov 23, 2024

South Stand Bonfire said:
Is that an official appeal though or just a post match referees “media“ opinion?

It’s not part of any appeals process.

PascalGroß Tips · Nov 23, 2024

schmunk said:
It's an official appeal. Trossard's recent second yellow, also for kicking the ball away, was also unsuccessfully appealed.

It’s NOT an appeals process … a panel reviews decisions made and feeds back. Nothing they decide will impact the original decision.

Skaville · Nov 23, 2024

Right Brain Ronnie said:
I agree but, I don't see anything at all in Weiffer, what am I missing? What does he do well?

I thought he was excellent when he came on, exactly what we needed. Read the game and won the ball on several occasions. It was the same against Spurs.

Not Andy Naylor · Nov 23, 2024

JBizzle said:
Obviously, it's easy to have a pop at Atwell, but from his angle it's a clear yellow. He sees Baleba go in late, catch the player on the shin and then writhe in agony, which is a yellow from his perspective.

I don't think he can see that he makes no contact and can only call what he sees

So you're saying he has seen something that hasn't happened?.

JBizzle · Nov 23, 2024

Not Andy Naylor said:
So you're saying he has seen something that hasn't happened?.

I'm saying he called what he thought he saw. Turns out it was wrong, but his eyes don't have the benefit of other angles and replays and the yellow removed VAR as a safety net.

It may have been wrong, but it was an honest decision to me

Sarisbury Seagull · Nov 23, 2024

Skaville said:
I thought he was excellent when he came on, exactly what we needed. Read the game and won the ball on several occasions. It was the same against Spurs.

Agree totally. I’m confident he’s going to be a really good player for us.

One of those that we look back on early posts about him and take the piss out of the posters.

He’s a player.

Krafty · Nov 23, 2024

Brilliant result. It wasn't an excellent performance, but collecting another three points shows the amazing fighting spirit of this team. Our defending was great, Pedro and Mitoma were clinical and we also had a little bit of luck! Disappointing with Baleba, but I'm sure this team will achieve something special this season. UTA!

amexer · Nov 23, 2024

What no are we on MOD

PILTDOWN MAN · Nov 23, 2024

Normandy seagull said:
Key moment that. We need to learn better game management. Could have easily ended up another Wolves which wouldn’t have been deserved and gutting. Knew Baleba was getting send off after the first booking. He is still a bit naive. Needs to reign it in a little after a booking but that’s his game snd only other option is to sub off. Agree with the Weiffer comments. Pleased he did well after coming on after lots of stick including from me!

Baleba got sent off for the offence of being on a football pitch no other reason.

Seagull58 · Nov 23, 2024

LamieRobertson said:
I thought the first guy gets it more or less right

He said the same thing 25 times

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Bournemouth vs Brighton & Hove Albion *** Official Match Thread ***

Well-known member

Why oh why oh why?

Well-known member

Well-known member

Not awoke

Well-known member

Well-known member

Not awoke

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Solly March Fan Club

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

In the Algarve

Share this page

[Albion] Bournemouth vs Brighton & Hove Albion * Official Match Thread *