X Factor, Diana's Claw

[Icy Gull]

I think TRHK and all the other NSC Diana haters have been posting on this site

X Factor: Diana's 'claw' - love it or hate it? | TV Blog - Yahoo! TV UK

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

She is utter rubbish. The only one with talent is Alexandra we all know that but I can tell you now the Irish Leprachaun is going to win and he will be the weakest ever winner of any of these shows.

 

[Trufflehound]

"There be bunny herbs"

 

[strings]

I still think she hasn't recovered from her throat problems. I thought she was amazing in disco week when she did a blondie song. If she can recover that form for the last couple of weeks she may well be in with a decent chance.

Eggnog to go this week.

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

You spotted that I'm not a fan? What gave me away.

[yt]yBvlwkHOxCQ[/yt]

And why can't she move at all? I don't think they should be able to dance, but does she have some kind of disability we aren't being told about?

Just seen her version of "Call Me" on You Tube.....it's f***ing horrible.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

4th - JLS
3rd - Kenneth Williams
2nd - Alexandra
1st - Leprachaun

 

[bobbab5]

Oooooh booooy!!!
that's one shitty voice.

 

[Brighton till i die]

she is f***ing awesome - and FIT.

i think she will win, with Alex 2nd.

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

Awesome is indeed one word that does apply to her, but perhaps not in the way that you mean it.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

She has a whiney voice, very irratating and is a scrawny spotty bint. I see dozens of more attractive women walking around every day.

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

US - you have missed this debate whilst in hibernation and you're covering old ground. I can save you about thirty posts by telling you how it will pan out:

- you will make a lot of valid observations about how average looking she is (at best), how her voice is shockingly bad, how she has straw like hair, how she has little or no discernible personality, how she is not "unique" in any way, and how there are dozens of more able and relevant female singers plying their trade sub-charts in the UK.
- a gang of her fans will come on and tell you you are wrong and that they think she is really fit and how they love her "uniqueness"
- no one will ever agree.

 

[m20gull]

And why can't she move at all?

She can move. She has a sort of tin-solider step standing on the spot and has used it in every song I've seen. But that's it.

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

Good point - I was just being unkind wasn't I. I had the movement (I wouldn't go as far as to call it dancing) down as being like a horse scraping at the ground. But tin soldier works.

 

[clippedgull]

- no one will ever agree.

Summed up in five words!

People hate Leona Lewis but love Gun's n Roses, and vice versa!

Some will hate both!

What a boring world if everybody agreed, all the time!

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

Totally right Clippedgull - but what seems to set this argument apart from some others is that neither side seem to be able to see ANY of the points being made by the other. That makes it interesting.

 

[Hiney]

Diana is a MESS

Alexandra is by far the best singer of those that are left.

Diana or Ogwen should go this week

 

[footychick]

I hate her claw and I hate her - there, I've said it.

 

[Perry Milkins]

Summed up in five words!

People hate Leona Lewis but love Gun's n Roses, and vice versa!

Some will hate both!

What a boring world if everybody agreed, all the time!

What we can have a usedful debate about is that the competetion is now seriously flawed for two reasons.

1. Parochial voting. Hence that snivelling little grovelly turkey expressioned irish laddie is still in the competition.

2. Cowell and Walsh are choosing their words carefully to influence voting.

 

[Dr Q]

Is she irish, she sounds, or is trying to sound like the lass from the Cranberries?
Dire really!

 

[adrian29uk]

She is bloody annoying. We have seen this all before. What's with the prentending to be stoned performances, and no shoes. Her voice is dreadful.

I only watch it to see people fail. I'm not a cruel person, these people need to be bought back down from planet X Factor and think about facing up to going out to work like the rest of us.

The only ones laughing out of all this is Mr Cowell and the judges.