I think perhaps some of those people should stop talking. Sensitive transfer dealings shouldn't be openly talked about and released.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Napoli interested in Billy Gilmour **Sold 30/08/24**
- Thread starter Bozza
- Start date
I think perhaps some of those people should stop talking. Sensitive transfer dealings shouldn't be openly talked about and released.
Lenny Rider
Well-known member
- Sep 15, 2010
- 5,991
StonehamPark
#Brighton-Nil
A real shame.
It would be nice to retain top Scottish representation at the Albion. Especially someone so talented as BG.
Forster's Armband
Well-known member
With the injuries and lack of experience in CM with out MW and MOR it's worrying letting him go with out something to fill the gap for a bit.
Two months ago Bozza and GB were both claiming to be ITK in two posts posted exactly after each other in the same thread. One of them claimed the ITK info said Solly March's rehab was going great and he could be back as early as October. The other said it was a 50/50 risk March would never play in the Premier League again. I was supposed to believe in both that things were going great and that there was a 50% chance of him never playing at this level again, or I was an idiot.
In this case with Billy, Bozza clearly doesn't rate the player from the beginning, spends some time arguing with me on whether he is good enough or not, and shortly after a medical is reported he says "I'm ITK and know the club don't want him".
But... what can I say? He's the boss and he's claiming to be ITK so anything I say is invalid.
Very, very strange and risky behaviour starting him this Saturday if the club was really that desperate to get rid off him. But good luck to him, will follow his adventures in Naples.
- Nov 15, 2006
- 4,229
I do not like what Bozza is saying and I know he’s not much of a WBG fan but I doubt he’s claiming to be ITK and categorically stating that the club don’t want to keep him because of his opinion about WBG.
I now expect him to be gone by midnight tonight
Machiavelli
Well-known member
And Baleba
Lenny Rider
Well-known member
- Sep 15, 2010
- 5,991
Full disclosure, Billy lives, or sadly lived, in my road in Worthing, earlier this week I met his parents out in the street, at that point, ie Tuesday morning, he had never indicated he wanted to leave the club, the complete opposite, with a potential World Cup with Scotland in two years time, two exciting seasons in the EPL with the Albion was top of the agenda.
Unfortunately it appears he’s surplus to requirements, but frankly the transfer fee is way under what it should have been when you look at what players of similar age and ability go for.
Unfortunately it appears he’s surplus to requirements, but frankly the transfer fee is way under what it should have been when you look at what players of similar age and ability go for.
Weststander
Well-known member
Doom and gloom merchants palpably reveling on any news of an injury or two.
Garry Nelson's Left Foot
Well-known member
Is that a the club don't want him in an active way? I.e they're actively pushing the sale,or;
He's surplus to the managers requirements so the club are happy to sell?
Tom Hark Preston Park
Will Post For Cash
- Jul 6, 2003
- 72,275
It's the Albion's loss, bigtime. Will be watching with great interest this season as WBG threads some delicious passes through for Lukaku to run on to. At least Scotland recognise WBG's true worthFull disclosure, Billy lives, or sadly lived, in my road in Worthing, earlier this week I met his parents out in the street, at that point, ie Tuesday morning, he had never indicated he wanted to leave the club, the complete opposite, with a potential World Cup with Scotland in two years time, two exciting seasons in the EPL with the Albion was top of the agenda.
Unfortunately it appears he’s surplus to requirements, but frankly the transfer fee is way under what it should have been when you look at what players of similar age and ability go for.
- Thread starter
- #1,373
That's not quite the case.
I think it's probably fair to say I don't rate him as highly as you, certainly, but that's not to say I don't rate him at all.
He did a great job last season stepping into the massive void left by Caiecedo and Mac Allister - probably the finest midfield duo the club has ever had.
However, if we do entertain genuine ambitions to reach Europe again, I do feel we need more in our central midfield than Billy Gilmour currently offers. I wouldn't look to offload him though - I think he'd be a fine squad player. Of course, I expect Gilmour wants more than that.
Whilst not believing that BG is a £50m+ player, I would have put his value somewhat higher than we seem to be selling at.
And I am genuinely surprised that no Premier League clubs have been mentioned as having an interest in him.
As others have said - there's a whole lot of weirdness around this likely-looking transfer.
Full disclosure, Billy lives, or sadly lived, in my road in Worthing, earlier this week I met his parents out in the street, at that point, ie Tuesday morning, he had never indicated he wanted to leave the club, the complete opposite, with a potential World Cup with Scotland in two years time, two exciting seasons in the EPL with the Albion was top of the agenda.
Unfortunately it appears he’s surplus to requirements, but frankly the transfer fee is way under what it should have been when you look at what players of similar age and ability go for.
Well this is obviously not true. We are never getting to a World Cup
It’s tough, but I suspect we’re getting the highest fee we could this window having left his departure to the last day of the window and played him in two EPL games because Napoli were low balling us.Full disclosure, Billy lives, or sadly lived, in my road in Worthing, earlier this week I met his parents out in the street, at that point, ie Tuesday morning, he had never indicated he wanted to leave the club, the complete opposite, with a potential World Cup with Scotland in two years time, two exciting seasons in the EPL with the Albion was top of the agenda.
Unfortunately it appears he’s surplus to requirements, but frankly the transfer fee is way under what it should have been when you look at what players of similar age and ability go for.
If he had the value that half of NSC seem to think he does, we’d have Russell from Stains, Oli from Palace and Kieran from Ipswich breaking down our door for a deal. They are not.
Your man Potter had a real disinterest in wingers and fullbacks. He’d stick Webster or Burn at full back and Moder or Groß on the wing. I think the same is true of Hürzeler and central midfielders. Unless you are going to get tons of goals and assists or be able to fit inbetween the centre backs and successfully mark the likes of Everton’s Dominic Calvin-Lewin, I don’t think FH is interested. We just need to adjust to his tactics which don’t include a need for players with the profile of WBG.
Last edited:
Weststander
Well-known member
£11.8m fee.
Gilmour Fan
Member
- Jan 15, 2024
- 15
Full disclosure, Billy lives, or sadly lived, in my road in Worthing, earlier this week I met his parents out in the street, at that point, ie Tuesday morning, he had never indicated he wanted to leave the club, the complete opposite, with a potential World Cup with Scotland in two years time, two exciting seasons in the EPL with the Albion was top of the agenda.
Unfortunately it appears he’s surplus to requirements, but frankly the transfer fee is way under what it should have been when you look at what players of similar age and ability go for.
That's very sad if that's the case he is being pushed out against his will. Do you mean his parents said he was surplus to requirements or do you just mean that must be the case if the transfer goes through?
I still can't understand why you would start a player in a match and risk injury if you were desperate to sell them?
Ali_rrr
Well-known member
Think that nails 90% of Albion fans' views.
Weststander
Well-known member
2 ….. JPVH by a country mile.
Take a look over the Ferdi thread.
You panicked and started a thread about a random Spaniard. I said no need for an alternative not only then but way before.
I can bounce them later but I suspect you’ve got them in Excel already.