X Factor

[bristolseagull]

f*** me that song from Sheryl Cole was IMMENSE !.

Credit where its due she was very good and the routine was meticulous.

oh do f*** off! yep, the routine was good but the song was dreadful. she cant sing for toffee.

painful.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Can't agree at all with that doug I thought the song was superb.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Very odd reaction I must have been listening to something else as I loved the song. Ok she is no Leona but she held a tune pretty well. Much better than I thought she would be.

 

[bristolseagull]

She was awful. Even worse than the record.

agreed. a joke. you could see Simon want to slate her singing but didnt have the balls...

 

[Stu1]

Did they say cheryl was number 1?

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Ah well I liked it.

 

[Brighton M]

Thought she did quite well to be honest.

 

[Tooting Gull]

It was part-mimed, and with the aid of a backing track. So it wasn't 'all live' at all. The only reason it wasn't recorded in advance was because of all the complaints. Considering she is judging people for singing live, it's poor. If you're that embarrassed at being shown up by the contestants (rightly), resign the judging position.

 

[sam86]

Really wanted to make it back in time for Cole's song, but missed it. Girlfriend said it was awful.

 

[The Wizard]

Ah well I liked it.

I agree.

First time she's ever sung live on stage by herself, I like the tune as well, not the greatest voice but very brave and when you consider her to last weeks Alexandre Burke who mimed, I prefer Cheryl's performance just because she didn't mime and had the guts to sing live.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Girls would say that wouldn't they.

Here it is a very decent pop song in my book.

YouTube - Cheryl Cole - Fight For This Love

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

It was part-mimed, and with the aid of a backing track. So it wasn't 'all live' at all. The only reason it wasn't recorded in advance was because of all the complaints. Considering she is judging people for singing live, it's poor. If you're that embarrassed at being shown up by the contestants (rightly), resign the judging position.

I think the fact she is part of the most successful female pop group of all time in the UK gives her some credibility and rationale to comment don't you think ?.

 

[mistahclarke]

I agree.

First time she's ever sung live on stage by herself, I like the tune as well, not the greatest voice but very brave and when you consider her to last weeks Alexandre Burke who mimed, I prefer Cheryl's performance just because she didn't mime and had the guts to sing live.

even though it sounds incredibly similar to Kellis' "Little Star" and she was blantantly wearing something Kandi Rain rejected when she slagged them off for looking too tarty?

She's not in Whitney's league.

 

[dougdeep]

Did they say cheryl was number 1?

No.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

QUOTE=The Wizard;3171147]I agree.

First time she's ever sung live on stage by herself, I like the tune as well, not the greatest voice but very brave and when you consider her to last weeks Alexandre Burke who mimed, I prefer Cheryl's performance just because she didn't mime and had the guts to sing live.[/QUOTE]

Wizard do you realise we have agreed TWICE now in the last 24 hours. What the f*** is going on ?.

 

[matildaseagull]

Cheryl was crap but I'd still rather listen to her than Shitney Houston. Now she is bland in the extreme.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

No.

Next Sunday. Its a bit difficult to be No 1 when the record isn't released until tomorrow.

 

[The Wizard]

Good performance from Whitney here, disappointed she only sung some parts live but nevertheless a great performance.

 

[Walkers Cajun Squirrel]

I didn't think she was that bad. First live solo performance. I liked it.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Dermot is a SHORT f*** isn't he.