Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Bournemouth vs Brighton & Hove Albion *** Official Match Thread ***
- Thread starter Dick Head
- Start date
Well quite but I have to think there is much more to come.
Right Brain Ronnie
Well-known member
I hope so, but what do you think it could be.
Goals,assists, great tackler, great in the air. Honestly I don't understand why we bought him, how much is he on? More or less the Collen Rooney?
Normandy seagull
Well-known member
I agree it was a harsh yellow but you always run the risk on a yellow going in for a tackle from distance. Even if you catch the player even a tiny amount. We won so who cares, but 10 men could have cost us
I’ll reserve judgement for nowI hope so, but what do you think it could be.
Goals,assists, great tackler, great in the air. Honestly I don't understand why we bought him, how much is he on? More or less the Collen Rooney?
Normandy seagull
Well-known member
I agree but sadly you do have to legislate these days!
Is that an official appeal though or just a post match referees “media“ opinion?No, any second yellow can be reviewed but there's a fairly high bar for getting it overturned - one slam dunk is, as you say, mistaken identity.
Here's an example which wasn't overturned on appeal:
Premier League panel make 'unanimous' decision on Declan Rice's controversial red card
The Premier League's Independent Key Match Incidents Panel have given their verdict on Declan Rice's controversial red card against Brighton.search.app
Right Brain Ronnie
Well-known member
I can see the large, but maybe I have missed the other bits.
I have seen him get caught so many times and miss passes and get caught out of position. I really do hope he proves me wrong but he would not be on my bench......at home.
schmunk
Why oh why oh why?
It's an official appeal. Trossard's recent second yellow, also for kicking the ball away, was also unsuccessfully appealed.
I disagree with you. 'Harsh yellow' makes it sound like it was a foul by Baleba, but the yellow was questionable, but in my opinion it wasn't a foul by Baleba. He didn't go in for a tackle from a distance, he stayed on his feet and ran across while his opponent went to ground.
Delighted we won, but I feel we're getting too many bad decisions, and Baleba missing against Southampton could cost us more points.
- Nov 15, 2006
- 4,270
Yeah but that’s Arsenal, we are a two bob club, even less chance
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
I thought the first guy gets it more or less right
Normandy seagull
Well-known member
Agree to disagree then. Sorry it was a foul but not a booking. Look at it another way, he was always going to rack up 5 booking at some point. Southampton H not the worst game to miss!
warmleyseagull
Well-known member
Flip side of that is conceding too many from central positions.
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
Spec savers appointment for Attwell
most embarrassing moment of the weekend award goes to the Bournemouth player rolling around in apparent agony having not even been fouled by CB
most embarrassing moment of the weekend award goes to the Bournemouth player rolling around in apparent agony having not even been fouled by CB
Last edited:
Time will tell friend, but I'm confident.
PascalGroß Tips
Well-known member
- Jan 29, 2024
- 594
My understanding is that although this panel reviews key match in incidents, it’s not part of an appeals process. Meaning if they disagreed with the award of a second yellow, it wouldn’t negate it and the second yellow still stands. It’s all about feeding back following an assessment of decisions made by officials and VAR.No, any second yellow can be reviewed but there's a fairly high bar for getting it overturned - one slam dunk is, as you say, mistaken identity.
Here's an example which wasn't overturned on appeal:
Premier League panel make 'unanimous' decision on Declan Rice's controversial red card
The Premier League's Independent Key Match Incidents Panel have given their verdict on Declan Rice's controversial red card against Brighton.
So the link you’ve shared is not actually part of an appeal.
PascalGroß Tips
Well-known member
- Jan 29, 2024
- 594
PascalGroß Tips
Well-known member
- Jan 29, 2024
- 594
It’s NOT an appeals process … a panel reviews decisions made and feeds back. Nothing they decide will impact the original decision.