- Oct 17, 2008
- 14,359
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Music] The Stone Roses or Oasis?
- Thread starter Peacehaven Wild Kids
- Start date
Silverhatch
Well-known member
No need to choose; both seminal sublime British acts
jakarta
Well-known member
The Roses for their debut album, the rest can largely be forgotten.
Oasis not in the same league
Oasis not in the same league
CliveWalkerWingWizard
Well-known member
Did she live in Havelock rd?I used to see a girl whose sister (Emily) was a long-standing girlfriend of Mr. Gillespie.
We were invited to go as his guests to Glasto (possibly '94?) but I bottled it, due to his reputation for huge consumption of 'things'.
I've always regretted that decision.
No idea about where Emily lived...or played.
The Stone Oasis
Arthur
Well-known member
Why? The entire tour sold out.Oh no, how embarrassing
I hope refunds were given!
I saw him at Brixton that tour and it was a cracking night.
HangletonGull
Well-known member
- Apr 10, 2023
- 2,281
Grew up with stone roses
bluenitsuj
Listen to me!!!
The Roses.
Mani's 4005 bass 
THe bands are in no way comporable IMO
Oasis efforts to be the beatles came out more like Freddy and the dreamers.
THe bands are in no way comporable IMO
Oasis efforts to be the beatles came out more like Freddy and the dreamers.
herecomesaregular
We're in the pipe, 5 by 5
Roses much more seminal body of work.
Oasis a good sing-song football band.
Both singers tireless knobheads and both dreadful live.
Both bands, back in the day, seemed to have fans I fecking hated at 6th form and Uni, making their music hard to listen to.
Did enjoy Oasis at Glasto '95 though tbf!
Oasis a good sing-song football band.
Both singers tireless knobheads and both dreadful live.
Both bands, back in the day, seemed to have fans I fecking hated at 6th form and Uni, making their music hard to listen to.
Did enjoy Oasis at Glasto '95 though tbf!
boik
Well-known member
Not a fan of either particularly, but it seems to me that The Roses had much more variety. Every Oasis song is the same dirgy speed (haven't checked BPMs but i bet they're all close), the same guitar sound, the same whiney vocals. I get that its probably great to sing long to in a crowd when you're pissed, by my god is it boring to listen to for any period of time.
SeagullinExile
Well-known member
Oasis - Quoasis more like. Liam Gallagher is an Ian Brown clone. Oasis were just a mainstream pop band, riding on the coat tales of the Manchester scene. Nothing more in my opinion.
Seagull58
In the Algarve
Influenced by The Beach Boys?
Crispy Ambulance
Well-known member
Yeah, my favourite one of theirs.
Seagull58
In the Algarve
Mine too.
