[Politics] The 2024 US Election - *MATCH DAY*

North Carolina Supporter said:

The real problem in America is that our primary process favors the extremes in both parties. This leaves a vacuum in the middle. There are no moderates to support. We used to have “Rockefeller Republicans” and “Blue Dog Democrats” that were fiscally to the right but more to the left on social issues. They are all but gone. Over half of Trump’s voters are not supporting him- they are voting against the left wing candidate. So many people “in the middle” are weary after years of inflation, porous borders, higher taxes, etc etc- they “hold their nose” and vote for Trump. I live in one of the few “purple states” - that reliably elects Democrats (blue states) and Republicans (red states) in the same election. I see cognitive dissonance on a daily basis… otherwise intelligent people “protesting” by voting against their own interests and/or ethics, morals, beliefs… it’s beyond comprehension. The untold story of this election is “how could a political party become so disengaged from the voters to lose to a convicted con man?” THAT needs to be honestly debated… without immediately falling into diatribes. It’s not the neo-nazi voters (all .000001%) it’s not the ignorant rednecks (10%) - it’s the 25% of the electorate that vote against the democrats no matter who is running. The left has absolutely enraged millions of educated Americans that are not nazis, racists, or dumb. It’s really worrisome how much anger is here in the US… sorry to ramble! Bourbon now safely in hand - cheers from North Carolina

Click to expand...

Johnson, McConnell call on Harris to tone down rhetoric​

North Carolina Supporter said:

The real problem in America is that our primary process favors the extremes in both parties. This leaves a vacuum in the middle. There are no moderates to support. We used to have “Rockefeller Republicans” and “Blue Dog Democrats” that were fiscally to the right but more to the left on social issues. They are all but gone. Over half of Trump’s voters are not supporting him- they are voting against the left wing candidate. So many people “in the middle” are weary after years of inflation, porous borders, higher taxes, etc etc- they “hold their nose” and vote for Trump. I live in one of the few “purple states” - that reliably elects Democrats (blue states) and Republicans (red states) in the same election. I see cognitive dissonance on a daily basis… otherwise intelligent people “protesting” by voting against their own interests and/or ethics, morals, beliefs… it’s beyond comprehension. The untold story of this election is “how could a political party become so disengaged from the voters to lose to a convicted con man?” THAT needs to be honestly debated… without immediately falling into diatribes. It’s not the neo-nazi voters (all .000001%) it’s not the ignorant rednecks (10%) - it’s the 25% of the electorate that vote against the democrats no matter who is running. The left has absolutely enraged millions of educated Americans that are not nazis, racists, or dumb. It’s really worrisome how much anger is here in the US… sorry to ramble! Bourbon now safely in hand - cheers from North Carolina

Click to expand...

Crawley Dingo said:

As none of you have been at all conciliatory, posting in bad faith or admitting errors there is F all chance that I am going to show any fealty even if you did have a credible case which you don't.

Go and pound sand.

Click to expand...

Deadly Danson said:

It's a great question and I'd be very interested in the answer. Murder? I think he's done virtually everything else already!

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

The real problem in America is that our primary process favors the extremes in both parties. This leaves a vacuum in the middle. There are no moderates to support. We used to have “Rockefeller Republicans” and “Blue Dog Democrats” that were fiscally to the right but more to the left on social issues. They are all but gone. Over half of Trump’s voters are not supporting him- they are voting against the left wing candidate. So many people “in the middle” are weary after years of inflation, porous borders, higher taxes, etc etc- they “hold their nose” and vote for Trump. I live in one of the few “purple states” - that reliably elects Democrats (blue states) and Republicans (red states) in the same election. I see cognitive dissonance on a daily basis… otherwise intelligent people “protesting” by voting against their own interests and/or ethics, morals, beliefs… it’s beyond comprehension. The untold story of this election is “how could a political party become so disengaged from the voters to lose to a convicted con man?” THAT needs to be honestly debated… without immediately falling into diatribes. It’s not the neo-nazi voters (all .000001%) it’s not the ignorant rednecks (10%) - it’s the 25% of the electorate that vote against the democrats no matter who is running. The left has absolutely enraged millions of educated Americans that are not nazis, racists, or dumb. It’s really worrisome how much anger is here in the US… sorry to ramble! Bourbon now safely in hand - cheers from North Carolina

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

The left has absolutely enraged millions of educated Americans that are not nazis, racists, or dumb. It’s really worrisome how much anger is here in the US

Click to expand...

Eeyore said:

I mean, I can fully understand why folk might vote Republican for Congress. But Trump as President ? Unfathomable.

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

The real problem in America is that our primary process favors the extremes in both parties. This leaves a vacuum in the middle. There are no moderates to support. We used to have “Rockefeller Republicans” and “Blue Dog Democrats” that were fiscally to the right but more to the left on social issues. They are all but gone. Over half of Trump’s voters are not supporting him- they are voting against the left wing candidate. So many people “in the middle” are weary after years of inflation, porous borders, higher taxes, etc etc- they “hold their nose” and vote for Trump. I live in one of the few “purple states” - that reliably elects Democrats (blue states) and Republicans (red states) in the same election. I see cognitive dissonance on a daily basis… otherwise intelligent people “protesting” by voting against their own interests and/or ethics, morals, beliefs… it’s beyond comprehension. The untold story of this election is “how could a political party become so disengaged from the voters to lose to a convicted con man?” THAT needs to be honestly debated… without immediately falling into diatribes. It’s not the neo-nazi voters (all .000001%) it’s not the ignorant rednecks (10%) - it’s the 25% of the electorate that vote against the democrats no matter who is running. The left has absolutely enraged millions of educated Americans that are not nazis, racists, or dumb. It’s really worrisome how much anger is here in the US… sorry to ramble! Bourbon now safely in hand - cheers from North Carolina

Click to expand...

Randy McNob said:

I think it's a brilliant move by the democrats which was planned from the beginning, a side step which has bamboozled the Trump camp.

Rather than 2 white old fogies who don't offer any real choice, now a younger, female woman of colour. Trump doesn't stand a chance

Click to expand...

Klaas said:

I'm sorry, but what is 'the left' of which you speak? Because when I hear Americans talk about marxists, communists and the far left, and then look at the democrat party, I think, 'Huh??'
Interested to hear also what it is that 'the left' has done to 'enrage' millions of people.

Click to expand...

Harry Wilson's tackle said:

It is a complete myth.

There was a half wit who used to post on here, now banned, who referred to anyone who fell outside his narrow circle as 'Trained Marxists' - a term he read on a fake news site.

That's what we are up against.

Click to expand...

Triggaaar said:

What did they do to enrage you so?

Click to expand...

Klaas said:

I'm sorry, but what is 'the left' of which you speak? Because when I hear Americans talk about marxists, communists and the far left, and then look at the democrat party, I think, 'Huh??'
Interested to hear also what it is that 'the left' has done to 'enrage' millions of people.

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

I am “the left” in America. I am trying to explain to (mostly) British- how Trump could possibly win the presidency. It is due to the fact that the majority of moderates have voted against Kamala Harris. NOT in favor of Trump- but against the Democratic policies. The surprising factor to observers like me- 40 years of voting- is the animosity that many “in the middle” have for the Democrats. their hatred of certain left-wing policies has overcome their own personal ethics and morals - they will vote for a spray-tan con man over a law abiding former prosecutor… bot because they like Trump- but because they hate the policies that Kamala Harris will enact or protect. It’s delusional- on a massive scale, but that is what is happening to the former “moderate republicans” and “conservative democrats” … this shift is not being covered by the US press

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

In the US, the “left” is oversimplified to mean anyone who is a Democrat. Anyone who believes in progressive tax policies, global warming, gun control, equal pay for equal work, more abortion access, etc.

The “far left” are the fringe parties in the US- Green and Socialists - maybe 2% of the voters combined. (The grand total of Marxist and communists in the US is a fraction of a fraction.)

The Right is anyone who reliably votes Republican. They want lower taxes first and foremost, more military spending is next, Second Amendment protection, closed borders to immigration, less environmental rules, more restrictions on abortions, etc.

30 years ago, the US was nearly equally divided- 1/3rd liberal or “left” 1/3rd moderate or middle and 1/3rd conservative or “right” … that has all changed. The extremes on the right and left have taken over - the moderates have lost nearly every primary. The middle has no one to represent us.

My point is that Trump is winning over more of the middle than anyone anticipated… and the reason for this is NOT because they like Trump. The reason is that many moderates have grown weary of the left. My point is this- half of Trump’s support is really just people who are protesting the other side- not supporting Trump. They don’t like him- they just want to show their anger at the left for the open borders, higher taxes, bigger government, etc. Trump found an audience with these divisive issues… it’s the great chasm in America. trump has been successful at dividing the country because he thinks he can get 51% of the vote … sadly, this is what is happening… I fear his strategy is working.

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

I am “the left” in America.

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

I am trying to explain to (mostly) British- how Trump could possibly win the presidency. It is due to the fact that the majority of moderates have voted against Kamala Harris. NOT in favor of Trump- but against the Democratic policies. The surprising factor to observers like me- 40 years of voting- is the animosity that many “in the middle” have for the Democrats. their hatred of certain left-wing policies has overcome their own personal ethics and morals - they will vote for a spray-tan con man over a law abiding former prosecutor… bot because they like Trump- but because they hate the policies that Kamala Harris will enact or protect. It’s delusional- on a massive scale, but that is what is happening to the former “moderate republicans” and “conservative democrats” … this shift is not being covered by the US press

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

They don’t like him- they just want to show their anger at the left for the open borders, higher taxes, bigger government, etc.

Click to expand...

North Carolina Supporter said:

I am “the left” in America. I am trying to explain to (mostly) British- how Trump could possibly win the presidency. It is due to the fact that the majority of moderates have voted against Kamala Harris. NOT in favor of Trump- but against the Democratic policies. The surprising factor to observers like me- 40 years of voting- is the animosity that many “in the middle” have for the Democrats. their hatred of certain left-wing policies has overcome their own personal ethics and morals - they will vote for a spray-tan con man over a law abiding former prosecutor… bot because they like Trump- but because they hate the policies that Kamala Harris will enact or protect. It’s delusional- on a massive scale, but that is what is happening to the former “moderate republicans” and “conservative democrats” … this shift is not being covered by the US press

Click to expand...

To win, Harris should talk more about working-class needs and less about Trump | Dustin Guastella

Our polling shows that the best way to defeat Trump is offer a compelling economic platform that puts working families first

www.theguardian.com

Albion my Albion said:

Johnson, McConnell call on Harris to tone down rhetoric​

Click to expand...

Zeberdi said:

I wouldn’t bother. NSC doesn’t do nuance well. All to quick to polarise a debate.

The NYT article I posted above reflects the points you are making well.

My Aunty and Uncle who live in Michigan are lifelong ‘conservative’ Democrats - they feel much as you do (but at least hate Trump even more although that is because as Jews, they fear the repercussions of white supremacy gaining foothold in main stream politics.)

( From the article I posted above) Political analysts say the Republicans and Democrats ”have prioritized the wishes of their most intensely devoted voters — who would never vote for the other party — over the priorities of winnable voters who could go either way.” Both parties “treat narrow victories like landslides and wave away narrow defeats, somehow seeing both as confirmation of their existing strategies.”

The Democrats are leaving a growing working class demographic behind in this election - they don’t want to hear about Trump’s threat to democracy, about Trump centralising power or Trump’s sexual proclivities - they want to know how a Harris administration would improve their economic outlook:

“Among blue-collar voters, a group that leans Republican, the democratic threat message was a whopping 14.4 points underwater relative to the average support for Trump’s messages. And among more liberal-leaning service and clerical workers, it was also the least popular message, finishing only 1.6 percentage points ahead of the Trump average. Even among professionals, the most liberal of the bunch and the group that liked the message the best, the message barely outperformed Trump’s messages.”

“Among independents – an imperfect proxy for nonpartisan voters – the strong populist message was best received, while the democratic threat message was least favored. Only Democrats strongly preferred the democratic threat message, and even then it was among their least favorite.

All of this suggests that the messaging pivot is a big mistake.”

If Harris loses, [and I am seriously now thinking she certainly might] the Guardian writer, Dustin Guastella, says it’ll be because the campaign and the candidate represent a party that is now fundamentally alien to many working people – a party that has given up on mobilizing working people around shared class frustrations and aspirations. A party incapable of communicating a simple, direct, progressive economic policy agenda. A party so beholden to a contradictory mix of interests that, in the effort to appease everyone and offend no one, top strategists have rolled out a vague, unpopular and uninspiring pitch seemingly designed to help them replay the results of the 2016 election.”

To win, Harris should talk more about working-class needs and less about Trump | Dustin Guastella

Our polling shows that the best way to defeat Trump is offer a compelling economic platform that puts working families first

www.theguardian.com

I am resigned to Trump winning this election now - he is an unstoppable force simply because he is making the most noise to a moderate working class swing electorate who are responding to his populist messaging; who want to know how the next leader of the US will reenergise the car and steel industry, end offshoring of American manufacturing to put jobs back on the table and who puts American working families first.

Click to expand...